Places to stay in Bay Shore

An expansive deck is furnished with a glass table and several lounge chairs, providing ample seating for relaxation. Potted plants add a touch of greenery. The serene water view reflects a clear sky dotted with light clouds, enhancing the outdoor atmosphere.

5 out of 5 average rating, 55 reviews

Turtle Dove Cozy Gem on the Bay

Keep it simple at this peaceful centrally-located Unit on the Great South Bay. Everything fully stock get you started at our New 1 Bedroom 2 Full Size Beds, Living Room/Dinning /Kitchen & Bathroom. Have coffee or tea from our coffee bar. Put on your robes and sit outside and enjoy a beautiful sunrise. Relax on deck as you gaze at the water while watching the boats. Walk 2-4 blocks to Town Restaurants, Shopping, Pubs, Fire Island Ferry, Long Island Railroad, SSUH Hospital. Drive minutes to Beach

A garden area features a wooden chair next to a small round table. The table holds a potted plant with colorful flowers. A wooden fence in the background is adorned with decorative arrangements and a flower accent, while lush ferns line the ground.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

♡Cozy 1Br Apt,Garden Patio & Off Street Parking♡

Welcome to Bay Shore! Natural light oozes into this cozy 1 bedroom, private bath,Apartment with new hardwood floors & windows. As a BONUS, there is a private patio. Enter slider in the back of the house. Guest has a designated parking spot in driveway. Work from the patio & enjoy the outdoors with the fast 1024 Mpbs WIFI. 4.5 miles - Good Samaritan Hospital. Ideal with kitchen for travelling nurses, doctors & interns looking for a long term stay. I hope you will love my space as much as I do!!

Superhost

A spacious outdoor area features well-maintained landscaping with a gravel driveway leading up to a two-story residence. Lush greenery surrounds the property, complemented by a fountain set in the garden. Clear blue skies enhance the inviting and serene environment.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 313 reviews

Amazing Fully Furnished near Fire Island Ferries

*Alternative to High Priced Fire Island yet minutes away! *Amazing Fully Furnished Ground level apartment with Office, Private Front Entrance and Private Deck *Daily, Weekly, Monthly. Seasonal rates "Hotel Style Setting- Turn-key Apartment *Centrally located within all major roadways on Long Island *Close to Westfield Mall and Downtown Main Street with many restaurants and bars. ****Great spot for those who got kicked out by wifey/hubby NO PARTIES PHOTO SHOOTS!!!

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews

An outdoor fire pit table is shown, featuring a warm flame surrounded by decorative glass beads. Two light blue adirondack chairs are positioned nearby, complemented by a tropical green plant in the background, creating a cozy atmosphere for gatherings.

Apartment in Deer Park

Best Studio-Private Entrance+Parking-Close To All

Make yourself at home! This Deer Park Den is your perfect suburban getaway in the heart of Long Island, close to everything and right in the middle of all the fun. Walking distance to lots of great restaurants that give you plenty of great options for ordering in or dining out. Other local destinations include: - Tanger outlets (1 Mile) - Heartland Golf Park (1.5 Miles) - Edgewood Oak Brush Plains Preserve (0.5 Mile) - Robert Moses state park (12 Miles) - Sunken Meadow state park (12 miles)

Apartment in Islip Terrace

An outdoor seating area is set up with wicker chairs surrounding a gas fire pit, glowing warmly in the evening light. A well-maintained green lawn and white privacy fence create a serene backdrop, with soft string lights enhancing the inviting atmosphere.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Near all! - Full Kitchen, Backyard & Fire Pit!

Come enjoy this beautifully renovated full 1 bedroom apartment with a full kitchen, living room with sofa/futon for a 3rd guest, bedroom, bathroom, and a sun-soaked backyard. Separate, Private entrance and off-street parking available for 1 car. Well-appointed for long-term stays or quick trips. This is a first-floor, ground-level apartment that gets lots of natural light. It is not a basement! :) Located in a quiet neighborhood and near all major highways. SmartTV. No cable TV :)

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Home in Commack

GOOD VIBEZ HOUSE! Mini Golf-Pool-Hot Tub-GameRoom!

STAY. SOMEWHERE. DIFFERENT. This isn’t just a stay—it’s an experience. Welcome to THE GOOD VIBEZ HOUSE! Your private escape in the heart of Long Island. This smart home is located in a safe, quiet neighborhood, this unique retreat is the perfect getaway from the hustle and bustle of the city or everyday life. From the moment you arrive, it feels like vacation. As Superhosts, we go beyond hosting—with warm hospitality, thoughtful touches, and a five-star atmosphere you won’t forget.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 273 reviews

A side view of the guest suite reveals a private entrance with a white door and small steps leading up to it. A winding stone walkway is bordered by grass and gardens, providing access to the suite in a serene outdoor setting.

Guest suite in Bay Shore

Bay Shore's Private Guest Suite

Welcome to our cozy guest suite nestled within walking distance of the Fire Island ferries and conveniently close to local amenities! This private unit, attached to the main part of our home, offers a comfortable retreat for your stay. Step through your own private entrance into a welcoming living room, where you can unwind after a day of exploration. The bedroom features a queen-sized bed, providing a restful night's sleep, and an adjoining bathroom offers convenience and privacy.

Apartment in West Babylon

A full bathroom is presented, featuring a bathtub with a shower curtain adorned in a floral pattern. A sleek vanity with a white countertop and a mirror above provides functional space. Natural light filters through the window, illuminating the earthy tile accents.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews

Loft 36 | King Sized Spacious Apartment

Welcome to Loft 36. A modern *private upstairs apartment* in a safe residential Long Island Neighborhood. Spacious and fully furnished with a private keyless entrance. Centrally located in the heart of WEST BABYLON. We are a quick trip to Babylon Village shops, bars, and restaurants, Tanger Outlets, Jones Beach, Robert Moses, and Marina Beaches. Ferries to Fire Island also close by. About an hour drive to New York City via nearby expressway or a 65 minute railroad ride.

