Monthly Rentals in Fairy Island

We enjoyed our stay here very much! It had everything we needed and was just as described. We were grateful for the earlier check in time as well. It was a bit warm inside (with A/C and a fan) but it was 94° outside so we were understanding. Parking was convenient and location was great! Would definitely recommend.

As another reviewer has written, I was so tempted to 'gatekeep' this magnificent property all to myself, because it was just that spectacular - but Suzanne and Charlie deserve every kudo for what they have created, so here I go..... I have never felt more at home in an Air B&B. This home has been so lovingly restored, and so thoughtfully appointed - and impeccably cleaned and maintained. Every single item you could hope to have at your disposal is not only present - but it's exactly where you would look for it to be, on the first try. I can't say enough about how thoughtful and intentional Suzanne and Charlie have been about creating this home. It's stunning, and has HAPPY energy - and heated floors in the bathroom! - and not a speck of dust anywhere. Clean, clean, clean and fresh. It felt like I was the first and only person who had ever been there. Suzanne and Charlie genuinely understand HOSPITALITY. I will 100% be back!!

Another great stay at Jessica's place. She was very responsive to an issue with coffee maker and it was fixed before the next AM! Cute place with lots of room!

Such a wonderful quiet area, the guest house was seasonal decorated which added to the experience! Me and my fiancé attended a wedding in Milwaukee but we bough don’t love downtown cities, very easy drive and close by to many restaurants, and cities. Host is a complete sweetheart and checked in to ensure everything was going well and if we needed anything. We will definitely be back if we end up in the area again!