Vacation rentals in Sugarloaf Key

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sugarloaf Key

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

A covered Tiki Hut is featured at the waterfront, furnished with comfortable seating arrangements. Views of the water and dock are visible beyond the structure, framed by lush greenery and palm trees. The space is designed for relaxation and enjoyment of the serene surroundings.

Home in Key Colony Beach

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Captain’s Quarters Ahoy Mateys! Florida, Keys

This is located at the Florida Keys in Key Colony, Marathon. It is a spacious two bedroom, two bathroom duplex surrounded by water. It is a renovated beauty and close to the best restaurants and the tranquility of this city. It is the perfect getaway where you can recharge your exhausted batteries. Captain’s Quarters is a clean and spacious base camp location for the many adventures that await you in this amazing location. Water views and the accessibility to the best fishing in the world.

Superhost

A sandy beach area is framed by swaying palm trees, leading to a two-story bungalow elevated on stilts. Lounge chairs are arranged on the shore, providing a relaxing spot, while kayaks are visible in the background, enhancing the inviting beach setting.

Home in Upper Sugarloaf Key

4.74 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Palm - Beach Houses Key West

If you’re reading this, you’re already on the path to paradise! Thank you for considering us for your dream vacation—we can’t wait to host you. Experience the charm of our recently renovated, one-of-a-kind two-bedroom beach bungalow, nestled right on the shore. Enjoy breathtaking ocean views from your private deck, relax on the sandy beach, and soak in the tropical ambiance. This family-friendly retreat offers the perfect setting to make you feel like you’re on your very own private island.

Top guest favorite

Home in Cudjoe Key

5 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

Oceanfront Cottage with Open Water Views

Oceanviev Serenity provides stunning open water views, and a 60 foot seawall for your boat. Comes with paddle board, kayaks, and more. Newly renovated 2BR cottage sleeps MAXIMUM OF FOUR (4) GUESTS, with a King in the Master BR and one Queen size bed Guest BR (both with new JW Marriott mattresses for comfort). All new appliances! Enjoy resort amenities like a pool, hot tub, tennis, and marina store. Just 30 minutes from Key West. $125 RESORT FEE DUE AT CHECK-IN (PER STAY, NOT PER PERSON).

Superhost

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Tropical Paradise

Oceanfront home with private pool, boat dock, kayaks, and private beach Tropical Paradise has been a popular and romantic vacation rental getaway since 2003. There are kayaks for adventures, a dipping pool and private beach for relaxation, a floating dock for fishing and docking a boat, (up to 24' boat allowed) screened in porch for dining There are 2 king bedrooms, 3rd bedroom has a queen with trundle 2 1/2 bath. This home has an open floor plan and recently remodeled kitchen.

Guest favorite

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews

Ocean~View w/ Dock, Pool, Kayaks, King Bed

Experience waterfront luxury in Venture Out on peaceful Cudjoe Key! Enjoy stunning Atlantic Ocean views, amazing sunsets, a 35' canal-front seawall, kayaks, bikes, outdoor shower, fish cleaning station & bait freezer. Keep your boat at the house and reach the Atlantic or Gulf in minutes. Near Key West, this updated Keys getaway includes resort amenities: heated pool, hot tub, pickleball courts, boat launch & store. Prime dates go fast, especially lobster season in August, so book now!

Guest favorite

An aerial view showcases the resort's central pool surrounded by palm trees and landscaped gardens. The inviting pool area is complemented by a spacious pavilion with a metal roof, providing a gathering space. The background features the resort's accommodations and the lush natural environment.

Condo in Summerland Key

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Family Suite at Sugarloaf Key Hotel (Pet Friendly)

Discover the perfect blend of comfort, relaxation and adventure at the Sugarloaf Key Hotel, nestled within the Sugarloaf Key / Key West KOA Resort campground. Newly built in 2023, this beautiful 6-person pet-friendly vacation suite offers everything you need for a great stay. Nestled amongst gorgeous tropical scenery, this resort includes robust amenities including resort-style pool and hot tub with an adjacent pub, quaint sand beach, marina, water rentals, café, camp store and more!

