Vacation rentals in New Madison

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Madison

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A cozy sleeping area is defined by a soft white bed adorned with decorative pillows. Warm light is provided by unique hanging fixtures. A wooden table displays an arrangement of fruits and snacks alongside elegant candle holders, creating a welcoming and intimate setting.

Tower in Pleasant Hill

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

Kick Cancers Ass With A Stay

Unique. For a Cause. Fun. A place where your stay truly counts! Your stay… Enjoy a night(s) away in an old grain elevator silo that now is home to a fully open concept layout with the most comfortable bed, a soaking tub of your dreams, handmade exposed copper piping & every detailed covered for the perfect getaway! The Cause… 20% of every nights stay goes to Pink Ribbon Good helping local ladies fight cancers. On Site… Coffee & Ice Cream Shop Axe Throwing Sand Volleyball Yard Games Boutiques

Top guest favorite

The front of the Craftsman bungalow is framed by a large tree and a colorful ornamental tree. A stone pathway leads to the entrance, surrounded by well-maintained gardens featuring various plants and shrubs. A grassy area is visible in the foreground.

Bungalow in Richmond

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 300 reviews

Artist's Retreat Guest House

The Artist's Retreat Guest House is a two-bedroom Craftsman bungalow in the Earlham College neighborhood that welcomes adults visiting our community of Richmond, Indiana. It features a living area, a fully equipped kitchen, a library filled with art books, a garden, fine antiques, and works by regional and international artists. Sorry, but no children, pets, or smoking. We keep the house allergen-free and many of the art pieces are too fragile or heavy for the safety of children and animals.

Top guest favorite

The loft features exposed red brick walls and a raftered ceiling, creating a historic character. A spacious bed with a white coverlet is positioned beside two large windows with light curtains. A wooden table and chairs are situated in a cozy corner, complemented by decorative lighting.

Apartment in Lewisburg

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 154 reviews

Leader Loft

Conveniently located less than a mile from I-70 exit 14, on State Highway 503. This loft is perfect for any stay length for every occasion, and with the electronic door lock system it is perfect for a last minute stop as you’re traveling down the interstate. The Loft shares our building with Flour Bakery, coffee and gift shop, and is a minute's walk from a delicious bistro, antique shops, other gift shops, the library and hardware store. Come explore all that our quaint village has to offer!

Guest favorite

The rustic exterior of the cabin is displayed, featuring a muted blue façade adorned with a brown trim. Planters filled with vibrant flowers are positioned by the entrance, complementing the greenery surrounding the porch. An eagle figure is mounted above the door, adding character to the entrance.

Cabin in Greenville

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Camp Combs Cottage

Situated in the Village of Wayne Lakes 6 miles south of Greenville, Ohio. CAMP COMBS is a RUSTIC two bedroom cozy summer fish camp built in 1940 with updates. Electic controlled fireplace if there is a chill in the air. Property has fishing dock, canoe, row boat and connects to swimming area on Lake Algonquin. Unfortunately, it is NOT pet friendly. WiFi is best on front inside porch; water heater is small with good pressure. Peace, quiet and comfort for a short break, week or longer stay!

Guest favorite

A glass vase with delicate yellow branches is centered on a wooden dining table. The background reveals a cozy living area with vintage seating and a television on a brick wall, while a glimpse of a bedroom can be seen through an open door.

Apartment in Richmond

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Industrial & cozy 2 Bedroom atop a Historic Bldg.

Located on the 4th Floor of the Loft Highway Building in the heart of Richmond’s Historic Depot District. The Loft Highway houses such local businesses as Roscoe’s Coffee Bar & Tap Room, Lisa’s Cakes, Oblivion Cinema & Arts, Journey Yoga Studio, and The Art of Hair Salon and Metamorphosis Day Spa. Multiple other local restaurants and shops are just short walks away throughout the area. Each Guest receives 1 Free Drink from Roscoe’s (per night). Salon/Spa Booking info available upon request.

Guest favorite

The two-story farmhouse is shown from the side, with a well-maintained lawn in the foreground. White siding and a black roof are complemented by a few windows and a covered entryway. An open field stretches out beyond the house.

Home in Eaton

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

The Patch: a cozy country home on a country farm

Conveniently located from exit 10 on I-70, The Patch is an old farmhouse in northern rural Preble County. Fully furnished, three-bedroom home with central air and WiFi. Main floor features a bedroom with a queen-size sleep number bed directly off a working area with two more bedrooms located upstairs. Walk into the full-size stocked kitchen with washer and dryer. A large patio provides privacy and relaxation with a view of the farm. Perfect for work crews, stays, or just passing through.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a two-story Techbuilt home is surrounded by lush greenery, showcasing large windows that invite natural light. A mature tree stands nearby, providing shade to the well-kept yard. The cedar siding highlights the home's mid-century architectural style.

