Vacation rentals in Shelter Island

The exterior of a single-story home is set among lush greenery, featuring a varied facade with shingle and clapboard elements. Symmetrical landscaping includes neatly trimmed shrubs and a spacious lawn. A pathway leads to the front door, framed by tall trees providing natural shade.

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

Peaceful and Private 3 bedroom home in the woods

Located on a private road & nestled in the woods, you’ll easily get lost in the quiet sounds & sights of nature all around you. Great walking/biking area, with the beaches less than a half-mile away. SI is a special example of the beauty on this earth! My 14 lb dog & I live in the separate converted garage. Your house has separate parking, a privacy fence & separate entrance, so you'll only see me if you need me. If you’re looking to escape, relax, & quiet your mind, you have found your home! ✨

A rocky shoreline is framed by a silhouetted tree against a colorful sunset. Clouds display shades of pink and orange as the sun sets over the water, creating a serene atmosphere. The beach area offers a peaceful view of nature.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

Shelter Island Getaway with Cozy Fireplace

Just 2 blocks from Hay Beach, our family & pet-friendly 3BR home offers space to relax & play. Enjoy a large yard w/ fire pits, beach gear, games, & toddler toys. Inside: open living area, fireplace, full kitchen, 2 baths, playroom, workout space, & extra sleeping options. Quiet neighborhood, perfect for families. Winter stays: cozy up by the fire & enjoy $0 cleaning fee Nov–Mar. Host lives next door for quick support. For the littles there is a full sized crib high chair and bathtub.

The exterior of a modern cottage is presented with a black wood facade and multiple windows. A front porch is seen, partially enclosed with slatted wood. Lush green grass and shrubbery frame the entrance, creating a welcoming approach to the home.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Waterfront NoFo Cottage w/ public beach access

Enjoy this waterfront cottage overlooking Marion Lake surrounded by lush landscape and wildlife. Experience the local Vineyards, take a leisurely stroll in downtown Greenport, ferry to Shelter Island, drive to Orient, or discover local hiking trails. Savor the culinary delights at the area's great restaurants, with fresh seafood and farm-to-table dining. Nestled between Greenport and Orient Point, East Marion provides access to all the North Fork has to offer. Rental Permit #1060

A bright living space is featured, furnished with two light-colored chairs and a dark coffee table. A flat-screen television is mounted on the wall. A doorway leads to a bedroom, while natural light filters in through the windows, illuminating the neutral decor.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 247 reviews

Aqua Vista

Newly renovated 2-Family Home! Located right in Greenport Village providing walking distance to all the restaurants, bars, shopping, coffee shops, and Shelter Island Ferry, Long Island Railroad (LIRR), and Hampton Jitney. My place is close to restaurants and dining, the beach, family-friendly activities, nightlife, and public transport. You’ll love my place because of Location!. My place is good for couples, solo adventurers, business travelers, families (with kids).

A charming historic boathouse features a steeply pitched roof with shingle siding and decorative trim. A white picket fence surrounds the property, while blooming shrubs enhance the entrance. A balcony adorned with planters awaits above the front door, complementing the inviting facade.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Designer's Dream - Charming Boathouse

An architect's and interior decorator's dream home! This home is a historic boathouse built in the late 1890's with modern updates. In the middle of Greenport Village - walking distance to train station, Jitney stop, and Shelter Island Ferry as well as the best North Fork restaurants, vineyards, bars, and beaches. Two bedroom home with ground floor fireplace, outdoor shower (not enclosed), and beautifully landscaped outside patio w/grilling & dining areas.

The exterior of a two-story house is depicted, featuring a light-colored facade with a welcoming front porch. Clear blue skies and greenery surround the property, while the lawn is well-maintained, offering a spacious area in front of the house.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 40 reviews

Hamptons - Shelter Island Farmhouse

Kid friendly! Perfect two family split! Come enjoy our island retreat. Relax with the whole family at this peaceful pad. You will be 2 min on bike from Wades Beach. You can also walk to the best BBQ/seafood in Shelter, Commander Codys. Features a large open kitchen/dining room plus also a spacious living room. 4 bedrooms with new mattresses, huge outdoor patio for family BBQs. No dogs please.

Home in Shelter Island Heights

A spacious living area features a brick fireplace with a mounted television above. Light-colored sofas are arranged around a wooden coffee table. Natural light enters through large windows, with a dining area visible in the background. Decorative lanterns adorn a rustic table.

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Laid Back Relaxation

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Nice newly updated home on a quiet street within walking distance to beaches, restaurants and a golf course. Great location near Shelter Island heights town, Crescent beach and Sunset beach. The location provides both privacy and relaxation at home with just a short walk or ride to popular Shelter Island spots.

Guest suite in North Fork

The exterior of a historic Tudor home is shown, featuring a blend of brick and wood accents. A winding driveway leads to the entrance, surrounded by lush greenery and a decorative black fence. Trees provide shade, enhancing the serene outdoor setting.

