Monthly Rentals in Coecles Harbor

Had a wonderful stay at Edward and Tracey’s place! Incredible lot and view of the water. Dock has a floating portion to ease access during low/high tide. Very private, nice quiet and secluded location. But also quite close to IGA (grocery), activities, and other local points of interest. House has lots of charm and had everything we needed for a multi-week stay. A great home base for your shelter island adventures! Thank you Edward and Tracey for your amazing hospitality! Would not hesitate to return to this special place.

The place is exactly as described and looks like the photos but more beautiful in real life. The house is an incredible value and the location is wonderful. Everyone room has water views and the place is kept pristine.

Incredible place to stay as a solo traveler. Clean, organized and efficient space with everything you could possibly need on site ! Amazing host with such knowledgeable recommendations for the surrounding area. Would absolutely stay here again & could not recommend more.

Donna's apartment was extremely comfortable and in a perfect location to explore Sag Harbor and the rest of the Hamptons. This was exactly what my wife and I were looking for in order to accommodate us and our baby daughter. The apartment was as advertised, and Donna was extremely communicative throughout our week. Check in and check out were a breeze. I would absolutely recommend Donna's place.