Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Cayuga Lake

Find and book unique fireplace rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated fireplace rentals in Cayuga Lake

Guests agree: these fireplace rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A scenic view of a lake is framed by lush greenery. A table is set between two Adirondack chairs, featuring a vase filled with colorful flowers. The calm water reflects the soft tones of the surrounding landscape.

Home in Ithaca

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 237 reviews

2 BR/2B Lake house Minutes from Town and Campus!

-Beautiful lake views -Amazing location -Cozy -Modern -Comfortable -Peaceful & Private These are the most common remarks from our guests. The perfect lake living on the water while still minutes from town! Treat yourself to coffee/tea every day while watching the sunrise over the lake from dual balconies/the dock. This is a two-story home w/ 2 bedrooms & 2 full baths. Accessible to Ithaca's finest restaurants, Cornell University & Ithaca College, wineries & all the Finger Lakes have to offer.

Top guest favorite

The elevated treehouse is illuminated by soft lighting along the wrap-around deck, surrounded by trees in a nighttime setting. A gentle slope leads up to the entrance, providing accessibility. The structure features warm wood tones that complement the natural surroundings.

Treehouse in Horseheads

5 out of 5 average rating, 212 reviews

A Treehouse -Falcon Nest

A Treehouse. Reconnect with nature at this unforgettable escape. Nestled in 28 acres of woods with hiking trails. This unique new construction all electric 525 square feet elevated structure offers a wrap around deck for an ever changing view. King size new technology foam bed offers complete comfort in separate climate controlled bedroom. Heated bathroom floor is a “warm” surprise. Optional outdoor shower for the adventurous spirit. Kitchen lacks nothing tucked conveniently in the great room.

Guest favorite

A green roof features a weather vane shaped like a dog, positioned atop the building. The background reveals a serene view of Seneca Lake under a clear blue sky, with lush greenery framing the scenery.

Apartment in Hector

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 332 reviews

Private Year-round Lakefront on Seneca Wine Trail

You’ll enter a Large, Luxurious, Private studio apartment in beautiful Arts & Crafts style. *Located on a Town Maintained secluded lake-side road on the shores of the east side of Seneca Lake. *Ten-foot Coffered Ceilings *On the Seneca Lake Wine Trail. *We welcome visitors all year round. A wonderful option for couples looking for a private, quiet place to get away. *Many custom-crafted details. *2 additional guests can be accommodated with a fold-out sofa bed (an additional fee. )

Guest favorite

A private deck features a rocking chair and a small table, positioned to offer stunning views of the lake at sunset. A large tree is visible in the foreground, silhouetted against the colorful sky reflecting on the water.

Guest suite in Ithaca

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 252 reviews

The Lakeview Nook – Midcentury Modern Stay

Enjoy this mid-century modern guest house in a spectacular site, with a lake view, waterfall, and forest all in one place. The house was just fully renovated. This house is just 2 miles from Ithaca downtown and 3 miles from Cornell University. The location is super close to everything Ithaca has to offer—Ithaca falls, downtown, restaurants, the farmer's market, wineries, all within a few minutes drive of your rental. This unit is fully private, with no shared areas/entrance with the other unit.

Top guest favorite

A newly constructed barn home is positioned beside a serene pond, surrounded by lush green grass and colorful flower beds. The expansive outdoor area offers scenic views of rolling hills and vibrant autumn foliage under a partly cloudy sky.

Barn in Burdett

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 203 reviews

Private EcoBarn Home with Sensational Sunset View

Eco-green,Recently Constructed Barn Home. Built with mostly locally grown organic, acquired and reused materials with a focus on health, comfort and energy efficiency. Connect with nature, every room features glass doors. Our home is a choice location for privacy, sunsets and exploration of the Finger Lakes and the famous wine trail. Our home features a large screen room, pavilion, fire pit and pond. Sample the bounty of our organic garden, berry bushes and fruit trees. Sample the best of FLX.

Guest favorite

A single-story cabin is shown with a blue railing surrounding a wooden deck. The entrance is visible, and a charcoal grill is positioned on the deck. Lush greenery and a view of the lake can be seen in the background, providing a serene setting.

Cottage in King Ferry

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 167 reviews

The Megan House-Cayuga Lake East Shore - Level Lot

OLD SCHOOL AIRBNB- We own ONE rental and we love sharing it with others! Enjoy amazing sunsets from this year round cottage on East Shore of Cayuga Lake. Sleeps 5. Everything you need to enjoy a relaxing vacation: Swimming, Canoeing, Campfires, Fishing, Kayaking. Three wineries within 5 min. Golf 3 mins away. 35 mins. to downtown Ithaca, Cornell U + IC. Great for a grad weekend, a girls getaway, or some family down time. TMH is a COZY CLEAN CABIN in a gorgeous setting, NOT a LUXURY HOME

Guest favorite

The image captures the exterior of the lake house during sunset, highlighting a wooden deck with railings and seating. Lush foliage and ferns frame the view, while the shimmering water reflects warm hues of orange and pink from the sky.

