Vacation rentals in Lake Montauk

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Lake Montauk

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Apartment in Montauk

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews

Duffy's on Lake Montauk 2

These newly renovated units are located on Lake Montauk, five minute drive from town and the ocean beaches. The property offers paddle boards, kayaks and beach chairs. There is a BBQ grill, a fire pit to enjoy sunsets and lounge chairs lake front to relax. The unit has a full kitchen, washer/dryer, queen bed, small living area, large screen TV and wifi. The units sit at a 90 degree angle to the lake with partial lake views from the deck. PRICES INCLUDE SUFFOLK COUNTY SALES AND OCCUPANCY TAX

Jan 27 – Feb 3

R5,018 ZAR per night

Guest favorite

Cabin in Montauk

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 424 reviews

Montauk | Tiny Cottage in Private Hither Woods

A little cabin on our property in Hither Woods. A cozy hideaway conveniently located 12 minutes walk from Gurney's Beach Resort, 16 minute walk from public path to beach, and 6 minutes drive from Montauk town for restaurants and nightlife. Good for couples and solo adventurers, the space is private and homey, with outdoor shower and Chimenea fire pit. The main house is 65ft away, but we honor your privacy. The cottage comes with WiFi, window A/C and complimentary coffee or tea. Parking for 1 car

Oct 5 – 12

R6,332 ZAR per night

Guest favorite

Home in Montauk

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

ocean view beach estate/ Ditch Plains

Secluded, magical 2 acre estate across the street from the famed Ditch Plains beach with panoramic Atlantic ocean and lake views. Nestled in the exclusive Seven Sisters enclave, this private renovated 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom house has sprawling lawns and nature. Top brand appliances: Wolf Stove, Bosch fridge, Duravit soaking tub. Designer furnishings, linens, and lighting. Listen to the waves and enjoy sunsets on patios and two balconies. Plus Weber BBQ, wi-fi. central A/C & heat, outdoor shower.

May 7 – 14

R15,379 ZAR per night

Guest favorite

Condo in Montauk

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews

Montauk Waterfront Condo w/ Sunset Views

Modern 1 Bedroom Condo in gated community (Rough Riders) with sunset views from beautiful deck. The community has multiple tennis courts, pool, jacuzzi, and sauna (pool area only open Late May - early October). The property is great for walks along the boardwalk and many guests enjoy fishing and swimming off the pier. The unit is less than a 5 minute car / Uber ride to town and a short 5-10 minute walk to Navy Beach and Duryea's. Strong wifi in unit, Smart TV ( Netflix, etc, - no cable)

Jan 6 – 13

R7,461 ZAR per night

Guest favorite

Bungalow in Montauk

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 52 reviews

Neff Cottage

Booking now for spring, summer & fall 2024! Neff waterfront studio cottage sits on a great lawn w/4 other cottages on Ft Pond Bay. Neff is steps away from our private beach w/ private beach path, benches. Indoor & outdoor showers, full kitchen, large deck, grill & 1 dog-friendly. Water views from the cottage & deck. A unique Montauk experience w/ quiet, private beach, beach path, the best sunsets in town & walking distance to LIRR, Duryea's Lobster Deck & Market, The Montauket & Surf Lodge.

Oct 21 – 28

R4,850 ZAR per night

Guest favorite

Home in Montauk

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews

Laid-Back Bungalow. 10 min Walk to Beach & Town!

Discounts available for longer stays. Find us @studiomtk to inquire about best pricing. Historic Montauk fisherman's cottage tastefully re-made into a stylish 2-bd beach getaway located within walking distance of the beach & downtown. Plywood accents, handmade furniture & eclectic finishes create a cool, laid-back vibe. Westward views across Fort Pond provide sunlight all day & beautiful sunsets. Designed by Studio MTK, this is Montauk at its best! EH Rental Registry: 22-1360

Apr 11 – 18

R10,077 ZAR per night

Superhost

Cottage in Montauk

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

REDUCED for last min bookings Modern MTK Cottage!

Contemporary home boasts newly finished hardwood floors, mid-century modern furniture, AC and fireplace, (non-working). With a light- filled open plan layout, this house sleeps four adults with two bedrooms. There is one full bathroom and a large outdoor shower for sandy trips from the beach. A fully equipped kitchen, private yard and deck, cookware, BBQ and WiFi ensures this house is your home away from home. Brand new smart TV - apple+ and all the popular apps compatible!

Jan 8 – 15

R8,987 ZAR per night

Guest favorite

Guest suite in New Shoreham

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

Hilltop Happiness

We are located high on Mott hill in the center of the island. It's about 2 miles to both harbors. There are lots of hiking trails nearby. We are located near the island airport so small private planes come and go during the day but it is usually very quiet at night. Many of our guests say watching the planes is one of their favorite things. This spot is ideal for visitors who like to retreat to a quieter space at the end of a long day at the beach or an evening on the town.

Oct 7 – 14

R3,269 ZAR per night

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Montauk

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Cozy guesthouse in an English style Tudor house

Light and airy, lots of blue and white (think Ralph Lauren) cozy and country feeling cottage in an English tudor house. The perfect place for a relaxing stay in Montauk. Reminiscent of an English county cottage with all its charm and imperfections. Its the perfect spot for a BBQ and relaxing outside with the sounds of birds chirping and the leaves rustling. 20 min walk to town, 25 min walk to the beach. I hope you'll enjoy your stay :)

Dec 5 – 12

R13,693 ZAR per night

Guest favorite

Apartment in Montauk

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Montauk’s Secret Private Spot

Sunsets & seashells are just a stone's throw away from your private beach. Centrally located and within walking distance to docks, delis and restaurants and the fishing community. Private parking and patio are just the beginning to your welcoming apartment. This sunny apartment affords you 1 bedroom, living room, kitchen and bath plus all your beach needs (chairs, towels, umbrella) and grill. BRING NOTHING EXCEPT YOURSELF!!!!

Jan 27 – Feb 3

R3,298 ZAR per night

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Mystic

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 541 reviews

Gorgeous Waterfront Getaway

Perfect getaway from the city for couples wanting peace and tranquility and stunning views. A beautiful waterfront one bedroom guesthouse, one and one-half miles from downtown Mystic CT. Beautifully decorated with art and antiques. Kitchenette, full bath and loft bedroom. Queen bed. Air conditioning and heated. Belgian linen bedding! Private patio. Dock. Kayak/Canoe rentals close by. Internet.

Dec 9 – 14

R3,561 ZAR per night

Guest favorite

Home in Montauk

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 418 reviews

DITCH PLAINS SURF HOUSE

Beach house on quiet street, 200 yards to Montauk's best surfing beach, Ditch Plains. The house is a simple all white home with 2 decks, BBQ, bikes, kayak, and easy open floorplan. You can hear the ocean all day long on this hidden Montauk street. Easily walk or bike to the beach, where you find waves, food trucks in the summer & miles of sand and ocean heading west to Montauk.

Mar 12 – 19

R4,369 ZAR per night