Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Fish Creek

stayed for a second time for our 30th anniversary. They added a king bed. We love the place! its beautiful, on the water and next to a great restaurant.

Beautiful space, fully stocked with everything needed and amazing local coffee and wine. Private space but still close to lots of options. Definitely check out twelve eleven wine bar and thyme restaurant - amazing food, drinks and service and right around the corner. Would definitely stay here again or check out Tim's other properties!

My partner and I had a great time here! We were able to make our own meals with the utensils/pans/etc. provided in the kitchen. There were restaurants and stores within walking distance which was super nice. Matt was super responsive and a great host.

We had a fantastic stay! The house was spotless, well-stocked, and incredibly comfortable. After staying in several Airbnbs, it was refreshing to find a host who truly thought of all the little details that make a stay feel special. From the starter supplies to thoughtful touches throughout the home, we felt well taken care of from the moment we arrived. All we had to bring was our food, beverages and personal items. The hosts were proactive, responsive, and easy to communicate with. We would absolutely stay here again!

We had an amazing time staying at Seth and Briana’s townhouse in Sister Bay. The location couldn’t be better—just a short walk to downtown, making it easy to explore all the shops, restaurants, and waterfront. The townhouse itself was immaculate, spotlessly clean, and incredibly comfortable. It had every amenity we could possibly need, making our stay effortless and relaxing. Seth and Briana were outstanding hosts—responsive, helpful, and always available if we had any questions. This place was the perfect home base for our Door County getaway, and we can’t wait to come back! Highly recommend!

We had a wonderful stay, the only thing wrong was we couldn’t stay longer! Amazing view, beautiful property and we couldn’t have picked a better time to visit. Thank you for sharing this spectacular home!!

Hands down, best place we have stayed! Beautiful yard, incredibly clean and stocked with anything you may need. Space for all of us to sit, eat and relax. Location was wonderful - quick drive downtown, but also far enough away to escape the hustle. With 5 kiddos joining us, we appreciated the unbreakable dishes, ample towels and lots of games and activities - both indoor and outdoor. We explored much of Door County, but could have just as easily spent more time at The Shed with plenty to explore and do.

We were looking for a beautiful and peaceful stay while we explored the Door County area and that is exactly what we got! The house itself was very clean and looked just like the photos. The property looks out onto Moonlight Bay and has incredible views. It was a little chilly during our stay so we did not get to enjoy all of the amenities but everything that was mentioned was present in the backyard/garage! The only thing we were disappointed in was that the dock wasn’t out. Other than that, we would definitely recommend this stay!

Wendi and Ron were great hosts! Their place is exactly as pictured and had every amenity to my my stay comfortable. It’s a great location on the west side of Sturgeon Bay, and everything was very clean and quiet. Great internet too!

We loved our stay in Egg Harbor! Mikes place is clean, brand new and modern! We will definitely be back. Thanks again!

This place was amazing! It was clean and had beautiful updates. It appeared brand new! It was spacious and perfect for our girls weekend. 3 Comfy beds and two large bathrooms suited the needs of our group of 5 and All the amenities you need for a weekend getaway!

Great place to stay! The host was very responsive and helpful and the place was very nice!

We really enjoyed Jon’s place. It’s located in a quiet area yet within an easy drive to all the attractions of Door County. The place is very spacious and could easily accommodate 6 people, but had plenty of room for the 4 of us. The beds were very comfortable, there were plenty of towels and other amenities. We appreciated the provided coffee and the coffeemaker, as well as all included kitchen accessories. The grill on the balcony was a great addition as well and we enjoyed cooking dinner on the night of our arrival. Thank you again for a great place to stay!

We just had the best time staying at Heavenly Stay. It was incredibly clean. So many rooms and each of the 3 couples had their own bathroom. Staying in an old church was so charming and it was decorated to perfection. We interacted with the owners on a few occasions and their assistance and suggestions helped make our stay in Sturgeon Bay filled with so many great memories. We will definitely be booking another stay here and bringing more of our family to enjoy. Thanks Al & Shannon

This was a surprise Birthday outing with my wife Shavonda and she truly love the space and we had a wonderful time. Thank you for being such a great host and having such a welcoming space.

Our stay at Mario’s was great! Very homey and welcoming! The location is perfect and the pool is great!