Vacation rentals in McGuffey

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in McGuffey

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

A welcoming living room is highlighted by ample natural light streaming through large windows. Soft, neutral-colored seating is arranged around a textured area rug. Floral artwork decorates the walls, adding a touch of elegance to the space. A ceiling fan is visible above for comfort.

Home in Bellefontaine

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Small Town Feels - King Beds - Hot Tub

Relax at this peaceful and comfortable Bellefontaine home. Main floor has 3 bedrooms, full bath, kitchen, dining room, and a living room. Basement offers another bedroom area within the living room, full bath and large laundry room. Fully fenced in backyard with a hot tub, patio and fire pit. Inviting porch to sit and take in the beautiful small-town neighborhood, 15 minutes to Indian Lake and Mad River Mtn. House trained dogs welcome only $50 fee. NO CLEANING FEE if you clean up after yourself.

LocationFamilyParking

Top guest favorite

A cozy bedroom features a spacious bed adorned with neutral bedding. A wooden accent wall complements the room's warm tones, while natural light streams through a window beside a cushioned nook. Two wooden closets are visible, adding to the room's inviting appeal.

Cottage in Russells Point

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 170 reviews

NEW! ❤️ The Pointe House ❤️ LAKE VIEW & BOAT DOCK

Welcome to The Pointe House! Brand new remodeled home located in the heart of Russell's Point w/ fabulous lake views and boat dock for guests to use. Cozy is an understatement! Walk next door to Jack n Dos pizza & ice cream shop! Stunning remodel, original decor. 3 BRs, 2 FULL BATHS! Comfortably sleeps 6! Quartz Counters, Recessed Lighting, Electric Fireplace. Amenities include 4K HD TV w ROKU. WI-FI, Keurig Coffee Maker w/ Complimentary K-Cups, Microwave, Fridge, Range, Fully Furnished Kitchen.

FamilyLocationAccuracy

Top guest favorite

A log cabin silhouette is presented against a vibrant sunset sky, featuring hues of orange and purple. The tranquil reflection of the cabin and surrounding trees can be seen in the calm water of a swimming pond in the foreground.

Cabin in Wharton

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

BackRoads Living

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. Huge ,newer Log Cabin, boasting all Live Edge Walnut countertops, a beautiful clean swimming pond , close to 3 acres of land including a small primitive cabin in case anyone wants to camp out by the campfire, also includes a huge finished basement with a bar and a pool table. Very quiet peaceful area. also includes a whole home generator in case a storm would come through and you would lose Electric.The generator would automatically kick on

LocationFamilyHospitality

Top guest favorite

Two individuals relax in comfortable adirondack chairs on a pebbled terrace, facing serene waterfront views. The scene captures a sunny day with scattered clouds and lush greenery lining the shore in the background, creating a peaceful atmosphere.

Home in Lakeview

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews

Open Water View-Heart of Lake-Memories Start Here

Perfect for making family memories, a retreat with friends, or a romantic getaway. Lakefront with EXPANSIVE views, outdoor relaxing, indoor coziness, boat tie up at the seawall & nearby restaurants and shops. In addition to all the lake activities, enjoy Mad River Mountain, Marmon Valley Farm, golfing & more. Waterfront home on quiet street near Fox Island Beach/Park. Indoor electric fireplace, outdoor firepit, central heat/ac, full kitchen & coffee bar and W/D onsite. Four seasons of fun!

LocationFamilyQuiet

Guest favorite

A modern cottage is showcased with a turquoise roof, surrounded by greenery. A spacious deck features a seating area with comfortable chairs and a table, while lounge chairs are placed nearby. The setting includes a man-made water channel, enhancing the outdoor appeal.

Cottage in Lakeview

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

Welcome to No Egrets - Waterfront on Indian Lake

Welcome to your fabulous vacation getaway! Completely renovated with 4 theme rooms created for your enjoyment - Lodge, Disco, Speakeasy, and Bar. Plus a 3 seasons room off the back deck that has a twin day bed and trundle if you want relax near the water. The kitchen is fully equipped with all the luxuries of home. In home laundry, tons of games and so much more. To learn even more about your new fav spot visit NoEgretsOhio dot com. About a mile walk to Froggy's and the Tilton Hilton.

LocationValueComfort

Guest favorite

A charming cottage is set on a spacious lawn, surrounded by trees. Its light-colored exterior features a prominent clock, while a welcoming porch invites relaxation. The serene sky displays soft pink hues at dusk, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere of the setting.