5 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Cozy Bay Shore Hideaway

Welcome to your modern, cozy hideaway for one or two! Located in a private house, this charming retreat offers a dedicated parking spot, a private entrance, and a serene patio. Inside, enjoy a cozy and immersive living area, a well-equipped kitchenette, and a restful bedroom with a large bed creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. Perfect for exploring the local area or unwinding comfortably. This is the ideal spot for a memorable getaway.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

An open-concept kitchen and dining area is bathed in natural light, featuring a spacious island with bar seating. A wooden dining table with stylish chairs faces large windows, allowing views of the outdoor space. Warm wood tones complement the modern cabinetry and fixtures.

Home in Bay Shore

Bay Shore Boat House

Waterfront retreat with stunning views, a designer kitchen, serene interiors, and outdoor amenities including a fire pit, bluestone raised patio, and cabana bar. Ideal for couples and families. Walking distance to downtown Bay Shore, close to Fire Island Ferries and Captain Bill's. Unwind, fish off the dock, and witness unforgettable sunsets. Your perfect escape awaits.

A lively evening scene at the Boulton Center YMCA is captured, showcasing a marquee displaying upcoming events. Soft lighting from the marquee contrasts with the darkened surroundings. Parked cars line the street, and nearby storefronts add to the vibrant atmosphere of the area.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Stay downtown & walk to Fire Island ferries

Spacious, private, ground floor space located in a mid-19th Century Mansard Victorian in Historic Bay District of downtown Bay Shore. Steps to dozens of restaurants, a spray park, beach, and ferry. 10 minute walk from LIRR. Child friendly. Please note that host’s family lives in the main house. Ask us about special add-ons to enhance your stay!

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 380 reviews

The kitchen cabinet displays a set of patterned mugs and four clear drinking glasses. The clean and organized layout emphasizes accessibility, with cups and glasses arranged on two shelves. A paper towel roll is visible on the bottom shelf, alongside an electrical outlet.

Apartment in Brentwood

Eco-friendly studio with Private entrance

We have created this quaint space with our guest in mind in order to keep it simple at this peaceful and centrally-located place. Studio apartment with your own entrance, kitchen , bathroom, queen size bed and work area. Self check-in. All the amenities of a super host.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Houses

A space thats all yours, with room for everyone

Apartments

Convenient locations with everyday essentials

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Popular amenities for Bay Shore places to stay

Self check-in

Gym

BBQ grill

Laptop-friendly workspace

Wifi

Other great vacation rentals in Bay Shore

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Inside a wooden cupboard, a variety of glassware is neatly arranged. On the upper shelf, several clear glasses and tall vases are visible, while the lower shelf features white mugs with handles, all positioned for easy access.

Guest suite in Bay Shore

New Renovated Guest Suite with Private Entrance

MarkRating, 5 stars10 months ago

the suite was clean and in a convenient location for places on the south shore of Suffolk County on Long Island. the owner was responsive when contacted through the app.

5 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

A modern kitchen features sleek white cabinetry and stainless steel appliances. Natural light streams through a window, illuminating the granite countertops. A dual basin sink and a spacious refrigerator add functionality, while recessed lighting enhances the bright and airy atmosphere.

Home in Deer Park

Home in Deer Park, New York

MichaelRating, 5 stars2 days ago

My family and I loved staying here. The house was really clean, within driving distance to restaurants and perfect for 4 adults. The next time we come to Long Island we will definitely check to see if Jose’s home is available.

A circular arrangement of five outdoor chairs surrounds a stone fire pit, which contains a small flame. Lush greenery and tall trees provide a natural backdrop, creating a cozy atmosphere for gatherings. The grassy area is well-maintained, offering a tranquil outdoor setting.

Guest suite in Islip

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 332 reviews

South Shore Beauty in the Woods

VictorRating, 5 stars3 days ago

Diana's place was so peaceful quiet private and it had beautiful surroundings! She is very responsive and friendly. tha place was nice clean and pretty cozy. There are a plethora of food options around and there's also shopping areas at driving distance. When we hace the chance we will definitely return!

Superhost

A modern kitchen is shown featuring stainless steel appliances, including a refrigerator and stove. A small table with a brown tablecloth is positioned near the entrance. The space is illuminated by recessed lighting, and wood laminate flooring extends throughout the area.

Apartment in Brentwood

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Home away your home

GeraldineRating, 5 stars1 month ago

The place is located in a peaceful area and close to a LIRR at 5 minutes, stores are very accessible as well best of all laundry mat. The only thing was morning hours if you're a light sleeper like me you'll hear the upstairs family a lot. But i didn't mind the place is very clean, and cozy. My boyfriend and I love it! and host was very responsive and friendly!

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Home in Oakdale

Riverfront Retreat in Oakdale

JannetaRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Our stay at the house was wonderful experience. Our host Michael whom fortunately we met personally is one of the nicest person you’ll encounter in life. The surrounding and the grounds were so beautiful that you will enjoy when you stay at that house. Many thanks to our host and his well managed house. The place is very close to all lovely restaurants, shopping areas, etc. We all highly appreciated and recommend to stay at this place for any occasion and vacation. Thank you again and hopefully will stay in the future. Your guest Janneta 😀❤️

A modern kitchen features navy blue cabinetry accompanied by stainless steel appliances. A large refrigerator sits prominently, while a sleek stove is positioned near the countertop. A blue rug adds a pop of color to the space, and a well-organized layout promotes functionality.