Vacation rentals with a fire pit in New Buffalo

We rented this property for our family with two little children. Although a bit small , it worked well for our needs. Lovely area, with a short pleasant walk to Lake Michigan beaches. We used to live in this neighborhood so it was very nice to revisit the area.

This is the second time we've stayed in Nancy's lovely home and we hope to return soon! The contemporary style features high ceilings and enormous windows overlooking a wooded lot and a graceful dune. The generous size of the living area and kitchen made it easy for our family to hang out together after a day in the Indiana Dunes National Park. You're only minutes from the lake, great hiking, and a restaurant we really enjoyed (Goblin and the Grocer) but the secluded, private setting makes you feel as if you're in the middle of nowhere ... perfect for city folks trying to get away from it all. Nancy is a great host, and her home features plenty of thoughtful touches to make your stay relaxing and comfortable. After a day of hiking and exploring, it was wonderful to return to this tranquil place. We can't wait to go back!

We had the most amazing week at The Treehouse! It is a beautiful house-so cozy, had everything we needed and we immediately felt at home! Our kids loved the loft space. We loved the area guide that was provided-we found amazing food, beaches and shopping! We’re already dreaming of our next trip back!

Igor's Prairie Home was the perfect backdrop for my husband and adult children to take a break and reconnect as a family. The home is beautiful and so comfortable. We enjoyed the great hot tub and sitting around the fire pit. Oh and I don't want to forget to mention the tree house! How clever 🌞. Location is perfect for anything you'd like to do in the area because the house is located with easy access to Red Arrow highway. Either way you go there is plenty to see and do. Everyone wants to stay at Igor 's again and my son in law has already recommended to his parents. So I know we'll be back. 😎⛱️

We really enjoyed our stay at Jennifer’s house! It was clean, great location & cozy! We especially loved the automatic pool cover so we could actually relax on vacation with our little ones running around. I also loved the three separate areas outside (pool, fire pit, grassy area). The separate areas offered a nice change of scenery to break up the day without leaving the house. I also loved that it’s a spacious ranch style house, so was easy to keep eyes on the kids. Jennifer was a wonderful & accommodating host & can’t wait to get back to her house soon! Thanks for having us!

Beautiful place! Fully stocked and perfect for a weekend get away!!

What a fabulous location! Walk to downtown and so many restaurants. The house had a great floorplan. Hot tub was a bonus. Terrific trip!

Absolutely perfect! Great spot to retreat from it all. Beautiful home and location. Super nice hosts!

Great place. I wish I would have gotten there at check-in time, so I could have enjoyed the river more!

We immediately felt right at home in Barbara’s apartment on their family horse farm. Our children enjoyed selecting books to read from their entertainment center and playing outside with Barbara’s children. It was nice to have respite from traffic down their long lane and to be able to fully relax due to the safe picturesque country setting. We appreciated the reverse osmosis filtered water, comfortable room temperature, shower stocked with toiletries, and cozy blankets. We slept well and were refreshed and ready for another day of traveling. We would happily stay again!

We couldn’t have picked a better place to stay. My husband, our 15 month old, and I are moving to Ethiopia in a couple of months and we needed to spend one last time with our family. Fern’s listing was so close to where our family lived and we were able to have our own space and also spend time with family. We got to meet and visit with our host one morning and they were so friendly and welcoming!! We will definitely choose these wonderful accommodations again if we ever come back.

Loved my stay! The farm was gorgeous and so peaceful and rejuvenating. Wish I could’ve stayed longer and would definitely stay again. Dan and Suzanne were friendly and helpful and the apartment was comfortable, well-equipped and beautifully decorated. 5 stars!

We had another great stay at Mari-Beth’s place, and we look forward to staying a third time in the future.

Becky's place was very nice and the backyard was beautiful! We even saw fireflies!

A wonderful and quiet space.

We had an amazing time! Me and my boyfriend stayed for one night, the patio and dock were super cozy and we really enjoyed sitting out there at night just listening to music and having some drinks. Super nice area, the beach isn't too far and they have some fun bars and restaurants in the area. Overall, we really enjoyed our stay.

if you're looking for a cabin in the woods this does not disappoint. Beautiful! Kelly is very responsive to questions.

Thank you for hosting, Sarah! We enjoyed walking to the beach and crossing the street for coffee and pastries at the Blackcurrent Bakery.

Had a great time with some friends at Candy’s property! She had helpful notes and cozy decorations all over the cabin, and we took full advantage of all the amenities she had to offer. We frequently saw ducks, swans, and other wildlife passing by and it was the perfect place to unwind and relax. Would definitely recommend to anyone that is looking to enjoy a weekend on the lake or take a breather from their busy lives! 🎣

Our family loves coming to this cabin. It is a wonderful place to stay with the great amenities such as the pond stocked with fish, the fire pit, grill, and walkable trails. It is such a nice place to stay and relax in the outdoors with the comfort of a cozy clean cabin to enjoy.

What a gem! And 3 very kind, friendly, generous hosts made our mother-daughter trip the best ever. The cabin was pristine and included unexpected extras. We felt so welcome to be there. The farm is beautiful, and the cabin has multiple comfortable seating areas for enjoying nature. We learned how peaceful it is to sit near the babbling creek and gentle waterfall and watch the adorable little goats go about their daily routine. Yet it was an easy drive to good restaurants and Lake Michigan. I dont have enough space to tell you how wonderful this place is. Just go there. We will certainly return.

If you are looking for a beautiful and private and peaceful retreat, look no further! David’s place is all of the above and more! This was our second stay! The little lake ( with boat and kayak) is always fun. The house is spotless and we are welcome with cookies! Thank you so much again!

We had a wonderful stay at this beautiful home tucked away in a peaceful rural setting. The house was full of charm and character, and the surrounding mature woods made it feel like a true escape. It's conveniently located near Three Oaks and New Buffalo, both of which offered plenty of great activities, dining, and local charm. Our dogs loved the space just as much as we did—especially the nearby dog beach! Highly recommend for anyone looking for a relaxing and pet-friendly getaway.

We had an incredible stay at the Sandy Dunes cabin! Jeannie was an excellent host--super responsive and friendly, and genuinely wanted us to have a great experience. The home is located in such gorgeous surroundings and overlooks a field of grass and tall trees. It offered privacy on the lot while also being located close to other homes and groceries stores and restaurants. The cabin was filled with tons of fun activities and it was spotlessly clean! Everyone in our group thoroughly enjoyed our stay and we would absolutely come back on the future! Highly recommend for a group or family trip.