Vacation rentals in Sheffield

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sheffield

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a renovated historic building is viewed, featuring a stone facade and large front windows. A vibrant red door serves as the focal point. Surrounding greenery and well-kept landscaping enhance the inviting entrance, while the nearby parking area is visible.

Apartment in Princeton

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews

The Flats at Elm Place - No. 1

Renovated historic building in the heart of Princeton! Conveniently located on the corner of Elm Place and N. Main St in historic Princeton, IL. Minutes from Hornbaker Gardens and many desirable venues in the Illinois Valley. Within walking distance to the Amtrak train station, restaurants, coffee shop, bakery, pie shop, clothing boutiques, salons, and bars. Explore Princeton's other historic Main Street .9 mi South. This 650 sf space is one of two private apartments in a single story building.

LocationFamilyKitchen

Top guest favorite

Tiny home in La Salle

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 332 reviews

Snug Owl Cottage - Starved Rock area/dog friendly

Welcome to Snug Owl Cottage and Starved Rock Country! Relax after hiking the parks in your own private nonsmoking dog-friendly tiny home. •Starved Rock State Park 7.3 miles🚲 7.7 miles 🚘 •Matthiessen State Park 8.6 miles •Buffalo Rock State Park 12 miles Historic Downtown LaSalle is a mile away, but you won’t want to miss nearby Utica and Ottawa. The 400 square ft tiny Snug Owl is on its own city lot with fire pit (check for fire weather bans) Yard is not fully fenced. NO CLEANING FEE/PET FEE

FamilyLocationParking

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the home features a tan façade with green shutters on the windows. A concrete pathway leads to the entrance, which includes a porch with steps. The surrounding area is beautifully landscaped with a grassy lawn and flower beds, offering a serene view of the neighborhood.

Home in Geneseo

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Groovy 60s Themed House

Enjoy this completely remodeled home that’s a step back in time. Filled with 60s decor, style and flare with modern amenities and the comfort of home. Step into the lower level to shoot some pool or relax with tunes on the record player. A spacious deck overlooks a wooded area for a relaxing quiet night. The Airbnb house is owned by C&S Antique Mall - which is open daily for your shopping fix. Just minutes from historic downtown and close to restaurants and shopping, the location is perfect.

LocationFamilyQuiet

Top guest favorite

The entrance features a white picket gate surrounded by greenery, leading into a quaint cottage. The structure is complemented by a sloped roof and a cupola, with trees providing shade in the background. A well-maintained path runs alongside the cottage.

Guest suite in Princeton

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Covered Bridge Cottage

Our little cottage was built with love by us and is nestled right in the heart Princeton. We are steps away from the Amtrak station, our towns historic downtown area, and minutes from all of the amazing festivals, and historical sites Princeton has to offer. *Discounts* for long-term stays. Interested in local organic farm fresh eggs, meats, fruits, veggies, and homemade foods? Send us a message to make arrangements to have a farm fresh seasonal food basket delivered to you during your stay.

FamilyValueHospitality

Guest favorite

Cabin in Moline

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 247 reviews

River Views in Front Horses in Back-Kayaks & Bikes

Wake up to sweeping Rock River views in the front and peaceful views of horses grazing in the back. Sip your morning coffee on the wraparound deck, explore the nearby bike path on the two included bikes, paddle out in the kayaks, and end your evening by the firepit as the sunset glows across the water. This eclectic riverfront bungalow blends vibrant décor, cozy comfort, and easy indoor-outdoor living. It’s perfect for girls’ weekends, fishing trips, romantic escapes, or peaceful getaways.

ValueLocationCondition

Superhost

A spacious wooden deck offers a clear view of the Mississippi River and lush greenery. A picnic table is positioned on the deck, surrounded by tall trees. The tranquil water reflects the blue sky dotted with clouds, creating a serene outdoor environment.

Home in Albany

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Mississippi River Oasis

Take in the beauty of the Mighty Mississippi in our 2BR 1BA cabin. Located just north of Albany, IL on Illinois' Great River Bike Trail, this riverside retreat is perfect for outdoor and biking enthusiasts or those looking for a quiet getaway surrounded by nature. This property is: -1 mile away from a public boat launch -15 min. from Wild Rose Casino. 35 min. to Rhythm City in Davenport. -40 min. to QC Intl. Airport -1hr from historic Galena IL Hard not to enjoy this little slice of heaven!

