Guesthouse vacation rentals in Long Island

Dawn set the bar high with this Carriage House. Fully stocked, updated, comfy, quiet, impeccably clean, high end everything. This was our first stay at an airbnb, I can't imagine they are all this new and this nice. Next time business or pleasure takes us up your way we hope to stay here. Thanks, J&B

Nice ground floor apartment across the street from the beach and 2 blocks from the state park. Love the outdoors. And Delores and her brother were amazing. Friendly, responsive, and helpful.

Peter's place is THE perfect stay for a couple (plus dog) planning a visit to Rockland County. The cottage is extremely clean and incredibly cozy. The surroundings are beautiful, with the property well set back from the road and bordering Harriman State Park. Suffern and its restaurants aren't far and there's easy access to the Palisades Parkway to go anywhere else nearby. I grew up in the county and visit my parents on a regular basis. Any time I can't stay at their home, Peter's place will be my go-to from now on.

Jonathan and Amy were the perfect hosts. Super friendly and resourcesful. The property is beautiful and so peaceful which was perfect for our down time as we were in town for a three-day wedding. We enjoyed breakfast with the family of deer that live in the back field and so many beautiful birds. The apartment is so quaint, very clean and has everything that we needed. The beds were super comfortable. It was decorated to the age of the property which we loved! It was a great find and we highly recommend the apartment and will surely book again if ever in the area.

Place was exactly as described, clean, comfortable, and quiet. Liz was flexible with checkin which was helpful since our flight got in early and we did not have a car for our luggage. We did bang our heads on the slanted ceilings a few times the first day, but we adjusted. Location is in a quiet neighborhood, we Uber’ed to eat and do other activities. We would stay again.

This is the cutest Airbnb! Everything you need in a little niche of love, convenience, and comfort! A wonderful location and neighborhood! When visiting family, I will certainly be back to stay here. 💖

We were in town for a concert in Red Bank and the cabin met our needs perfectly. Ideal accommodations for two people and we were able to bring our dog along. An easy stay in a very comfortable setting.

John was a perfect host! Friendly, responsive and made us feel welcome. I took my 9 year old son and we had a great time fishing off the dock and kayaking. The kitchenette is lacking if you want to cook any meals but it didn’t matter in our case. Absolutely beautiful location!

This place is very peaceful, in a great area with lots of restaurants and shopping nearby. The guest house is extremely clean and there is no clutter. I really enjoyed my stay here and highly recommend this Airbnb if you ever want to get away to someplace peaceful but close enough where you can find things to do.

We had a great time staying for a week at the Sherwood Barn ❤️ Thank you!

The pictures really don’t do it justice , the place is adorable. The kitchen has all new appliances, and it has every amenity you could need for a long or short stay.

This home is absolutely perfect – the entire space is beautifully decorated, peaceful, and spotless from top to bottom. The beds are incredibly comfortable with high quality bedding. The kitchen is fully stocked with every conceivable item. The hot tub and fire pit are a relaxing way to end the day. You can tell Dean and Brenda take pride in maintaining the space and every little detail made it feel like a high-end stay. I’ll definitely be coming back and recommending it to friends!

We absolutely loved our stay. Unfortunately, we booked on a much colder day so we weren’t able to take full advantage of the pool— but even then, being able to sit outside in the patio is nice. The family gave us so much privacy. Would absolutely love to come back on a warmer day!

We had a wonderful stay at Kathleen’s! It was a perfect location and close to everything! She was flexible with check in and check out and gave us recommendations for a rainy day. Our little girl even got to take home a little stuffy! Thanks for everything!

Wonderful stay! Thanks for everything!!

We can’t say enough good things about our stay! The space was beautifully decorated and had everything we needed for a weekend at the beach. They also provided thoughtful touches like a beach bag loaded with towel and a map to make it extra special. We loved how walkable it was to the beach and enjoying a cocktail on the porch after a hot day. Madison has some amazing restaurants and shops too - a perfect long weekend. Thank you for being such welcoming hosts!

Had a great time at Shay and Sam’s luxurious cottage. Every aspect of this place is thoughtfully designed from the decor, lighting and bathroom spa, to the Frette sheets and towels making for an incredibly comfortable stay. The kitchenette is very compact but has just about everything needed, including a dishwasher. A lovely backyard and patio are an added bonus along with a ramp to the property’s entrance. Located in a beautifully manicured and very quiet neighborhood across from the back of Harbor Island Park, the property is about a 25 minute walk from the train station via Mamaroneck Avenue-with its various shops, restaurants (Nonna Carola is not to be missed) a liquor store, and a small Italian market. We were pleasantly surprised to find a Trader Joe’s, bagel shop and the Nautilus diner about 20 minutes walking distance from the property as well. Communication with Sam was easy and very helpful. Would love to come back and definitely recommend a stay here.

Amy and her husband welcomed us when we arrived and were super friendly and responsive with messaging! The place was just as described and the perfect accommodations for a weekend in NJ. A nice surprise was the enclosed backyard for our dogs to explore! Wifi was a bit spotty, but definitely not a deal breaker for us.

A group of us stayed here for a wedding nearby. Durelle was super communicative and helpful the whole time we were there. We didn't get to spend much time there and due to the weather we didn't hang outside too much but the property was beautiful and seemed like a great place for a summer getaway with the pool & firepit

This cottage is absolutely lovely and peaceful. You have a view of the Long Island Sound across the street and the house sits on an inlet. We truly enjoy sitting on the back deck on the inlet water. There are ALWAYS people walking, riding bikes, jogging, walking dogs… etc Lots of delicious restaurants and stores so super close! We will definitely be booking here again in the future!

This cottage was very comfortable, we had everything we needed, it was easy to get to off of Interstate 95. We enjoyed the shops at Old Mystic Village and the ride into downtown Mystic was a breeze. The beds and pillows were super comfortable. We enjoyed sitting out on the front porch. This cottage was well appointed and centrally located.

stayed here for a second time and it was amazing, very quiet and clean place, absolutely coming back when I'm back in the area 💕

This was our second stay at this cottage. We were so happy it was available for the weekend we needed because we loved the first stay! Neil is the perfect host and we truly appreciate his hospitality, including the delicious strawberries from his garden and the special kiddo activity area my granddaughter enjoyed so much. We hope this rental will be available for us again on our next New Jersey visit.

Second time stay here and I loved it! It’s such a cute, private and homey place. I enjoy every minute there and Meg is so accommodating and sweet! I will absolutely book here again