Vacation rentals in Sunset Bay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sunset Bay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favorite

A serene outdoor space features a fire pit surrounded by several blue and red chairs, overlooking a calm beach. The sandy shore meets the tranquil water, with lush greenery framing the area and a walkway leading to the beach in the background.

Home in Irving

The Seaglass Shack

Newly renovated 4 bedroom 2 bath house on Lake Erie in a private community. The master bedroom has a queen bed and full bath and outdoor deck.. The second bath also houses the laundry. The second bedroom has a queen bed the third bedroom has two twin beds. There is a loft area reached by a library ladder that has a sitting area and 5 mattresses on floor The kitchen has all new appliances and open to living and dining area. An enclosed porch open onto a large deck There is direct beach access.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the charming home features dark wood siding and classic white trim. A welcoming front porch is adorned with potted plants, and two large windows allow natural light to fill the interior. An American flag is displayed, enhancing the home's character.

Apartment in Silver Creek

Cozy Bay Getaway

Soak up the modern & vintage charm of this 1 bedroom independant apartment attached to our 160 yr old charming home by the bay. Queen sized temperpedic adjustable bed in the bedroom . Original modern an vintage artwork. 2 large screen TV's Wifi Fluffy bathtowels body soap. Full small but complete kitchen . Bottled water. pots & pans. Dishes cutlery glass ware. Walk to eaterys grocery pharmacy . 5 min drive to Sunset bay beach & beach club. Perfect getaway for a couple that needs to unwind

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Guest favorite

A charming cottage exterior is framed by lush greenery and colorful flowers. A welcoming sign hangs above the entryway, and two chairs are positioned on the porch, inviting relaxation. The blue shutters complement the white siding, enhancing the home's quaint appeal.

Cottage in Irving

Charming Cottage by the Lake

This quaint, well-maintained cottage is a perfect getaway to the beach. Located a short walk down a private drive to our community lake access, it has a fully fenced backyard and patio with grill, three bedrooms, well-appointed, updated eat-in kitchen, charming dining room, cozy living room with working fireplace, and a comfortable family room. You are five minutes from Evangola State Park, and close to Sunset Bay, SUNY Fredonia, Brooks Memorial Hospital, and Frank Lloyd Wright's Graycliff.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Irving

Lotus Bay Cabin- all seasons oasis

*8-person stand alone hot tub open Dec.-April* *In-ground pool with spill over hot tub & pool house open May 1st, 2026* Winter, Spring is that you? A drink in the above ground hot tub (or pool & hot tub), meals in the fully stocked kitchen, movies on the spacious sectional, reading in the sunroom, bomb-fires under the dark sky & gorgeous sunsets, walks and seasonal swimming along Lake Erie…simply cannot go wrong! Wine country, beaches, ski resorts, Buffalo & Niagara Falls all nearby

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 236 reviews

Guest favorite

Tiny home in Silver Creek

Waterview Cottage

Welcome to our Waterfront Boutique Resort nestled on the picturesque shores of Lake Erie, where tranquility meets adventure. Our idyllic property is a haven for those seeking both luxurious relaxation and exhilarating outdoor experiences. With its own 400 feet of sandy beach Hideaway Bay Resort offers a unique blend of natural beauty, modern comforts, and endless opportunities for fun and relaxation. Indulge in the convince of an onsite restaurant and bar, creating the perfect getaway.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Top guest favorite

A serene beachfront scene captures a calm stretch of sand leading to a body of water reflecting soft pastel hues of a sunset. The sky features light clouds, creating a tranquil atmosphere over the horizon.

