Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Starke County

We stayed at Casita del Lago for our honeymoon and couldn’t have been happier with it. The little house was incredibly clean, beautifully decorated, and had everything thought through and taken care of. How clean it was was a huge bonus to us and Vic and Jess were awesome every step of the way. There were so many nice little details; we really enjoyed how there was everything from a toaster and a coffeemaker to kayaks and bikes. The area is definitely a hidden gem with tons of great food, lakes and parks, and nice things to do close by (go visit Little Chocolates if that’s your thing. It’s a cute shop with wonderful handmade chocolates and caramel). We would definitely recommend this place and would stay here again for our next trip to Dune-land!

This Airbnb was such a peaceful escape beautifully put together with so much intention. The overall vibe was serene and calming, which was exactly what I needed. One of my favorite parts was the screened-in porch perfect for enjoying the fresh air without worrying about bugs. I also really appreciated the sound machines in every room; it was such a thoughtful touch that made sleeping even more restful. If you're looking for a stay that brings peace and comfort, this is the place. Highly recommend!

I rented Leah's home for my son's. They love to fish and Leah's home was the perfect place. They enjoyed the pontoon boat and sitting around the bonfire. The house was clean and kitchen equipped with everything needed for their weekend of grilling. Leah was a perfect host. Thank you, Michelle

Staying here felt like we had borrowed a friend's cabin. Checkin and checkout were super easy. A beautiful property that we will definitely come back to.

We had a girl’s getaway weekend at this lake house . We needed a place to simply relax and unwind, and Polly’s place provided just that. It is in a very peaceful location. We all enjoyed having our coffee/tea in the sunroom in the morning while listening to the birds. A couple of questions came up during our stay, and Polly and Jack were responsive and helpful. Polly even came over to be our photographer when we had an idea for some pictures on the staircase. She was a great sport. The kitchen was very well equipped, and the home was spotless. The fire-pit area and access to firewood was great . If there was any suggestion I could share, it would be to devise an easier way to utilize the paddle boat. We didn’t attempt it, because we don’t believe we could have got it in and out of the lake easily. Other than that, we had a great weekend. I would definitely recommend the property to anyone looking for a peaceful place to stay.

The place is absolutely beautiful and peaceful! We loved staying here and will definitely use in the future

This was ur second stay at Andrew’s and it didn’t disappoint. He worked with us last minute to make a reservation so we had somewhere to stay. A friend of ours passed away and we didn’t have a lot of planning time. We love that the place has a pack n play, high chair, and some kids toys & dishes. Things like that make a stay with children much smoother. Thanks again for another great experience.

We stayed here while we waited to close on our new home - they had kiddie toys ready to go, beautifully set/made rooms and beds, extremely friendly hosts, and the river out back is the COOLEST. We caught lots of fish in our week stay. Would absolutely stay again and recommend to friends and family

We were in town to visit family and the apartment was perfectly located. Clean, well-decorated, and very comfortable. Make sure you check out the bakery below in the morning!

The space is absolutely beautiful. We didn't know what to expect as this was our first time in the area, but my sister and I were very impress with the decor and nice and clean everything was. The rooms were a good size and we really enjoyed our stay. The host was very nice. We would definitely stay here again if and when we are in the area. Highly recommend.

We have stayed at locations hosted by Jennifer before and each visit has gone great. She has been super attentive both before and after the stay. Can't imagine what she could have done to make it any better.

Needed a place to stay in this cute little town for a family funeral service and it was just what we needed! Close to everything we needed and we were able to walk everywhere. Loved the big window in the living room area overlooking downtown and enjoyed the seating area across the street. The layout was fitting for our family and loved the children’s books for our youngest daughter. Cute place to stay and was clean. Host was great and responsive if/when we had any questions.

Loved my stay! The farm was gorgeous and so peaceful and rejuvenating. Wish I could’ve stayed longer and would definitely stay again. Dan and Suzanne were friendly and helpful and the apartment was comfortable, well-equipped and beautifully decorated. 5 stars!

It was an absolute BEAUTY of a stay. My husband and I literally booked it last minute. (1 hours before leaving) and the host immediately responded and was so friendly and kind. It’s about a two minute walk from the beach. Very quiet, the house has a lot to culture. I felt right at home, truly. Thank you Matthew !!

Great place, centrally located. 5 minute walk to Cafe Max and Main Street shops in one direction, and the Lakehouse Grille or Culver Coffee in the other, with Papa's just a couple minutes beyond that. The patio and main bedroom balcony are great for morning coffee and enjoying the view. Suzy was very responsive to messages. Will likely stay here again on the next trip.