Pet-friendly vacation rentals in New Buffalo

We had a great stay! The house was perfect. It was nice and clean with a great rooftop deck and screened in porch. The location could not have been better, walking distance to everything in town. Everything was easy as far as check in and check out with a book explaining everything in the house. Mark was great at responding to questions. I would highly recommend staying here.

Such a lovely place to relax and unwind with family! They truly had all the amenities you could think of, which is so wonderful. We enjoyed Three Oaks which is 10 mins away and offers great restaurants and shops.

Very peaceful to stay put here--bring what you need and stay in these beautiful surroundings among birds and gardens and an art-filled home. Or spend time on nearby beaches and trails, wander the nearby small-town shops and nice variety of restaurants and look forward to a hot tub soak and campfire. Donna's home is welcoming and inspiring!

Lovely home, many well thought out perks like fans in upstairs rooms and beach toys for kids! Info said it was an easy short walk to beach so I spent a whole lot more than I usually would. With children it would not be pleasant and is really not a short walk (and is on a semi busy road) & beach is down a whole lot of steps. BUT there are parking spaces so it was fine. Within the house, the steps are fairly steep at parts & there are 2?big ones going into house &!these were hard for my 70 year old mom w knee issues. So if person reading reviews is one of those people, this might not be THE place. That being said, it is very short walk to community pool & host is very responsive & house is beautiful! My mom mostly stayed within first floor including an awesome bed/bath on ground floor. There are games (although I didn’t love the Ouija board 🫣😂) . This would be a great place for multiple family / friends to split cost ;) Its very beautiful & community pool & hot tub are great!

This is our 5th year of vacationing in New Buffalo and have stayed at Missy's place on 3 of those visits! The house works beautifully for our family (7 adults and 4 kids under 6 yo) and you're never tripping over each other, which makes it so relaxing! We'll be back!!

Hannah was a great host. She was easy to contact and very approachable—although we didn’t need anything extra during our stay! Directions to get inside were easy to follow and we had everything we needed. Very clean and exactly like the description. We loved her reccs and ended up driving out of our way to try the Mason Jar Cafe which I, now, also highly recommend! Would stay here again if I was in the area.

Igor's Prairie Home was the perfect backdrop for my husband and adult children to take a break and reconnect as a family. The home is beautiful and so comfortable. We enjoyed the great hot tub and sitting around the fire pit. Oh and I don't want to forget to mention the tree house! How clever 🌞. Location is perfect for anything you'd like to do in the area because the house is located with easy access to Red Arrow highway. Either way you go there is plenty to see and do. Everyone wants to stay at Igor 's again and my son in law has already recommended to his parents. So I know we'll be back. 😎⛱️

Nice quiet location that is close to the beach

Loved our stay! The house was very nice and clean

This is our 3rd year in a row to come for an extended Labor Day weekend and bring our kids and/or grandkids. We love the setting. The pool is perfect for the younger kids and the adults appreciate the beauty of all the surroundings, including at poolside. If we could change anything at all we would add another bedroom as we can't quite get all of our extended family here at one time. That said, we would like to return for a 4th year at Labor Day weekend time next year. The combination of beauty, privacy, amenities, condition (always in great shape!), and proximity to lovely South Haven can hardly be beat!

We loved our stay. Kids especially loved the pool and hot tub. We brought our King Charles cav who loved walks along the road that runs parallel to the lake. We walked to whistlestop cafe for coffee and breakfast and hit up the private beach one night. So pretty. The house had some of the best beds I’ve ever slept on in an air bnb and the train did not bother us- they had sound machines in every room. I loved the cozy surroundings and all of the vintage touches of this home. Would stay again.

We had a great time. The home was perfect for what we needed, and feel super cozy!

We had a wonderful time at Mary’s property. Top notch amenities, beautiful and private location, and a seamless experience communicating with Mary prior to our arrival. We would absolutely recommend this listing, and hope to return for future getaways!

The property itself was clean and cozy, and the location was great for a quiet getaway. The host was responsive and check-in was smooth. Great vacation! However, one major downside was the hot tub. While it was advertised as a feature, there was no way to test or verify the water quality—no test strips provided, no information about maintenance, and no visible signage about recent cleaning. For guests concerned about health and hygiene (especially with hot tubs), this was a letdown and made us hesitant to use it. We ended up avoiding it altogether, which was disappointing since it was a key reason we booked the place. The hosts tried to contact the owners but we never heard back about it. If the hosts address this with proper water safety protocols or at least provide test strips for guests, it would make a big difference. Otherwise, the stay was enjoyable and the rest of the amenities were as described.

Really enjoyed the cottage for our family of four. The place is walking distance to the beach and a local playground. We enjoyed staying in nature but being able to drive to New Buffalo for restaurants or other things. Highly recommend for a weekend getaway.

Great stay! Loved the pool and lanai. Had fun playing the board games from the 80s and 90s. Great, well equipped kitchen - even a blender for smoothies! Linens were amazingly comfortable.

The most adorable cottage and getaway for my husband and I! I am picky and this one checked all the boxes. We loved being right across the street from the private access beach, walkable to Whistle Stop, comfortable and super clean accommodations - everything feels well thought out from the sheets to the design choices and we appreciated all of the details. We will definitely be back!

This is a nicely furnished cottage in a quiet and friendly neighborhood, and with an easy walk to everything on the town's little main street. The yard, deck and outdoor shower are great! I would stay here again.

The house is so great! Jess provided such impeccable details and was so helpful! We felt comfortable, safe and confident during our stay. This was our first ‘official’ vacation with our 2 year old, so we very much appreciated all of the toddler friendly amenities. We had such a great peace of mind throughout our stay. Everything is so clean and maintained well. We loved the board games! We had interesting weather during our stay (hot and cold!), so we enjoyed the open space of the house and all of the seating options both indoor and outdoor. Overall a great experience !

We had a wonderful stay and will definitely be returning! The house was beautiful and extremely clean, the master bed was so comfy and the backyard was perfect for our pup to run around in. The location was also perfect and in a peaceful area, but also only about 10 minutes to New Buffalo and some amazing restaurants! I would definitely recommend and can’t wait to book our next trip back here!!

Great property for the area! Host was very helpful and responsive as well

love staying in this cabin, is so cozy and warm. We spend a good day there . thanks for sharing this space with us

this was the first time using the platform. The communication with the host was absolutely phenomenal, even offering to help with any questions I might have using the app. I rate them the highest possible on every account because of the stellar job that they did. The house was very nicely put together and absolutely stunning. The location of the home is perfect for a variety of things in Michigan City and is very much appreciated. I highly recommend the house and its location as well as the wonderful host.

My wife, our dog and I stayed at the farmhouse for a long weekend to relax away from the city. It was the perfect country escape- peaceful, tranquil and still a quick drive to everything we wanted to explore. We mostly went to New Buffalo for restaurants and kayaking, and to the Indiana Dunes for hiking. The farmhouse was tastefully decorated with upscale amenities (like the coffee maker we decided to purchase when we got home). Mornings were spent reading on the screened in porch, listening to the birds and watching the chickens outside. There’s plenty of seating if you have a larger group, with tables inside and outside for meals. Stefanie was a wonderful host, her guidebook has great recommendations of things to do in the area and she gave very helpful instructions for the house. We definitely hope to return sometime as it’s so close to Chicago! Perfect weekend trip.