Vacation rentals in Mayville

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Mayville

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Elkhart Lake

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 294 reviews

Elkhart A-Frame, Wooded Retreat near Road America

The Elkhart A-Frame is an ideal location for the adventure seeker who wants a unique and private experience that is still close to all the action. The home sits on a wooded three-acre private retreat only about a mile from the village of Elkhart Lake, Road America, and Golf Courses. This unique cabin was built in the 1970's but has been recently renovated with a fun Scandinavian modern flair. It has all the amenities for a memorable vacation stay that provides plenty of epic photo opportunities.

Superhost

A red kayak rests on the green lawn, positioned near the lakefront rental home. The home features a spacious outdoor patio with seating, framed by trees, and offers a relaxed setting for enjoying the natural surroundings.

Home in Juneau

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

Take a Break at Lakeside Acres

Lakeside Acres; a 2-bedroom, 1 bath vacation rental home located on beautiful Lake Sinissippi. Open concept living area with furnished patio and private dock. This newly updated home provides the perfect summer getaway or winter retreat for family and friends. Whether you spend your days kayaking with the complimentary kayaks, exploring Horicon Marsh, or soaking up the sun on the dock, you're sure to have an unforgettable stay in this lakefront hideaway. Note: Docks are not in the lake Nov-Apr.

Guest favorite

A bright living area showcases a comfortable seating arrangement with decorative cushions. Potted plants add greenery, and light streams in through the large windows. Artwork adorns the walls, while a mix of textures is provided by the rugs and furnishings.

Apartment in Bay View

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 350 reviews

Bay View MKE Hideaway - with Parking!

Cozy, inviting, one bedroom apartment in the heart of Bayview, literally steps away from some of Milwaukee's best restaurants, bars and shops! One of two Airbnb guest spaces in our house, this downstairs apartment is our home base when we're in Milwaukee, and we love sharing it with guests when we’re on the road! We are within five minutes of Summerfest grounds and East Side & Historic Third Ward districts, and within 10 minutes of the airport, downtown, Marquette University, and Miller Park.

Top guest favorite

A cozy seating area features a brown leather couch adorned with a floral accent pillow. Two wooden side tables with lamps flank the couch, while a round wooden coffee table with a decorative lace centerpiece occupies the center, set against a rustic wall.

Apartment in Watertown

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 260 reviews

The Ernest Inn - Located downtown Watertown

Welcome to the perfect "home" away from home. This apartment is located in a historical building in the heart of downtown Watertown right on Main Street. This apartment features a complete kitchen, a working typewriter, a record player, a collection of classic vinyl, wifi, a smart tv, a brand new stone tile bathroom, and a back porch to relax and take in the sounds of downtown. This apartment is perfect for just one or two but can accommodate up to 6 guests. Licensed, insured, and inspected.

Guest favorite

The historic home, designed in a Queen Anne Victorian style, features a white exterior with intricate woodwork. Large windows reflect soft evening light, while a spacious porch offers a welcoming entry. The surrounding yard is open, with mature trees that provide shade and a natural ambiance.

Home in Wales

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Charming, Updated and Historic

This is truly a memorable, charming, and welcoming place to stay. You will have the home to yourself. You will love the warm feel, woodwork, and historical prominence of this home. It is very charming throughout and is on a large 1.5-acre estate size lot. The price quoted here is for 1-2 people and a 1 Bedroom suite with 1.5 Baths. Under this listing we can open up to three suites and accept six guests. If need more there than 2 guests and 1 suite we are happy to make you a custom offer.

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Cascade

5 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

hot tub and sauna on 5 private acres

Need a peaceful retreat? Experience 5 acres of tranquil, private woodland paradise. Cool nights are perfect for warming up in the hot tub or infrared sauna which overlook the meadow. Explore hiking trails and lakes that the scenic Kettle Moraine has to offer. Grill a delicious meal and later craft perfect s’mores by campfire as the crickets sing. Unwind at SoLu winery, just a minute down the road. Near Road America, Kettle Moraine State Forest, and Dundee. Your inspired getaway awaits!

Top guest favorite

A historic stone home is presented, featuring multiple windows that enhance its classic appeal. A well-maintained garden with colorful flowers surrounds the exterior, creating a welcoming entrance to the Butler Place. A sign displaying the property's name is held by two guests in front of the house.

