Vacation rentals in Fire Island

Wow just Wow HIGHLY RECOMMEND! This Airbnb is incredible. The drive up alone made me feel like I was no longer in NY lol. I gave Kayla a heads up that I was less than 10 mins away from the house and she responded right away and made the arrival so easy. The house is unbelievable! Its so beautiful in person, the pictures don't do it justice. We rented it for a night for my sons birthday and we had a pool gathering with family and used the BBQ for grilling. The pool is HUGE and goes pretty deep is you enjoy a good swim! Everything was ready for us to use and if we had any questions, Kayla was readily available to answer. The house was very comfy and accommodated us very well. In the evening, The pool table gave us lots of competitive energy and fun while the kiddos watched movies in the theater. I appreciated the air purifiers in the house, it let's me know that the space is constantly clean and free of dust and dander. Thank you so much Kayla and we hope to use this space in the future!

The beach house was perfect, just as described. It was clean and very homely, in a lovely location. Natasha was a great host from start to finish. Would definitely recommend to friends/family looking for a place to stay in Patchogue. Many thanks Natasha

This is our second time at Kerry’s place and we wish we could come back every weekend!! The place is so comfortable and cozy and the fact that our dog was welcome was so wonderful. The neighborhood is so picturesque and we loved just walking around the area! Kerry and her husband were so welcoming and warm but also gave us our privacy while we were there. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a cute coastal getaway!

We just stayed at this Airbnb for less than 12 hours but it was perfect!! We got in late, but the check in was so easy and seamless. Marina has the whole place stocked with essentials like bath products, snacks, and water bottles.

This was a perfect base for us to visit our family in nearby Blue Point. We knew the neighborhood and felt right at home. We will try to stay here every time we visit.

We had a wonderful two day stay at Roger and Amy’s place. It was fantastic- such a beautiful, inviting home. Our kids had a blast in the heated pool- we could barely get them to come out despite it being under 60 degrees out! The kitchen was stocked with more than just kitchen basics- the spice cabinet had soo many different choices ! It was probably the most perfect AirBnb experience I’ve had and we travel plenty.

Wonderful and cozy apartment! We were in town for a wedding and needed a clean and safe space to make home base. This was perfect. Would absolutely stay again!

We enjoyed our 4 night stay in this quiet neighbors hood! Easy walking distance to restaurants, churches and library! The bed was very comfortable .

The Ocean Bay home was in a lovely location with a large sunny deck, comfy beds and convenient wagon, beach chairs, and umbrella. Our host was very responsive and the proximity to a beautiful beach made for a great stay. We look forward to visiting Fire Island again with our family.

We had a great and very peaceful time. The cottage is private and very close to both the beach and restaurants.

Robert’s beach house is absolutely fantastic. Super comfortable just as advertised and the outdoor shower is everything!

Geoffrey and Thomas were very gracious hosts, filled with benevolence, they greeted us with such warmth, gave us a tour of their beautiful home, along with the complimentary beverages, providing us with resources as well as information about the island since we’re newcomers, the house was lovely, clean and serene, hot tub was amazing, we enjoyed hearing their stories about fire island as well as giving us recommendations for food, shopping and sightseeing, it’s good to know fellow New Yorkers will have your back, very happy we picked their place to stay, absolutely would come back.

Erin’s place was perfect! We did a girls trip to fire island over memorial day weekend, it was the perfect size for 3 of us. Erin’s place was situated about a 30 min walk from the Ocean Beach, and super easy to get to from the Ocean Bay Park (I think?) Ferry Station, so it was super easy to get to. We had such a lovely weekend exploring the island, and could easily get to other parts of the island (i.e. Cherry Grove) by Water Taxi. Erin was extremely helpful with navigation guidance. We would definitely come back again!

We had a lovely time and were very impressed with Gabrielle's response time when we had questions. I plan on returning next year!

Great location with great outdoor seating for all types of activities. Beach access was convenient and the towels, chairs and beach umbrella were nice to have. This studio didn’t have great privacy incase that is a concern but it was fine with us. Hope to stay again.

We had a relaxing stay in Fire Island. The house is cute with lots of quirky beachy Fire Island charm. Location is excellent - just a short walk from ocean bay park ferry and super close to the beach. The outdoor shower (with hot water!) was such a great bonus feature of the house! All in all we would definitely recommend booking. Thanks for a great stay :)