Home in Geneva

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

Azalea Beach House on Seneca Lake

Enjoy this spectacular lake house with 4 bedrooms and 2 1/2 baths. Extra sleeping space provided in the upstairs loft areaand the lower level with 2 daybeds in each space. The living room sofa is also a queen sleeper. Luxury vaulted kitchen, fireplace, laundry...lots of parking, dock, kayaks and new hot tub!. You'll love the wrap around covered porch that looks over the lake. Located on the "gold coast"...east side of Seneca Lake... close to so many wineries, breweries & downtown Geneva

Guest favorite

The image features a serene sunset over a calm lake, with soft hues of orange and pink reflecting on the water. A dock with a boat is visible, alongside a well-maintained lawn leading towards the water. A small tree adds greenery to the scene.

Home in Auburn

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

Owasco Lakefront | Flat Lot, A/C, BBQ, Kayaks

Private lakefront home in the Finger Lakes on Owasco Lake with stunning sunsets and rare level access to the water—no steps! 15 minute drive from downtown Auburn and Skaneateles. Large flat yard, 2 kayaks, new barbecue grill, 75” smart TV, A/C and smart TVs in all bedrooms. Master suite with deck, lake views, and en-suite luxury bath. Fast Verizon Fios Wi-Fi. Minutes to wineries, breweries, public golf courses & charming small towns. Perfect for families, couples, or a relaxing getaway.

Guest favorite

Aerial view of a lakeside property featuring a red dock with a picnic table and green umbrella. A fire pit and seating areas are visible on the shore, surrounded by lush greenery. The house, with multiple decks, is nestled among the trees in the background.

Home in Ithaca

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 154 reviews

Magical lakefront treehouse, minutes to downtown

A magical treehouse perched over its own gorge on Cayuga Lake. This place is special! There’s a giant porch wrapped around a 300-year oak tree and a lakeside tea house that can serve as an extra bedroom. There’s a dock, fire pit, room for yard games by the water, plenty of outdoor seating on the porch, by the lake, or on the dock. All of this is minutes from downtown Ithaca, Cornell, and Taughannock Falls state park. It’s also a great base to explore the Finger Lakes wine region.

Top guest favorite

A charming lakeside retreat is framed by lush trees, showcasing a dark exterior complemented by bright yellow doors. Colorful flower beds add vibrancy to the landscape, while the shimmering lake is seen in the background, offering a serene setting just steps from the water.

Home in Skaneateles

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Skaneateles Lakeside Retreat

Just 3 miles from the Village of Skaneateles, this lakeside retreat is the perfect place to enjoy stunning sunsets over the lake, relax by the fire, and explore the true jewel of the Finger Lakes region. Built in 2021, our home has everything you need to live, work, and relax: 2 comfortable king beds, 2 baths complete with heated floors, a well-appointed chef's kitchen, and a cozy living room with fireplace. In the warmer months, enjoy the patio and dock from sunrise to sunset.

Top guest favorite

An inviting living area features large windows that allow natural light to fill the space. A neutral-toned sofa and seating chairs are arranged around a central area rug, while a stone fireplace adds a rustic touch. Greenery can be seen through the windows, connecting indoors and outdoors.

Home in Skaneateles

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

Sunset House- Beautiful Home with Gorgeous Vistas

Experience a home full of windows and light that take in breathtaking views from every angle. You feel like you are on top of the world surrounded by beautiful rural landscaping that is only 1.8 miles from the charming Village of Skaneateles! Lovely interior furnishings with your comfort in mind. You are within close reach to the Skaneateles Polo Fields, a free public boat launch, Skaneateles Country Club, wedding venues and a winery. This newer home is fresh, clean and cozy!

Superhost

An outdoor deck overlooking the lake features a large brown table surrounded by six matching chairs. Sunlight illuminates the scene, where the water reflects a partly cloudy sky. Large windows provide views of the tranquil waterfront.

Cabin in Seneca Falls

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

Finger Lakes: Private Cottage on Lake

Full house on Lake; 3 min from the New York Chiropractic College; 10 min from the historical town of Seneca Falls, Montezuma National Wildlife Refuge, and nearby Finger Lakes wineries. You can swim right off the deck using the ladder (summer), fish, Kayak (2 available + life jackets). Beach and a boat ramp in Cayuga Lake State Park (2 min up the road). In the winter, cross-country ski and ice skating rings nearby (Geneva; Watkins Glen). New lock for easy check-in.