Vacation rentals in Cayuga County

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Cayuga County

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

The image captures a tranquil sunset over a lush green landscape, with the expansive horizon meeting the shimmering water. A modern home is nestled in the foreground, surrounded by trees and an open grassy area, offering a peaceful retreat in nature.

Home in Town of Sterling

A+ Country Getaway | Rooftop Deck | Pet Friendly

Unwind in our spacious 3-bedroom sanctuary in Sterling, NY! Just a short walk from McIntyre Bluffs & Sterling Nature Center, the Eagle's Nest is perfect for outdoor adventures. Enjoy scenic trails, lakeside picnics, & quality time together. Fully equipped kitchen, TV in each room, & Wi-Fi ensure comfort. Unique layout with 4 short stair areas inside. Rooftop deck for sunset views over the trees. Gather around a fire pit for cozy star gazing. Don't miss this unforgettable retreat! Book now!

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 51 reviews

Guest favorite

Home in Baldwinsville

Seneca River Waterfront Retreat

Gather your group for a relaxing waterfront stay on the scenic Seneca River--just 20 minutes from SU & only a few to Timber Banks & Route 31 shopping. This renovated home sleeps 10 & has 2 remodeled full bathrooms, full kitchen, 4-season room, laundry, patio, firepit & 100+ feet of private river frontage w/new 28' dock & kayaks for exploring the water. Enjoy peaceful views, comfortable indoor-outdoor spaces & the perfect balance of nature & convenience for your next Central New York area escape.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Ovid

Blue Heron Lodge- Lakefront luxury with boat dock

Welcome to Blue Heron Lodge, your ultimate Cayuga Lake getaway! This Adirondack-style home blends modern amenities with upstate NY charm. Enjoy a powered boat lift, dock, canoe, paddle boat, and rowboat. The main floor offers a luxury kitchen, living/dining area, two bedrooms, and a half bath. Upstairs, two semi-private loft bedrooms include one with an en-suite bath. The basement features a living room, full bath, and gym. Relax on the deck, screened porch, or 150’ of private lakefront. EV char

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews

Guest favorite

Large glass doors provide a view of the Seneca River, with natural light filtering through sheer curtains. A comfortable sofa is positioned near the door, and a floor lamp stands beside it. A deck is visible outside, surrounded by trees.

Home in Baldwinsville

The River Retreat

Stay at our cozy pet friendly river retreat nestled on the banks of the Seneca River Supplied with all amenities including central AC heat cable high speed Internet multiple parking spaces. Our nightly price covers 4 guests Air mattress/pack N play at request Entry Keyless entry Kitchen Full kitchen microwave dishwasher pots/pans cooking/baking appliances Bedroom 1 Queen size mattress dresser closet desk Bedroom 2 Full mattress w/ twin trundle Living room 4K 50” smart TV gas fireplace

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

Top guest favorite

The spacious waterfront home is illuminated at dusk, with a sunroom featuring multiple large windows. A sandy beach area is visible in the foreground, accompanied by lounge chairs and a tree providing shade. The surrounding yard is lush and well-maintained.

Home in Town of Sterling

4 King Bed Private Beach +Pet Friendly +Pickleball

Cherish family moments in our spacious 20’x30’ sunroom with 22 bay-view windows. Exclusive beach home with 180 degree stunning view, private 50' dock, walk-in beach, grass yard, movie room and campfire. Parking for 6+ vehicles. Sleeps 12-14 in 6 bedrooms, including 4 King beds, 1 Queen bed, 2 Twin beds. 3 full bathrooms and fully equipped kitchen. Create lasting memories at this tranquil Fair Haven Bay retreat, with private location offering bay views from 3 sides of the 3 story home.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Top guest favorite

A spacious living area features a high vaulted wood ceiling and large windows that allow for abundant natural light and scenic views of Cayuga Lake. Comfortable seating arrangements include a gray sectional couch and a distinctive orange chair. A patterned area rug is placed on the warm wooden floor.

Vacation home in Seneca Falls

Brand new luxury lakefront home on Cayuga Lake!

Newly built luxury accommodations on Cayuga Lake in the heart of the FLX. 4 BR (5 Beds). 3 full baths. Laundry. Wifi. Central Air. 75" Smart TV. High-end finishes. Nearby amenities include: Cayuga Wine Trail Cayuga Lake State Park Women's Rights National Historic Park del Lago Casino & Resort Waterloo Premium Shopping Outlets Taughannock Falls State Park Ithaca (Cornell University & Ithaca College) Watkins Glen State Park Family built, owned, and managed since 2022. Be our guest!