Cottage in Angola

Beachfront House for Family Fun or Romantic Escape

Perched atop a secluded dune, our stylish 4-season, beachfront home overlooks a stretch of the beautiful Lake Erie shoreline. Take the stairs to a private sandy beach where you can relax, stroll, swim, fish, or marvel at the sunsets. Our home is family friendly featuring a smart TV, free WiFI, fully appointed kitchen, 4 comfortable BR, 3 baths. Need provisions or a night out? You’ll find several restaurants and nightclubs, and the Buffalo Bills Stadium are a short distance away.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Top guest favorite

A modern kitchen is highlighted, featuring stainless steel appliances, a sleek countertop, and a wooden dining table with chairs. A cozy nook with decorative pillows is visible, alongside a vase of blossoms on the countertop, enhancing the inviting atmosphere of the space.

Cottage in Angola

The Lovejoy Cottage • Walk to Beach, Sleeps 10, AC

Welcome to The Lovejoy Cottage, a recently renovated 5 bedroom retreat near Lake Erie. Accommodating up to 10 guests, the cottage is perfect for families or friends seeking a relaxing beach vacation. Bedrooms have fresh linens and blackout curtains. Kid-friendly with new appliances, fully equipped kitchen, covered porch, back deck, outdoor eating area, yard space, and fire chimney. A 5-minute walk to the beach through the town park, with restaurants within walking distance.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

Top guest favorite

A two-story house is set against a backdrop of green trees and grass. The entrance features a set of front steps leading to a welcoming porch. Large windows are visible, allowing natural light to illuminate the space.

Home in Irving

Peaceful waterfront paradise

Take it easy at this remodelled, well stocked, peaceful, family friendly, vacation spot. Fish, swim, kayak, golf, visit wineries or just watch nature. Located in Sunset Bay, a beautiful sandy beach on Lake Erie, 10 minute walk away. This is a beach community, during the summer it is very active, two beach bars in the bay. There are boat launches nearby. Trains pass nearby, which may disturb your sleep. This area is 40-50 min. drive to the Buffalo/Niagara Falls area.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a two-story lake house is shown, featuring a front porch with white railings. Lush greenery surrounds the home, including well-maintained bushes and trees. A welcoming path leads to the entrance, creating a tranquil and inviting atmosphere.

Home in Angola

Lake Breeze Retreat

Escape to this cozy lake house, nestled in a cottage community with breathtaking sunset views and just a short walk to a private beach. Whether you’re looking to unwind by the water, soak up the sun, or enjoy peaceful evenings under the stars, this is the perfect spot to relax and recharge. Whether you're planning a family vacation, a romantic getaway, or a retreat with friends, this lake house offers the ideal combination of privacy, nature, and comfort.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Angola

Private Beach 600' at end of street!

600 feet from Private beach in great peaceful neighborhood. Enjoy gentle breezes off the lake under the covered patio or walk to the huge private beach and enjoy the sunsets! The living room and kitchen have beautiful hardwood floors and the cathedral ceilings give it a spacious open feel. The large yard is great for kids to play. Some board games and kids toys are included. This is a brand new, fresh and clean property!!

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

Guest favorite

The exterior of a beach cottage is shown, featuring a gray wooden facade and a welcoming deck. A pair of bright red umbrellas provide shade over outdoor seating surrounded by colorful flowers and lush greenery, enhancing the charm of the space.

Cottage in Irving

2 bedroom - Beach Cottage- Fun in the sand & sun

Our little beach cottage in Sunset Bay has all the perks of home. Our little cottage is within walking distance to the beach, the bars (Cabana Sam's / Sunset Bay Beach Club / Sportsman's Restaurant) and located across the street from the Sunset Bay State Marine Park. Our Place is a 6 night minimum from June 15- Sept 1 before or after that if an inquiry is sent for less days we will accept the offer if it's available.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Silver Creek

Charming Vintage House by the Creek - Downtown!

Relax in this charming 4-bedroom vintage home in downtown Silver Creek. Enjoy a private creekside yard, spacious living areas perfect for gatherings, an enclosed front porch, and a covered back porch for year-round comfort. Just steps away from local shops and cafes, this cozy retreat blends vintage charm with modern convenience- perfect for families, friends, or a peaceful getaway.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews