Cabin vacation rentals in Cedar Lake

Let me start out by saying, the pictures honestly don’t do the cabin enough justice! I hosted a small, lowkey bachelorette party and the cabin truly made the trip. Totally exceeded my expectations with space, uniqueness, and authentically rustic yet chic!

We stayed at Donna’s for my graduation from Oliver Nazarene University. My husband, daughter, parents, brother and I all stayed at the cabin for the weekend. It’s was cozy and full of charm. We loved being able to stay together, cook meals, play games and watch movies all in the serene setting of the cabin. Donna was kind, responsive, and always made sure we had everything we needed. Highly recommend and we have already started talking about coming back for another visit! 😀❤️

Thank you for hosting my friends and I, we had a peaceful stay!

Absolutely magical place. Truly isolated in the midst of a small meadow (no close neighbors), the cabin is also excellently appointed with everything you could possibly need, high quality kitchen and bathroom fittings, and lots of little quirky touches. Full length windows surround the living space, with stunning views that I could gaze at all day. Ryan was friendly, helpful and quick to respond. Can’t think of a single thing that needed improvement. We had a fabulous time and are already dreaming of the next time we can come back!

I had not had so much fun with my family in a long time. I loved how fast was the response of the host and the kindness of the cleaning lady. We want to come back.

We were lucky enough to snag Sarah's place at peak spring, right before the summer crowds rolled in. Our toddler loved the huge, grassy yard that wraps around the house and playing hide and seek on the screened patio. (Bonus: He slept soundly after all the running around!) My husband and I enjoyed our evenings in the hot tub, plus the thoughtfully equipped kitchen and comfortable king-sized bed. Steps from Neon Moon Gelato and a market. Short stroll to Townline Beach and Seedz Brewery. We would definitely stay at Sarah's again!

Great stay in New Buffalo!

Sarah’s beautifully built A-frame home was the perfect base camp for our weekend away to celebrate my partner’s 40th birthday. The neighborhood was peaceful and quiet. We enjoyed the fire pit and the hot tub. Getting to downtown Three Oaks was a breeze and a public beach was a mile-ish down the road. We would love to come back for another visit!

Very cute place! Definitely recommend! Monica responded quickly & was helpful.

Our stay was nothing short of amazing! The airbnb was so clean and so nice! We enjoyed our stay and would love to make the trip back up and stay again!

Very nice place!

Linda and Floyd's cabin was comfortable and relaxing. We enjoyed our stay and appreciated the beautiful wall decor.

Another great stay at Brightstone. I took my wife this time, who loved it. She enjoyed the peacefulness and the location around the lake. Looking forward to coming back.

Great vacation spot for families!

Oh my this place didn’t disappoint! My first time last minute booking a beautiful cabin in northwest Indiana! I had no idea what I was looking forward to my family was very impressed. The location was very secluded with nearby cabins! The walk to the lake was maybe about 10 mins considering I’m 9 months pregnant it was very clear and easy to transport to. I love our stay the cabin felt very new and comfy. Clean, Eric was super responsive when I had issues getting in! I was overall pleased with our stay will do again in the future. The place was immaculate and had so much to offer. I’m glad we booked with brightstone they made our weekend complete!

My family stayed there for a long weekend. They said it was beautiful, clean and plenty of room for the six adults and one two year old.

Sarah was very friendly and showed amazing hospitality. Her place offered a very relaxing get away with a beautiful view.

We had a wonderful time at the cabin. The lake was a quick walk away and the beaches were quiet. The neighborhood has a nearby park as well. The cabin was the perfect fit for our group and very clean. We are already looking at returning next year.