Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Tompkins County

We booked this home after changing our trip dates and losing the original house we rented. Boy, was it worth it!! The home is Beautiful! The views, natural light, huge master bathroom, and the most comfortable couch were just some of our favorite things. One of the bedrooms had kids' books and toys, and it was perfect for our 4-year-old daughter. The owners' communication with us was at its best! We look forward to returning next year!

Booked this place to celebrate a my birthday with some friends. We had 12 people and we had plenty of room for everyone. Check in/out was very easy, and everything that was said to be included was. The room with the pool table was a great hangout spot and is bigger than how it looks in the pictures. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone with a larger group of people. We had an excellent stay!

The views of the lake were beautiful and so peaceful and private. The home was very comfortable and close to Cornell. Dominic gave great instructions - it was a lovely weekend.

We had a wonderful stay! The house itself is beautiful and well-maintained, and we felt right at home there. Jennifer was incredibly responsive and accommodating, allowing us to check in early and check out late which was a huge help. We truly enjoyed our stay and would highly recommend this property to anyone looking for a relaxing getaway.

Great safe and quiet neighborhood, clean pet friendly house and a park for dog walking one block away. traveling with a pet doesnt get any better and even though its on the "Cornell" side of town we have used it twice for Ithaca College events. juat a short 10-15 minute drive. Mary is super nice and reaponsive. Very highly reccommend.

We just enjoyed our 4-night stay at the house with 6 adults and a 3-yr-old. It had “most” amenities, was close to Ithaca and spacious enough for our crew. Three of us ran the Ithaca Gorges Half Marathon this weekend so we chose this place bc it’s right next to the Black Diamond Trail, where the race is. Pros: ample parking, location, view, yard space, easiest check-in, right next to the Black Diamond Trail, have filtered water faucet, firepit / grill setup, Barry (host) was very responsive, lots of older books/games/DVDs in home. Cons: water smells like sulfur so laundry room smelled while doing laundry and the water was a little brown when we bathed our son in the tub (after its initial spurt of really brown water…rusty pipes?), had to dig around for more hand soap, toilet paper and hand towels, had to use a putty knife to cut a pizza, house wasn’t spotless clean, oven put off a strong gas smell. Overall it met our needs for the price, and we had a great time! Thanks Barry!

We really enjoyed our stay. Tracie is a wonderful host and the house was very well appointed with attention to every detail. The living spaces are warm and inviting. The weekend we were there the weather did not cooperate--despite that we had some great quality time as a family both in and out of the house! We look forward to having the opportunity to stay there again!

Really wonderful host and great space. So easily walkable to town! A complete pleasure

Location was perfect, was able to access all the hiking, lakes, center of town, and farms within 20 min from this stay. Had a great time had everything we needed.

Thank you Suzanne! We enjoyed our stay and it was in great proximity of Cornell for our son's graduation. Just a couple of really small things to enhance guests' future stays. WD-40 on the bathroom doors and a little more comfortable sleeping pillows. Everything else was just great and we had an amazing weekend. The views of the pond and beyond and the serernity was just beautiful. The space was perfect for us. Thank you so much!

Three of us stayed at Peggy’s place for a weekend and my only regret is not booking for longer! The location is a dream—right on the lake and only a few minutes drive from the farmer’s market and other must-see places in Ithaca. I hope to come back!

We had such a great time at Andrew’s place! He was super helpful and gave us awesome tips on what to do around. The house looks just like the pictures, the beds are super comfy, and the coffee was amazing. Totally worth it!

The place was spacious and relaxing. It had a lot of charm - we loved the old farmhouse feel - and it had everything we needed. I appreciate little things like the electric tea kettle, and that there were extra towels in each bathroom. David was very responsive and helped when we had a small issue, but gave us plenty of space / privacy. We hope to return sometime soon!

Great place in the Finger Lakes area. Katie was very responsive and helpful. Very quiet place.

We stayed in the south wing suite and had a great stay. We have family in the area and this will be our go to place after staying in many other airbnb's in the area. Beautiful house to explore and walking distance to town. Jes was a pleasure to work with. See you again soon!

We stayed here for Cornell’s graduation and couldn’t have picked a better spot. The apartment is right in Collegetown—just a 5-minute walk to campus (though uphill, so be ready for a bit of a workout!). The location was perfect: quiet, convenient, and close to everything. The host was incredibly friendly and responsive—always quick to answer any questions or accommodate our needs. Would definitely stay again next time we're in Ithaca!