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 153 reviews

Guest favorite

A spacious deck with two dark wooden chairs overlooks a serene beach scene. A cup rests on a small table, and beyond, two colorful lounge chairs are positioned on the sandy shore. The calm waters of Lake Ontario reflect a clear blue sky.

Cottage in Town of Sterling

Wes Anderson Lake Cottage | Beach, Deck & Kayaks

Escape to our Wes Anderson stylish, solar-powered lakefront cottage on Lake Ontario with private beach, stunning sunsets, and room for families or friends to unwind. Just 10 minutes from Fair Haven, this 3-bedroom, 2 bath retreat is perfect for beach days, cozy nights, and peaceful weekend getaways. Wake up to lake views, relax on the private beach, and explore Upstate New York's scenic wonders. Wander bluffs, swim in the lake, stroll along the beach, or unwind on the lakeside deck.

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 87 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Skaneateles

Spotless ranch 2 miles to village & beautiful yard

This house is about 2 miles from the village, lake, restaurants, bars and most wedding venues. Enjoy the beauty of Skaneateles and then return to your own oasis on nearly an acre of manicured landscape with a wonderful deck overlooking a pond. Make time to watch the sunset with a glass of wine or the sunrise with your morning coffee . Coffee bar included with snacks. In the wintertime enjoy the wood stove (wood is provided but if you need more the Byrne Dairy has some) and games.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

Top guest favorite

The historic home features a spacious front yard adorned with vibrant yellow daffodils and various green shrubs. A covered porch is visible at the entrance, leading to the inviting façade. A blooming cherry tree adds a touch of color, framed by lush greenery in the background.

Home in Baldwinsville

The George Washington Suite

Step back in time in time as you enter the first-floor George Washington Suite in this 1790 historic home in Baldwinsville, NY. Period furniture blended with modern amenities provide for a luxurious stay. Park directly outside your suite and private front entrance. From your living room, step out onto the grand, columned back porch and stroll through the peaceful gardens. Sip your morning coffee on the patio beside the fountain or under the pergola while enjoying the gas fire pit.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 215 reviews

Top guest favorite

An inviting living area features large windows that allow natural light to fill the space. A neutral-toned sofa and seating chairs are arranged around a central area rug, while a stone fireplace adds a rustic touch. Greenery can be seen through the windows, connecting indoors and outdoors.

Home in Skaneateles

Sunset House- Beautiful Home with Gorgeous Vistas

Experience a home full of windows and light that take in breathtaking views from every angle. You feel like you are on top of the world surrounded by beautiful rural landscaping that is only 1.8 miles from the charming Village of Skaneateles! Lovely interior furnishings with your comfort in mind. You are within close reach to the Skaneateles Polo Fields, a free public boat launch, Skaneateles Country Club, wedding venues and a winery. This newer home is fresh, clean and cozy!

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 221 reviews

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area features warm wood flooring and a television on a modern console. A comfortable chair with a colorful throw pillow is positioned near a fireplace. Art pieces with muted tones are displayed on the wall, complementing the inviting atmosphere.

Home in Skaneateles

Newly updated, pet-friendly home in Skaneateles!

Relax at this peaceful place to stay right in Skaneateles! This cheerful, private, newly updated 2-bedroom residential home is close to town in a quiet neighborhood. Enjoy fun summer dinners on the large patio with gas grill. Walk or bike the short mile into town to enjoy Skaneateles Lake and all that our beautiful village has to offer! Shopping, dining, boating, hiking, wineries and breweries are all close by, ready to enjoy, no matter the season!

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews

Top guest favorite

A charming entrance showcases a blue exterior and a welcoming porch. A black grill is positioned on the right, complemented by a small wooden welcome mat. A glass-paneled door provides a view into the interior, framed by a well-maintained lawn.

Home in Cayuga

*The Cozy Cottage* on Cayuga Lake

Find your peace overlooking the lake in this cozy and cute cottage! This two bedroom ranch home is perfect for a couples getaway or a family of four to escape to the Finger Lakes region for some much needed relaxation. This house is located on the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, making it a great home base for a wine tasting weekend. The yard is a double lake lot, making it big enough for the kids and dogs to play and enjoy all that lake life has to offer.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews