Vacation rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cagles Mill Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Farm stay in Whiteland

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 529 reviews

The Vintage Farmhouse

Charming, full sized apartment w private entrance located on 2 acres in a beautiful country setting 10 minutes from the city. 840 sq ft accommodates up to 7 people. Pet friendly, happy to share our fenced yard w your pets. Full kitchen, washer/dryer, free Wi-Fi, smart TV. Owner on site. 30 min. from downtown Indy, Indpls Intl Airport or Indpls Motor Speedway. PARKING FOR TRAILERS/UHAULS ETC. 6500 sq ft fenced yard w pizza oven available for gatherings, addtl fees apply. Inquire before booking

Top guest favorite

Guest suite in Bloomington

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Hideaway Hollow - A Woodsy Getaway

Hideaway Hollow is a cozy, private guest suite in Bloomington, Indiana. Located on the north side, it is just fifteen minutes from the heart of downtown Bloomington, IU stadium, and an hour from Indianapolis. Nestled in the forest, the suite offers a covered porch with a private entrance, a spacious living room, a kitchenette, and a master bedroom with a full bath. Suitable for up to four guests, come to enjoy the serenity of country living, the comforts of home, and easy access to the city.

Top guest favorite

Barn in West Terre Haute

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

The Goat-el at Old 40 Farm

Spend your night in the most unique "barn" you'll ever find. Complete with a full bath & shared with 20+ goats, 2 ponies, and other farm animals, you're sure to have a memorable stay (the animals have their own space). There is also a walking path to a small pond on the property & ample free parking. Should you time your stay right you could join in on goat yoga or another farm event! This barn is located just off I-70 & a short drive to several areas colleges, the casino, & entertainment!

Top guest favorite

Home in Bloomington

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

5 Mins IU • Priv Parking • Fast WiFi • Spacious

🏡 Cozy & Thoughtfully Curated Home ⚡️2 Miles: IU, Stadiums, DT, Golf, Lake & More!⚡️ Newly renovated with style, comfort & convenience in mind. Guests love the thoughtful touches, cozy ambiance and immaculate cleanliness. Whether you're here for business, visiting IU, or enjoying a relaxing getaway, you’ll find everything you need. Special Offer: Early/late check-in/out — $25 ❤︎ Add to your wishlist by clicking the ❤︎ in the top-right corner! ❤︎ Message me with any questions! ❤︎

Top guest favorite

Home in Gosport

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

Maria’s Haven

Welcome to “Maria’s Haven”💕 A beautiful cozy home in the heart of a beautiful small town. This home belonged to my mother, Maria, who passed away in 2020 to breast cancer. This home was truly her “Haven”. Take a walk to the local diner, museum, Gosport playground, local shops, or to our delicious Amish bakery. We are also just a few miles from the popular “Hilltop” restaurant as well as McCormicks Creek State Park. Our mission is to make you feel like you never even left home. ☺️

Guest favorite

Cabin in Martinsville

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 476 reviews

Grandpa's Cabin at Heidenreich Hollow

Grandpa’s Cabin at Heidenreich Hollow offers exclusive lodging on our hilly 5 acre wooded property. We offer a peaceful getaway from life while being right in the middle of both Indianapolis and Bloomington! Our quiet rustic cabin has a loft bedroom with stair access that includes a King size bed, 2 twin beds and an air mattress. We have a spacious bathroom and a fully equipped kitchen to help you feel at home. Search YouTube for Grandpas Cabin at Heidenreich Hollow for a video!

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Unionville

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

Summer Forest Sanctuary: Adventure & Relaxation

Escape to "Cabin Porch Paradise," nestled on 40 acres of lush forest near Lake Lemon and just a short drive from charming Nashville, IN. This summer, ignite your romance or gather your closest friends for an unforgettable getaway filled with adventure, relaxation, and starlit nights. Romantic King Bedroom Cozy Queen Bedroom Unique Sleeping Porch Area Two Spacious Porches BBQ Shack Fire Pit Hot Tub Coffee Bar Board Games Washer & Dryer Boat Rental at Lake Lemon-10% discount

Guest favorite

Home in Poland

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 204 reviews

Captain Bill's Guest House/seasonal swimming pool

Welcome to Captain Bill's Guest Lodge at Cagels Mill Lake! This gorgeous home offers modern amenities in a countryside setting. Perfect for bikers, boaters, fisherman, and anyone looking to enjoy lake life. Our guests are welcome to join us poolside at the main house. Our private pool is open only to us and our listed guests at our two Airbnb units. We're located seconds from the boat ramp and a short drive to Cataract Falls and Lieber State Park. Pool is seasonal.

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Nashville

5 out of 5 average rating, 457 reviews

Modern Nashville Home in the Woods

Welcome to Plāhaus - a modern home nestled in the woods of Brown County. Plāhaus is a space of solitude and relaxation for anyone wanting to enjoy the beauty of Brown County, without the typical log cabin decor. Enjoy the gorgeous view from the balcony, spend some time around the firepit, and venture into Nashville to check out the unique shops and restaurants. Come for a family getaway, a romantic retreat or simply to clear your mind from the everyday stresses.

Guest favorite

Home in Brazil

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 325 reviews

Swans Nest

If you are looking for a place to get away from the stresses of life this is it. You can fish on our 10 acres lake, walk thru the woods or just relax on the porch swing. Only 5 minutes from the nearest town, 30 minutes from Terre Haute and 40 minutes from Indy. Front porch faces a walnut tree grove and back porch faces 10 acre lake. At least 3 State Parks are within 20 miles of this property. Also super close to the Parke County Covered Bridge Festival.

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Carbon

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews

Parke County Dream Cabin

Come experience the serenity of country living and get away from the daily grind of everyday life. Come fish in our five-acre lake (catch & release only), paddle-boat, kayak, or stroll through the woods. A covered porch and seating lakeside for relaxing. Located close to Mansfield and Bridgeton, 30 minutes from Turkey Run State Park, and only 30 minutes toTerre Haute or Greencastle. Come explore everything Parke County has to offer! KIDS WELCOME!

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Unionville

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

The Lake Cottage

The Lake Cottage is located on beautiful Lake Lemon. Bring your boat Kayaks, bikes, fishing poles and hiking shoes. Biking is the best in the Midwest, Hike the trails in Morgan Monroe state forest just minutes away, or walk out the door and explore the lake! We are a 20 minute scenic drive from Bloomington, IU, Nashville. 15 minutes to Oliver Winery and Butler Winery. Our cozy cottage has everything you need for a relaxing getaway.