Apartment in Richmond

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 541 reviews

Private Apartment-800sq ft Next to Earlham College

Upper level separate apartment. Short stroll to Earlham College campus, ball fields, tennis courts, stables and Athletic Center. 5 houses up from the President's house. Windows galore offer natural lighting. Quiet neighborhood. Hardwood floors give that cozy feeling. Guaranteed clean and private. Well-behaved pets welcome. Breakfast not included. Coffee, tea, microwave, toaster oven and refrigerator in apartment. Host lives in lower apartment with dog and 2 cats. Chickens in the back yard.

Top guest favorite

A spacious front porch features four cushioned chairs and two small tables, inviting relaxation. Lush plants and hanging flower baskets enhance the area, while the entrance includes a handrail leading to the porch. Soft, filtered light casts gentle shadows, creating a welcoming atmosphere.

Home in Richmond

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Cozy 3BRw/porch kids OK, no pets, near EC-IUE-Reid

This private, spacious, two-story older home, was built in 1918. We do not allow pets. Past guests have loved the cozy gas fireplace and lovely front porch. Sleeps up to 6 in 3 upstairs bedrooms; with half bath on main floor, full bath upstairs. Kid-friendly, across from a wooded city park with rentable shelters, a playground and a basketball court. In a quiet residential area 3 blocks from Earlham College, 3.7 miles from Reid Hospital and IU East, 2.5 miles from Wayne County Fairground.

Top guest favorite

A spacious living room is enhanced by green walls and natural light from large windows. Comfortable seating is arranged around a rustic coffee table, with a media console displaying a television. A decorative rug adds warmth to the polished wooden floor.

Cottage in Richmond

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 484 reviews

The Cottage on Abington Pike - Earlham College

Charming private cottage (home) on the West edge of Richmond within walking distance to Earlham College. This updated Three bedroom home has one custom full bath (w/Tub) & one half bath. The kitchen has been updated and is on the lower level. Great location. Wooded private rear yard with covered patio. Cardinal Greenway, Gorge Trail all of Richmond nearby. Fast Wi-Fi. Large Living room & Game room w/Pinball & Multi-cade. Outside quiet 10:00PM. Parties not allowed. 2 Tvs.

Top guest favorite

A cozy living room is presented with a large flat-screen TV positioned on a white cabinet. A comfortable gray couch is complemented by a plaid armchair nearby. Natural light filters through the window, with a small indoor plant adding a touch of greenery.

Guest suite in Richmond

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

Justice Gästehaus apartment

Directly right of interstate 70 Within 5 miles of: • Earlham College Moore Museum • Reid Memorial Hospital • Short distance to Middleborough Reservoir Lake • Hayes Arboretum • Wayne County Museum (5-star Trip Advisor rating), which houses an authentic Egyptian mummy • One of the largest antique mall in the Midwest • Richmond Civic Theatre • 40-minute drive to Brookville Lake Smart TV you can sign in to with your Netflix &/or Amazon account (no cable)

Top guest favorite

A well-maintained exterior view of a modest structure featuring a green roof and light-colored siding. The entrance is framed by a wooden deck with a railing, accompanied by landscaped stones and decorative elements, including small sculptures and shrubs. Natural light highlights the inviting entryway.

Farm stay in Greens Fork

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

A country night under the stars!

Get away from it all when you stay under the stars. Join us for a peaceful country stay, close enough to drive to nearby shopping and dining, and far enough to hear the crickets and see the stars. Your cozy place will include a kitchenette, coffee pot, microwave & TV. The dining area inside or on the attached deck, full size bed & full bath with shower. Only 3.9 miles from Interstate 70. Should you choose to use 100-foot zipline to exercise your pet.

Top guest favorite

A charming cottage is surrounded by colorful autumn foliage. A gravel driveway leads to a spacious grassy area in front of the home, complementing the inviting deck that extends from the entrance. Trees with vibrant leaves create a tranquil backdrop.

Cottage in Lewisburg

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

The Cottage Retreat

Whether you are looking for a place to spend some time or just passing through we think you’ll find it quite lovely here. We are just 5 mile off of I70 and centrally located among many places of interest. Go out or stay in. The outdoor living space is pretty spectacular! Private, with a hot tub, fire pit (wood provided), turf to play corn hole. Inside delivers all the comforts of home with full kitchen, laundry, workspace and cozy fireplace.