Superhost

A waterfront property is surrounded by lush palm trees, with a gravel area leading to a private dock. The home is painted in soft blue tones, reflecting a comfortable coastal vibe. The expansive water views offer shimmering reflections under the clear sky.

Cottage in Little Torch Key

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews

Waterfront Cozy Cottage with Boat Ramp & Dock!

Welcome to Paradise! Stay in the amazing Keys and beautiful waterfront home with 250 foot dock, ramp, and basin for your boat. It's a must-see rustic outdoor environment and fishery experience, very typical in the Keys! The property lot is almost an acre with a work section and still very spacious. Stunning panoramic water views, sunrise and sunset. Steps away from ocean water. Bring or rent fishing and snorkel gear nearby to fish right off the dock and enjoy the underwater scenery!

Superhost

An aerial view captures a vibrant community of stilt homes nestled along the coastline, with clear blue waters stretching in the background. Lush palm trees dot the landscape, while a distinctive red marker indicates a specific location within this scenic setting.

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Spanish Queen @Venture Out

Experience the beautiful Florida Keys and stay at the popular Venture Out Private Community at Cudjoe Key. Newly furnished two-bedroom, 2 bath stilt home checks all the boxes for the ultimate Florida Keys Vacation. Sun- filled open floor plan allows family to spend the their precious time together cooking and entertaining. Two-2 person kayaks and 4 bikes included *** Please note that guests must pay a resort entry fee of $125 directly to security upon entry into the park***

Guest favorite

A heated pool is surrounded by a spacious deck, featuring lounge chairs and a dining table with blue chairs. Beyond the pool, a pathway leads to lush greenery and the ocean view under a partly cloudy sky.

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Palm Breezes! Room for Everyone on the Ocean.

This 5 bedroom 3 bath house with pool on Ocean front property on Highway 1.. This lovely home has its own huge pool area with full lounge chairs all the way around pool area, the pool is heated. Grill, Jacuzzi. Full WiFi. TVs in every bedroom! Travel down our private dock way to the beautiful Cudjoe Bay, hop one of the many kayaks and take a healthy paddle with your friends/family or just enjoy the breathtaking ocean view while you sit on the porch.

Top guest favorite

A serene waterway is framed by charming homes, with a white boat bobbing gently at the dock. The sky displays a vibrant sunset in shades of orange and pink, reflecting softly on the calm water, creating a peaceful waterfront scene.

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

Waterfront, Dock, Pool, Pickleball, near Key West!

Welcome to “The Barnacle” your waterfront home in the Florida Keys! Dock your boat behind this charming two bedroom home with 35’ sea wall! We have direct access to some of the best fishing, snorkeling and diving in the Keys! Beautiful neighborhood loaded with amenities. Bring a pole and fish from the dock! Relax, enjoy and have a wonderful vacation experience. Visit YouTube “The Barnacle at Venture Out”. Swim, Fish, Dive …Repeat!

Superhost

A comfortable outdoor seating area is showcased, with bright blue cushions arranged around a dark table. The view overlooks crystal-clear waters, and decorative lanterns provide soft lighting. A potted flower adds a touch of color beside the seating, enhancing the peaceful ambiance by the water.

Home in Cudjoe Key

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

*Emerald Seas*-Florida Keys Ocean Front Paradise!

Welcome to our Florida Keys Ocean Paradise, Emerald Seas! Truly a special place to get away and relax. Enjoy the crystal-clear waters and amazing views. Bring or rent a boat, look for sea turtles, manatees, dolphins, lobster & tropical fish right from your patio or dock. Take in a glorious sunrise or moonlit night over the water. The amazing, 180 degree panoramic ocean views will take your breath away every moment you are there.

Superhost

Tiny home in Summerland Key

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviews

Cottage

Experience island living at Sugarloaf RV Resort's NEW Cottages in the Lower Keys, just 25 minutes from Key West. These Two-Bedroom Cottages sleep up to 4 guests with 2 Queen beds. Features include a kitchenette with double burner stovetop, dorm fridge, microwave, single serve coffee maker, toaster, plus outdoor seating. Coastal charm with keys-style design and a private patio perfect for morning coffee or sunset relaxation.