Guest suite in Sussex

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 303 reviews

The Loft @ The Butler Place. 1846 homestead.

The Loft at the Butler Place is a beautiful, quiet retreat set in the rural suburb of Sussex, just 30 minutes west of Milwaukee. The home is the 1846 homestead of the William Butler family, making the home older than the State of Wisconsin! The 2019 remodel of the Loft is in sophisticated farmhouse style and pays tribute to the history of the home in its furnishings, up cycled pieces, and beautiful setting. "Broken becomes blessed" both tells and compells as an invitation to all.

Top guest favorite

A historic stone building with arched windows is surrounded by well-maintained lawns and mature trees. A small shed is visible near the garden area, adding to the outdoor space's charm. Bright green grass and seasonal foliage contribute to the serene setting.

Home in Campbellsport

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 189 reviews

Gleason's Chouse

You'll love staying in our unique home, in a quiet neighborhood. This is a recently remodeled 1867 church converted to a "Chouse". Featuring 2 bedrooms, Full Kitchen, 1 Bathroom, Balcony, Parking, and a Gazebo.. all beautifully complimented by a range of antiques and decorations. 8 Miles East of Hwy 41, a 45 min drive to Oshkosh or an hour to Milwaukee. Just down the from Lake Bernice & Eisenbahn Bike Trail. Also close enough to the Kettle Moraine Forest to hike and sightsee!

Top guest favorite

A red door with a decorative wreath opens to a outdoor patio area, featuring a comfortable seating arrangement and potted flowers. Lush greenery surrounds the space, enhancing the connection to nature, with a glimpse of the lake in the background.

Cabin in Fox Lake

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 203 reviews

Cabin on the Trail

Kick back and relax in this cozy space with up north, cabin vibes. In the summer months enjoy the excellent fishing, swimming and boating and in the winter have fun ice fishing on beautiful Fox Lake! *Please read the full description and look at all of the pictures of the property *Not suitable for parties or loud gatherings. Please note, there is a 4 person maximum, including children. *All dogs/pets must be pre-approved by the host. There is a $50 pet fee/stay.

Guest favorite

A charming cottage is located near the water's edge, framed by lush green grass and a few trees. Outdoor equipment, including kayaks and a table setup for dining, adds convenience for guests. The exterior is painted in a soft blue, enhancing its inviting appearance.

Cottage in Hustisford

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Charming and Cozy Cottage on Lake Sinissippi!

Pine Shore Retreat is a charming cottage so close to the lake that you feel like you are in a houseboat! The east side location means you have fabulous sunset views, as well as swimmable, hard bottom frontage off the platform pier. It is a small space, just one bedroom, but very cozy. Comfort is the focus, with new, high-end furnishings. The stainless steel refrigerator, granite countertops and a gas range in the kitchen offer a higher end experience.

Top guest favorite

A rustic living area is highlighted by exposed log walls and hardwood floors. A stone fireplace is centered against one wall, while a comfortable plaid sofa faces a wooden coffee table. A dining table is set for meals, featuring simple floral decor.

Farm stay in West Bend

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 223 reviews

Family friendly farmstay just outside Milwaukee

The Inn at Paradise Farm is an original 1847 log homestead in rural Wisconsin just a short drive from Milwaukee and close to many attractions, especially for nature lovers. Our very spacious private 4-room suite with private entrance is comfortable for couples, families, or business travelers who long to unwind in a pastoral setting. Visit with, and even help care for, our friendly animals! We are licensed and inspected. Paradise Farm welcomes all.

Top guest favorite

A relaxing living area features a stone fireplace as its focal point. Comfortable seating options, including a leather chair and a spacious sofa, are arranged around a rustic coffee table. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, with glimpses of the surrounding scenery.

Cottage in Fond du Lac

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 287 reviews

Beautiful Lake Home.

Our Beautiful two bedroom cottage is located on the shores of Lake Winnebago . Centrally located to many of Wisconsin's best attractions. Less than 1 hour from Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, Close to Oshkosh (EAA) and Elkhart Lake. Includes 2 bedrooms, with plush queen beds, 1 full bathroom, Laundry room with washer and dryer. The perfect home for a laid back group of friends, couples or a family to stay with all the comforts of being at home.