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 704 reviews

Walk to Vineyards, Beaches, Farms & Town

Private bungalow with a separate entrance in a historical tudor home. Spacious bedroom with king-sized bed, kitchenette and bathroom. Two bikes, cable TV, internet, AC, beach towels, parking, snacks, coffee and water all provided. Walking distance to the beach, restaurants, shops, vineyards, grocery, farms and fish market. Jitney stop is one block away!

Superhost

A round wooden dining table is surrounded by four metal chairs. Natural light enters through two large windows, with framed black-and-white photographs arranged on the wall beside them. A decorative centerpiece is placed on the table, offering a rustic touch to the space.

Apartment in Shelter Island Heights

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 259 reviews

Squire Chase House

Wide open loft like space in the heart of the Heights walking distance to North ferry and Marie Eiffel market Many antiques including 1930s leather club chairs and a wonderful 1850 Swedish gustavian sofa in the living room many original pieces of art work Note :the bath tub in the master bedroom is for decoration only Shelter Island license B Zone

A serene poolside scene features a clear blue saltwater pool alongside a comfortable lounge area. An umbrella provides shade over the sunbed, while a rustic outdoor seating arrangement sits nearby, surrounded by lush trees and well-maintained landscaping.

5 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

CASA GYPSEA - a chic and peaceful 3 bedroom house

Unwind and quiet your mind in the spacious yard surrounded with lovely specimen trees. Take a dip in the salt water gunite pool and enjoy never-ending afternoon lunch in the outdoor salon. This is a lovingly remodeled house, beautifully furnished, with many collection books and a full french library.

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

A spacious backyard features a heated swimming pool surrounded by a sun deck, adorned with loungers. Lush greenery and trees provide a natural backdrop to the inviting setting, while a charming house is visible in the distance.

Home in The Hamptons

4 BD w/ Heated Pool in E Hampton, Fully Furnished

Rent a beautiful and spacious 4 bedroom/3 bathroom property in East Hampton with a heated swimming pool in the backyard. This three level house with large kitchen, central A/C, BBQ in the backyard, and a garage is the perfect place to entertain guests or to relax and escape in East Hampton.

Cottage in Shelter Island

A traditional New England-style house features a front porch supported by white columns. Two white chairs and a small table are arranged on the porch, complemented by a dark front door. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, surrounded by green landscaped areas.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

3 Bedroom Cottage Gem

Traditional Shelter Island house, located in the heart of central village. This 3bedrooms/2 bathrooms house is really quiet, convenient for tennis players with courts cross the street, 4bikes to borrow. This house is close to restaurants and is close to the beach as well...

Popular amenities for Shelter Island vacation rentals

Gym

BBQ grill

Laptop-friendly workspace

Wifi

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Shelter Island

Cottage in Shelter Island

A wooden dock extends over calm bay waters, leading towards a small boat anchored in the distance. Lush greenery lines the shoreline, and a clear blue sky complements the serene landscape. Birds are seen casually swimming near the water’s edge.

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews

Large Waterfront Cottage on Historic Estate

A beachfront house with a wooden exterior is depicted, featuring multiple windows adorned with green planters. Soft sand covers the area in front, leading to the water, which reflects the clear blue sky. A small chair is visible on the sand, emphasizing the serene beach setting.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

The Sandy Shack - Coastal Escape

5 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

A charming cottage exterior is surrounded by vibrant pink and purple hydrangeas. A well-maintained stone pathway leads to double doors adorned with seasonal wreaths, framed by natural greenery. The textured shingle siding adds a rustic element to the inviting entryway.

Cottage in The Hamptons

Charming Cottage in Sag Harbor

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

The exterior of the home features a modern facade with natural wood siding and a green lawn surrounding a heated pool. Two umbrellas provide shade for patio seating, while large windows allow for ample natural light. Trees frame the backdrop for a serene atmosphere.

Home in The Hamptons

Chic East Hampton 7 Bedroom, 7 Bath, heated Pool

The beachfront home features a wrap-around balcony and large windows that provide views of the shore. The exterior is surrounded by a stone wall and sandy beach, with a staircase leading down to the water from the deck.

5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Kayaks ~ Bikes ~ Boards ~ 6mins> Greenport ~ 55"TV

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews

A bright living room features large windows that showcase water views. Comfortable white sofas are arranged around a wooden coffee table, while a dining area is visible in the background. A ceiling fan and a wall-mounted TV add to the room's functionality.

Home in The Hamptons

Wake up to Stunning Views at a Serene Waterfront Haven

5 out of 5 average rating, 60 reviews

A spacious living area is filled with soft natural light, featuring a curved sectional sofa and a modern coffee table. A stylish armchair and decorative items are present. The background reveals an elegant staircase leading to an upper level, enhancing the room's contemporary design.

Cottage in The Hamptons

Luxury Gem At The Heart of Sag Harbor Village