House vacation rentals in West Tisbury

Joshua's place was the PERFECT place for our dad's 70th birthday! The 9 kids had an amazing time between the pool and game barn there was constant entertainment for all ages! If you have a big family/group this is the spot!

We loved are family stay at Paul & Katie’s home for Easter Week. It is a dream home . The neighborhood was beautiful and walkable, with a peaceful path to a private beach. We enjoyed the shops and restaurants in Mashpee Commons about an 8 minute drive away.

We had a wonderful stay here in New Seabury! The house is beautiful, spacious and just as described. The heated pool was an added bonus! Michael provided prompt and clear communication when needed. I would absolutely stay here again!

We had such a fantastic stay at Sue’s beautiful Edgartown home! The house was charming, spotless, and well-stocked with everything we needed—from kids’ toys and extra keys to cozy spaces for the whole family. Even with some chilly weather, we made great memories thanks to Sue’s warmth and hospitality. One huge highlight was the car rental—what a convenient bonus! It was clean, reliable, and made exploring the island a breeze. Sue was responsive and thoughtful throughout our stay, checking in with helpful suggestions and going above and beyond. She truly made us feel at home. From shell picking at Felix Neck to relaxing in the playroom and enjoying everything the Vineyard has to offer, our family had a wonderful time. We’re already talking about our next trip back—and hoping Sue’s hot tub addition is ready by then! Highly recommend!

Emily was so kind and responsive and the house was exactly as expected. The walk to the beach was lovely and doable with the toddlers thanks to the wagon provided. It was a quick drive into all things Falmouth and a great home base for us. The stand outs for everyone were how comfy the beds were and we were all obsessed with the outdoor shower. Loved all the thoughtful amenities, such as games and kids dinnerware. Overall very stylish and comfortable. Highly recommend.

Wonderful place to stay! So comfortable and lots of space! Close to lots of restaurants and shopping! Would definitely stay again!

We had a great stay at this place! The house was exactly as described—clean, comfortable, and well-stocked with everything we needed. Check-in was smooth, and the host provided clear instructions throughout. The neighborhood was quiet and convenient, with easy access to local attractions and restaurants. Would definitely recommend this spot to anyone visiting the area!

Beautiful house. Kid friendly Really close to the beach Amazing hosts

The home was clean and cozy. Updated decor and well supplied with everything we would need. I would stay again.

While the weather did not cooperate (it rained the entire time) the cottage and views made up for the weather. From the table to the couch the views are wonderful. The cottage is very well stocked from towels and blankets to the kitchen. We did not need anything that wasn't supplied. The bathroom is small but functional. The shower might not work well for a larger person. The neighborhood is quiet and feels very safe and peaceful. We enjoyed our long weekend and would book this cottage again.

We loved the location at the end of a little road so no through traffic (fresh eggs next door too). The pond is fun with lots of wildlife, sometimes we could hear the roosters next door. The sunsets are lovely from the home as well. Seating in the living room great and found it to be quiet when sleeping at night. The two bedrooms on the lower level both have heat pumps (for heat/cooling) we have always had great luck with (for temperature control in the bedrooms). Loved sitting on the back deck and having the resident geese wandering around. Lovely property!

We traveled with 4 couples who have know each other since HS, 40 years ago. It was a great home to relax and catch up. The house is lovely and we loved that we each had our full bath! I highly recommend this home and this location.

We had an amazing time and would love to come again! The location was perfect, close to the beach and away from the busier parts of the island. I definitely recommend staying here for a relaxing vacation.

Elizabeth is a wonderful host - responsive and friendly. The home is lovely and just a short walk from town. The living area has an open floor plan, with a well appointed kitchen and lots of comfortable living room furniture - a nice space for hanging out in the evenings. The beds are very comfortable and the bedrooms are quiet. The bathrooms were very clean and showers have great water pressure. There's a very thorough guest guide with everything you need to know about the house... heat, tv, garbage, etc... plus lots of helpful recommendations for restaurants, shopping and attractions. A great house whether you're traveling with family or friends - we felt very much at home.

Beautifully remodeled home, lovely setting on a large pond. Everything was clean, the kitchen was well stocked. I am an avid cook/home chef and appreciate the decent cookware. So many places have understocked kitchens and wounded cookware. Comfortable King bed. Thoughtfully decorated. Nice quiet neighborhood. We travel with our 13 year old boxer who has traveled the country and we appreciated the one level living. We did not mind being farther from town, we love the wildlife and the beautiful swan swimming on the pond! The host, Benjamin, was easy to get ahold of, though we had no issues with anything at all. The booklet on Salt Crystal that was sent ahead to us was extremely helpful to us! We would definitely stay here again!

Lisa was a fantastic host. Her beautiful home was the perfect getaway. We had everything we could possibly need in this home. I couldn’t praise Lisa more. Count yourselves lucky to stay at such a wonderful property on an amazing island. 10/10… would stay again in a heartbeat.

We had such a nice time staying in this home! It was beautifully decorated and was extremely clean. We felt right at home during our visit. We had a hiccup at the start of our stay but our host was very quick responsive. I really enjoyed my stay and hope to be back

Lovely spot near end of a cul de sac, great water views and light. Joel was proactive and responsive in communication.

We loved our stay! The house was beautiful, immaculate, spacious, and well-stocked. The location was perfect, we walked into Edgartown every day, and rented bikes to get to the beach. Amy was super responsive and the house manual she provided in advance had all of the info we needed. The only downside was construction on a neighboring house— the work was noisy and a little disruptive, and large construction vehicles sometimes blocked the road getting into and out of the house. No fault of Amy’s, though, and hopefully the work will be done soon!

Patricia was very responsive before and during our stay. She was easy to communicate with and gave great suggestions for beaches to visit. The house is about a 10 minute drive from the closest beach. It’s near water but it’s more for fishing or boating. It’s less than 10 minutes from the center of town where there are great places to eat and shop around. The house is beautiful and spacious. Two bedrooms and a full bathroom on the main level and 2 bedrooms and a full bathroom the second level. Highly recommend.

Glenn’s place was outstanding! His hospitality and thoughtfulness was apparent throughout the house and through our entire stay. The view was beautiful for watching boats and sunrises. The location was also centrally located for a trip to Boston or taking a ferry to Martha’s Vineyard or Nantucket. Glenn was very attentive to our needs and checked in on us via message periodically throughout our stay. Thank you for an amazing weekend!

Charming house, conveniently located with grocery stores, fish market with fresh fish and seafood and restaurants nearby. Kitchen generously stocked, bathrooms clean and well equipped. We had everything we needed for a short family vacation including beach chairs and towels. Kim is a great host!

The home was cozy and well maintained. Very peaceful surroundings and close to the Main Street shops and restaurants. Andrea was great responding with any questions or issues that arose.

Excellent host. This place by far is the most kid friendly house I’ve rented. So many accommodations for my three children, including a high chair, pack n play, outdoor mud kitchen, endless toys and books upstairs and downstairs. Lauren also let us borrow her beach toys for our beach days. The house is very cute with colorful decor and local art, it was fun for us to admire the art work. The house is half of a two family unit, but it felt very private, couldn’t even tell there is another unit next door. She did a great job setting up screens and growing plants to provide privacy. Location was top notch, easy drive to all the local places, has two car parking if we want to bike to places. I would definitely come back here.