Vacation rentals in Rum Cay

It was the first time my family and I visited Long Island. We met Docky and Jill and they made us feel at home from the very beginning. Starting from the simplest details of providing, coffee, tea, bug spray, baby oil for mosquitoes to the more complex like taking time out to direct us everywhere on the entire island. The home is equipped with all of the basics even some cooking seasonings. The yard is big and has a beautiful huge tamarind trees. a nice gazebo, grill and the house hilltop view was spectacular. We had true privacy and the neighbors were quiet and kept to themselves. We never saw them..You definitely will need a car to get around especially to restaurants and grocery shopping. It’s located to the very northern tip of the island. The busiest settlement is 45 minutes to the south. We will be back again and will be delighted to book with Bonafide fishing house again. We didn’t do any fishing with Docky because of the rain. We came as visitors and left feeling like locals.

Great place to stay!! Everyone is very friendly and the views are incredible.

The stay was very spacious and accommodating. Jill was very responsive and communicated very well. We will book our stay with her again.

This was our second stay at Grotto Bay Beach house and it was still great. The location is stunning, with an excellent cove and snorkeling just down from the house. Recommend a rental car to drive to town and around the island, though roads around the house are quite rough. Karen is kind and gives local recommendations and information and Nicola, the local housekeeper, met us at the house to let us in and show us around. She is an excellent source of information and so friendly. The house is beachy and casual, with linens and basic kitchen and bath supplies, as well as some snorkeling equipment. Great wifi, but local phone service did not work (though a local Bahamas SIM card worked great on cell phones) and did not try to use the TV. The AC worked off and on, though the weather meant we didn't need it, though we did keep the door and windows closed to keep out the no-see-ums (tiny biting flies) at night. A great value and highly recommend for the excellent location!

Raymond and Michael host a dynamite & efficient spot for someone who wants to engage kitesurfing at the Turquoise jewel called Snow Bay. The apartment was perfect for resting, making a meal, cleaning up, WiFi and/or Netflix chilling after a day on the lagoon. Easy access to gorgeous beaches and snorkeling on low wind days. I appreciated that they offered a car rental which a guest needs to get to the kitespot (~30 minute drive), making grocery run. (~10 minute drive). I’ll be back again for sure!

We had a wonderful stay at this location. It was extremely private and picturesque. The best part was all of the helpful information Wally, the host, provided. the information he provided made a very remote island much more accessible!

We love Long Island and the Fox 2 house in Stella Mari’s was a great home base for us! Everything was exactly as described and we appreciated the beach towels and chairs. A little cooler would be a nice addition! Such a beautiful island with such happy and friendly residents. Hope to return and would rent this house again!

This place was wonderful! We immediately felt right at home. The hostess, Karin was extremely welcoming and helpful. Great communication and very knowledgeable. The house and amenities were perfect! We had use of coolers, beach bags, an umbrella and whatever else was in the home, very hospitable. I would 100% recommend this stay to anyone. No hidden fees or wacky rules. (Electricity not included, but Karin was upfront about this) Perfect for two couples, plenty of privacy. Thank you Nils and Karin for all of your care and attention to the guest experience!