Vacation rentals in Paoli

#302 Private Apartment in Historic McFarland House

*** Our 2nd Floor is being remodeled throughout 2025 adding 4 more units to the old McFarland House This newly remodeled unit is located in the attic of the Historic McFarland House, built in 1856 in the community that bears its name. Nestled in our small suburban downtown, this unit is perfect for travelers visiting the Madison area or nomads making a pit stop in the mid-west. Only 8mi to campus or a quick commute to the capitol, McFarland is an easy exit off multiple highways and interstates.

Mill House Retreat

The Mill House Retreat is a 2 story loft set in a park like setting next to the Sugar River. Built in 1864, this stone grist mill has soaring 15ft ceilings, original fittings and luxurious finishes. You will be greeted by chesterfield sofas, a large bar, a copper tub and comfortable beds. Just minutes to bike trails, live music, restaurants, and bars. Guests are welcome to have local friends over to enjoy the setting and reminisce. Madison, New Glarus and Epic are just minutes away.

Entire Lower Level, Countryside Garden Suite

Welcome to our home! We have upgraded our Garden (lower) Level to host travelers much like ourselves and long-term guests. The view of our backyard is incredible! You will find yourself lost in the country, yet less than ten minutes from all the excitement that Madison has to offer. Along with a private drive and entrance, you will have 1,000 square feet of comfort all to yourselves. This property is perfect for a quiet getaway we all need from time to time. All designed with you in mind.

Cool, Roomy, Scenic Country Art Studio

Creative souls love my marvelous studio retreat, a delightful one-room loft-style space featuring tall ceilings, an entire wall of sliding glass doors, kitchenette, piano, and an expansive view of a picturesque barn, pasture, and wooded hills. This amazing, heated, spacious country getaway has no plumbing— it's just a few steps across the yard to the main house guest bathroom. Come create, relax, and renew here! Well-behaved dogs, included in your reservation, must be leashed when outside.

Loft 3 - On The Historic Monroe Square

Loft 3 is 40 steps (2 flights of stairs) above the Monroe Square. It's a climb, but the view is totally worth it! Newly remodeled in 2021, and reminiscent of the 1859 character of the building, this space is cute, cozy, and truly one of a kind. Literally a couple steps away from your entryway is Sunrise Donut Cafe, featuring customized donuts and a full menu of excellent coffee items. From there, explore the rest of the Square for food, drinks, and shopping in a quaint Main Street atmosphere.

ONE OF A KIND vacation rental with a view

Arbor Hill House - Unique A-frame vacation rental perched atop a hill with great views overlooking the Beltline, UW Arboretum and the city of Madison. Excellent central location with easy access to all of Madison and surrounding areas. I'll be happy to do whatever I can to make your stay a pleasant one. Please keep things clean and be respectful. The home should not be used for parties or events. If you have any questions please feel free to ask. I look forward to sharing my home with you.

Downtown Apt - Steps to Coffee & Sushi!

* Be sure to check out our winter extended stay discounts for 3+ nights! * Welcome to historic downtown Oregon! Step into the past while enjoying modern comfort in this beautiful space, which once housed our 1st library! Just steps away from locally owned coffee and gift shops, a wine reserve, and amazing restaurants! With convenient access to Madison (14 mi), experience the best of both worlds – small-town tranquility and urban excitement. Whether for work or leisure, welcome home!

Quiet sunlit studio near vibrant downtown

This architect-designed studio is bathed in natural light, with skylights and a breakfast nook with a wrap-around window. Featuring an upscale bathroom with a walk-in shower, this comfortable space has all the amenities perfect for a quick weekend getaway or a week-long business trip. The studio adjoins a house and is up a flight of stairs through a separate outdoor entrance. Located just up the hill—a 5-minute walk—to Downtown Middleton and a 15-minute drive to UW and Downtown Madison.

The Hideout In Downtown New Glarus

Modern 1 bedroom with a spacious outdoor deck on the second floor of the historic Citizen's Bank building built in 1910. Located above a retail space in the heart of downtown New Glarus. You'll be steps away from restaurants, pubs, shops, park, a bike path, and festivals. This newly remodeled apartment has beautiful quartz countertop & island, and original wood floors. Newly installed large windows allow for ample natural light. Check out The Hideaway if you need a 2 bedroom rental.

Nördlich Chalet - Trail-side, 1 Bdrm in New Glarus

Enjoy access to all that America's Little Switzerland has to offer! This one bdrm chalet apartment offers a bright spacious living area w/ kitchenette, bedroom and bath, and balcony. Set just off of the highway and next to the biking and snowmobile trails and within walking distance to downtown New Glarus shopping, bars, restaurants, festivals and more, this is the spot to be! Check out Bailey's Run Winery or the New Glarus Brewery and New Glarus Woods State Park, just up the trail!

Comfortable Madison Area Retreat In The Trees

Tri-level duplex centrally located in Fitchburg. Nestled in a quiet residential neighborhood backing up to a small patch of woods for privacy. Feel away from it all with the sights and sounds of nature yet close to all the modern conveniences. Enjoy separated living spaces, a fully equipped kitchen (per WI health code, edable cooking supplies, are not allowed–we do provide untamperable salt and pepper), 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, fully stocked laundry room and attached garage!

Cozy Cabin on Decatur Lake

Relax in this cozy cabin on the lake. Fish, hike or even swim (after a short canoe/kayak paddle); just like being Up-North without the drive! Use our canoe or kayaks or bring your own. Cook indoors or out. Near Sugar River Trailhead, Headgates Park and Three Waters Reserve. A few miles away from tubing on the Sugar River. An hour from Madison and 30 minutes from Beloit, Monroe or Janesville. Previously listed by Betty and under her same great management!