Cottage vacation rentals in Silver Lake

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Silver Lake

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A large two-story house is surrounded by a well-maintained lawn featuring green grass and a variety of trees. The front porch is covered and supported by wooden beams, inviting outdoor gatherings. A clear blue sky complements the home, enhancing the serene setting.
Cottage in Perry
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews

16 Sandals

Come enjoy the friendly neighborhood in our cozy lake front home. Bring your fishing boats, kayaks, canoes and fishing poles! Spend the day on the lake or on our large lake view patio, then unwind at night at our fire pit or in the hot tub! Nearby, you can find a drive-in movie theater, mini golf and ice cream- fun for everyone! In the winter months, bring your snowmobiles to enjoy direct access to hundreds of miles of marked and groomed snowmobile trails including nearby Letchworth State Park.

Top guest favorite
A spacious living area features a comfortable couch and armchair arranged around a coffee table. A stone fireplace anchors one wall, while a dining table is positioned nearby. The kitchen area, visible in the background, is equipped with modern appliances and wooden cabinetry.
Cottage in Great Valley
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Country get away

Beautiful private country setting. Perfect spot to take in the fall foliage and count the stars as you sit around the fire. Newly remodeled cozy country cottage . Full kitchen and washer and dryer available . Perfect get away from the hustle and bustle of the city . Central location to all of the area attractions like Holiday Valley ski resort , Ellicottville shopping and restaurants and Seneca Allegany casino. WiFi and dish network provided in a clean and sanitized space. Gas grill available

Top guest favorite
A serene view of the lake at sunset captures the golden sun reflecting on the water's surface. A boat is moored at the dock, while the surrounding hills fade softly into the background, creating a calming and tranquil atmosphere.
Cottage in Honeoye
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Honeoye Haven

Enjoy Honeoye Lake in this recently remodeled year-round home. This three bedroom, 1.5 bath home has many oversized windows which offer postcard views of the surrounding Bristol Hills. The level yard and large deck open to over 50 ft of lakefront. Take advantage of the private dock for sunbathing or fishing. There is a grassy area for yard games, a fire pit for night-time marshmallow roasting, a front and back deck for outdoor entertaining and much more. Weekly rental required July-Labor Day.

Top guest favorite
A spacious living area features a cozy electric fireplace beneath a wall-mounted TV. Large windows provide ample natural light and views of the surrounding landscape. Comfortable seating options, including a leather sofa and armchair, are arranged around a natural wood coffee table.
Cottage in Naples
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 183 reviews

Hideaway House >HOT TUB< *Secluded w/Amazing Views

The Getaway Hideaway House is tucked near the scenic Honeoye and Canandaigua Lake Wine & Brewery Trail—perfect for wine lovers, adventurers, and those seeking a peaceful escape. Enjoy stunning valley and hillside views from the living room or while relaxing in the year-round covered hot tub on the patio. Just a short drive (under 10 minutes) to Naples for great dining and entertainment. Note: Due to the hillside location, AWD or 4WD is recommended during inclement weather for safe access.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of the cottage features warm wooden siding, complemented by large windows that provide views of the surrounding nature. Two skis are mounted on the wall, hinting at outdoor recreational activities. Lush greenery and a small deck are visible next to the cottage.
Cottage in Fillmore
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 225 reviews

Iris Cottage, Nature on Higgins Creek

Iris cottage is set on a quiet road in WNY just 15 mi. from Letchworth State Park and 5 mi. from Houghton College. Gas fire place greets guests on chilly days and a large deck overlooks woods and Higgins Creek. The kitchen is well stocked and fully equipped. Whether summer or winter this is the perfect place to enjoy WNY nature at its best and get away from it all. 2 bedrooms open to open plan living, kitchen and dining. Onsuite master has a second electric fireplace and deck access.

Top guest favorite
A panoramic view of a serene lake framed by two large trees is captured at sunset. The warm glow of the sun reflects off the water, highlighting private docks and a lush green lawn in the foreground.
Cottage in Silver Lake
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Recently Renovated Lake House on Silver Lake

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. Enjoy our recently renovated lake house! This all season lake house comfortably sleeps 8… Includes screened in porch with a beautiful view of the lake sunsets! 50 feet of private Lake front with two docks and plenty of green space. Minutes away from Letchworth State Park. Interested in a relaxing round of golf? The Club at Silver Lake, a public course, can be seen across the Lake and is only a few minute drive away.