LocationFamilyDecor

Guest favorite

A cozy bedroom is presented with a floral-patterned comforter covering a spacious bed. Decorative cushions, including a round pillow, are arranged at the head of the bed. Natural light streams in through two windows, framed by light-filtering curtains, creating a welcoming ambiance.

Home in La Moille

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 396 reviews

Cozy & Quiet Living at the Cookie Cottage

Welcome to the Cookie Cottage—a charming 2-bedroom getaway in the peaceful town of La Moille, IL (pop. 700 people). This vintage-inspired home has been lovingly updated with all-new beds, bedding, and linens… as well as a 43” Smart TV, fast WiFi, Echo Dot, Ring camera, and a smart thermostat. Perfect for relaxing or exploring nearby towns with great dining and entertainment just a short drive away. A cozy, quiet, comfy escape from the busy world. Our guests rock! No cats allowed, DOGS ONLY.

ValueLocationRiver

Guest favorite

A solar-paneled cottage is positioned on a grassy expanse, accompanied by rustic barns in the background. The deck extends from the home, providing a viewing area of the surrounding landscape under a clear blue sky.

Cottage in Princeton

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews

Cheerful eco-cottage at Edgewood Farm

Take in old growth oaks, native habitat, Bureau Creek, and rustic barns on 400 acre Edgewood Farm. Nestled in the Bureau Valley, the Eco-Cottage is a solar panel powered fully furnished two bedroom home with modern amenities. Enjoy peaceful morning coffee on the front porch overlooking restored wetlands, prairie, and hardwoods. Walk the miles of farm paths before dining outside under starry skies. Just minutes from Princeton's Amtrak station, antique malls, coffee shops, and bakeries.

LocationFamilySleep quality

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a quaint single-story home features a welcoming porch with a wooden railing and an American flag. Lush greenery surrounds the entrance, complemented by decorative flower beds. A large, partially fenced backyard is visible, adding to the inviting charm of the property.

Home in Toulon

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Laten Lodge

Experience Small-Town Living at Its Best… You’re just a short walk from the town park, local restaurants, bars, a charming ice cream shop, and a cozy coffee shop. Outdoor enthusiasts will appreciate the Rock Island Trail, which starts on the east side of town and stretches all the way to Peoria, Illinois—great for walking, running, or biking. Whether you’re here for a weekend escape or an extended stay, you’re sure to enjoy everything this small-town gem has to offer.

FamilyValueHospitality

Top guest favorite

Home in Kewanee

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 99 reviews

213 Kellogg Place

Enjoy your stay at this charming little house located just minutes from any Kewanee destination and walking distance from Wethersfield School. This newly decorated home gives off a very calming feel for that perfect couples getaway, a small family stay or a fun girls weekend. Centrally located to visit Johnson's State Park, Good's Furniture Store, Black Hawk East College, the Historical Bishop Hill or the Psycho Silo Saloon.

ValueLocationAccess

Top guest favorite

A driveway leads to a garage with two doors, bordered by manicured grass. A swing hangs from a tree nearby, with open fields visible in the background under a partly cloudy sky.

Home in Roanoke

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Sage Inn

Charming property conveniently situated between Peoria and Bloomington, IL metro areas. A stone's throw to Roanoke Park and Pool (open seasonally from Memorial Day to Labor Day) including a renowned disc golf course. Amenities include: access to WiFi, full kitchen, Smart TV, Washer/Dryer, Electric Fireplace, Futon in the living room folds out into a queen bed for additional sleeping arrangements.

LocationFamilyIndoor spaces

Guest favorite

A charming two-story house with a green exterior, framed by tall trees and a well-maintained lawn. A welcoming front porch is visible, with steps leading up to the entrance. Pathways and garden beds add to the inviting curb appeal of the property.

Home in Princeton

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 276 reviews

Historical Princeton House!

Spacious and comfortable, our 4 bedroom, 1 bath home is perfect for families, friends, or small groups. Enjoy a fully stocked kitchen, smart TV with streaming and a fenced in yard for your four legged friends. Located just 2 blocks from downtown Princeton’s Main Street shops and restaurants, you’ll love the walkable location, privacy, and cozy feel from the moment you arrive.

LocationValueIndoor spaces