Farm stay in Ottawa

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 258 reviews

The Granary

The Granary is a unique and spacious home. Set on a small farm, it was converted from barn to cottage in the late 1990's. Pets are allowed (for fee) and our dog and cats may stop by to visit. Great for families visiting home, or looking for a place to get away. Great for travelers visiting the Gilboa Quarry. No parties or events per AirBNB policy. **IMPORTANT: 1 queen size bed on the first floor The other beds are open lofts visible to each other and accessible by very STEEP stairs.

LocationFamilyComfort

Top guest favorite

The dining room showcases a large wooden table with a decorative centerpiece, complemented by a ceiling fan. Natural light filters through the windows, illuminating the wood flooring and the inviting atmosphere. French doors create an open flow to the adjoining living area.

Home in Ada

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 64 reviews

The Grady House

Located right across the street from Ohio Northern University’s campus and steps from downtown, this home was one of the first places ONU Founder, Henry Solomon Lehr lived when he ventured to Ada, Ohio. His granddaughter lived there carrying on the Lehr-Kennedy legacy. Enjoy Padrones Pizza, just steps away, Mona’s lunches at 302 carry out (right next door!), visit family in the area, Tavern 101, enjoy the Ada Park, just minutes away, or take a stroll through campus! Welcome home!

FamilyValueWifi

Guest favorite

A serene pond reflects colorful autumn foliage and a wooden dock. Surrounding trees display vibrant fall colors, enhancing the natural beauty of the ten-acre wooded property. A rustic cabin is visible in the background, providing a tranquil ambiance.

Cabin in Harrod

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 97 reviews

Secluded Cabin, 10 acres Hot Tub, Pond, Fire Pit

Sugar Creek Cabin is a peaceful 10-acre wooded retreat that welcomes up to 12 guests. Enjoy walking the property, relaxing by the fire pit, spending time on the pond dock, or soaking in the hot tub under the stars. Inside, the newly renovated rustic cabin offers a cozy fireplace, board games, and karaoke, creating the perfect mix of relaxation and fun. It’s an ideal getaway for families, friends, and anyone looking to unwind in nature.

FamilyValueHospitality

Top guest favorite

A single-story yellow house is framed by a white picket fence and manicured landscaping. Red shutters complement the windows, enhancing the home's curb appeal. A tree provides shade, and a small decorative truck is positioned near the flower bed, adding a charming detail to the exterior.

Home in Lima

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 195 reviews

Comfortable Family-Friendly Home in West Lima!

Comfortable and family-friendly 3-bedroom home on the West side of Lima, located very near the movie theatre and a short drive to the hospitals or factories. A fenced back yard, covered parking, a fully stocked kitchen, spacious living room, and a dedicated work space make this a great place for traveling families or for work! Newly remodeled half bath. Quiet neighborhood. Close to everything! Pets are allowed with a $25 cleaning fee.

FamilyValueBackyard

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Harrod

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Little house on the prairie.

Escape the noise and unwind in this peaceful countryside retreat. Wake up to birdsong, relax to the sound of frogs in the evening, and enjoy the quiet beauty of nature—all while staying within an easy drive of Ada, Bellefontaine, Kenton, and Lima. Whether you're traveling for work, visiting family, or simply looking for a relaxing getaway, you'll enjoy the privacy, comfort, and convenience this cozy cabin offers.

ValueLocationAccuracy

Guest favorite

A lakeside view showcases a vibrant sunset over the water, framed by trees. A stone patio is visible, featuring several outdoor chairs surrounding a firepit, providing a welcoming space for relaxation.

Home in Belle Center

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Gorgeous lakefront property w amazing sunsets

Beautiful scenery on a gorgeous lot. Well furnished 4 bedrooms, 3 full bath lake house on the point of Long Island. Right on the water with over 180 feet of shoreline. Enjoy the beautiful sunsets. New appliances, and a new kitchen island with farm house sink. Read our description for more property details. Includes utensils, cups, plates, and most major kitchen appliances (coffee maker, dishwasher, etc).

FamilyValueWifi

Guest favorite

An outdoor entertaining area is surrounded by wooden fencing, featuring a shaded seating space with a sectional sofa. A hot tub is positioned nearby, and a grill is present. Colorful outdoor rugs and string lights create a relaxed ambiance.

Home in Lakeview

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

Serene Silo & Spa

Experience the ultimate couples retreat in our completely remodeled cottage featuring a charming grain bin gazebo and a relaxing hot tub. Unwind in style amidst private, serene surroundings, blending rustic charm with modern comfort. Just a 3-minute walk to Chippewa Marina and boat dock, with plenty of parking for your vehicle and boat, your perfect retreat awaits!

ValueFamilyNearby