Guest favorite
A charming cottage with a gray exterior features a sloped roof and welcoming front steps. Two adirondack chairs sit on the patio, surrounded by landscaped gardens. In the background, the tranquil lake can be seen, framed by lush trees, emphasizing the property’s peaceful lakeside setting.
Cottage in Perry
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Lakefront cottage minutes from Letchworth

Enjoy lake life at the cottage on Silver Lake. Cottage includes central air. Enjoy 50 ft of lake frontage which includes 30 ft of dock, great for fishing & swimming. Wall to wall windows are perfect for evening sunsets and enjoying the views of the lake. The cottage is 2 bedrooms (plus a pullout couch & trundle bunk bed) that sleeps 5 comfortably. Conveniently located near Letchworth State Park, restaurants, brewery, putt-putt mini golf and drive-in movie theater.

Top guest favorite
The kitchen area features navy blue cabinets and a spacious island with stools. Natural light fills the space through large windows, complementing the warm wooden floors. A dining area is visible in the background, with a dining table and wall-mounted clock.
Cottage in Honeoye
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

The Hideaway on Hobart - New / Recently Renovated

*This property just completed a FULL RENOVATION in 2023. Steps from Honeoye Lake* The Hideaway on Hobart is a newly remodeled cottage steps from the hidden gem of the Finger Lakes, Honeoye Lake. The house is conveniently located at the north end of the lake and has full access to a private community beach, park and boat launch. The property has 2 bedrooms, one of the best kitchens/common spaces on the lake and an AMAZING deck. Two ski resorts within 15 minutes.

Guest favorite
A charming lakeside cottage is showcased, featuring multiple decks and outdoor seating areas. Kayaks and paddleboards are neatly arranged on the lower deck, complemented by comfortable lounge chairs. The property is surrounded by lush greenery, creating a serene outdoor environment.
Cottage in Honeoye
4.8 out of 5 average rating, 268 reviews

Captain Frank's Lakeside Get Away

Simply kick back and relax in the cutest lakeside cottage on Honeoye Lake! You can see large mouth bass swimming right by the shoreline. There is plenty of room for the whole family. There is an additional two bedroom upper cottage that can be rented as well for more family and friends. Come see what the finger lakes are all about! I have included a nice fireplace so you can even enjoy the winter months. Enjoy relaxing in a hot tub overlooking the lake.

Guest favorite
A comfortable living area showcases a spacious gray sofa and two tan leather chairs arranged around a wooden coffee table. A ceiling fan is mounted above, and ambient lighting is provided by two lamps. A decorative rug adds warmth to the hardwood floor.
Cottage in Hemlock
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 199 reviews

Cottage in Hemlock

The peaceful atmosphere of this lovely home has everything you’ll need for a restful stay. Within a few miles of Hemlock, Canadice, Conesus, and Honeoye Lakes, enjoy canoeing, kayaking, fishing in the lakes or hiking, biking on the many nearby trails. Close to the Finger Lakes wine trails, local breweries, and distilleries. You’ll have the entire home to yourself. The bedroom has a queen size bed, and there are two self-inflating twin size air mattresses.

Guest favorite
The exterior of the A-frame home is featured, highlighting its unique architectural design. Large windows illuminate the interior with a warm glow, while a stone chimney adds character. The deck is visible, leading down to the water, surrounded by lush green grass and a stone border.
Cottage in Conesus
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 99 reviews

Stunning A-Frame lakehouse w/ all modern comforts!

Pamper your family and friends in our families beloved year round A-frame lakehome on Conesus Lake. Enjoy the amazing sunrises and gaze for hours. Meditate, read & sketch on the lovely deck. Fish right off the dock or venture off to your favorite cove. Bring your canoe / kayak or use one of our kayaks. This is a special place sure to create an experience and memories for a lifetime. Note: Dock removed for season in October.

Top guest favorite
A scenic winter landscape is visible from the deck, showcasing a horizon where the sun begins to rise over snow-covered fields. The railing of the deck frames the peaceful view, enhancing the sense of tranquility in this countryside setting.
Cottage in Franklinville
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 200 reviews

Countryside Zen Cottage with remarkable views

Spend a weekend, week or more in this fully furnished, dog friendly, 2 BR with loft country retreat near Rushford Lake, NY. Views, sounds and fresh air of the countryside will facilitate deep relaxation and re-energize. Surround yourself with nature, watch from your second story deck as deer feed in the fields, wild turkey gather and ducks frolic in the pond. This is true country living.

Popular amenities for Silver Lake cottage rentals

Quick stats about cottage rentals in Silver Lake

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Silver Lake vacation rentals start at R3,137 ZAR per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 150 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Silver Lake rentals

  • 4.9 Average rating

    Silver Lake stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.9 out of 5!

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Wyoming County
  5. Castile
  6. Silver Lake
  7. Cottage rentals