Vacation rentals in Protestant Cay

5 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Villa in Christiansted

Mojito Hill - private hilltop pool oasis!

Beautiful 1-bedroom ocean view villa with private pool. Relax on the private pool deck with brand new patio furniture featuring chaise lounges, table seating for 4, and a gas grill. Sweet dreams await you in the four-poster king sized master suite, complete with french doors that open to the pool deck and allow for the ocean breezes to keep you cool. The shower is a fully stocked oversized marble shower with room for two. A fully equipped kitchen with granite countertops and modern appliances, including a Keurig latte machine, will make you feel right at home. Mojito Hill includes many conveniences such as a smart TV, wifi, air conditioning, washer/dryer, and much more. Extra guests are no problem, as the couch features a pull-out bed. Villa Madeleine is a gated community on St. Croix’s relaxing East End, where you will enjoy the privacy, amazing views, tennis court, and close proximity to the Reef Golf Course, Duggan’s Reef restaurant, Divi Casino and Resort, Grapetree beach to the south and Reef Beach to the north. All these amenities are within walking distance, but do require traversing a steep hill, so driving is typically preferred. We have an on-island manager, and Tom & Hillery are available at any time via email/text/phone if needed. If you don't see the dates you are looking for, please message us, we also have a Splash of Lime in the same complex that has a spectacular northern facing view.

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Bettys Hideaway book your Winter and Spring Break

Your family will be close to everything when you stay at this centrally-located place.Welcome to Betty's Hideaway my new seventh listing as a diamond premier host of the past nine years. This top to bottom 100% remodeled beautiful hill side condo with its traditional island decor is accentuated by the spacious rooms and abundance of natural lighting. It has awesome views of Gallows Bay, historic downtown Christiansted, and Protestant Cay! Minutes from shopping and dinning, in addition to fishing

5 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Frigates View

This secluded mountainside oasis, conveniently located mid-island, provides panoramic views of Salt River Bay, Buck Island and surrounding islands. A spacious studio with private veranda and separate entry off a verdant courtyard adorned with exotic flora, offers a stunning 180 degree ocean seascape. Enjoy beautifully landscaped grounds, Japanese gazebo and jacuzzi, while listening to the sounds of the breaking surf and cooled by constant trade winds. A perfect blend of romance and relaxation .

Superhost

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

The Royal Wait - An Elegant Retreat

The Bonney, a gated historical Danish villa, rests in the heart of downtown Christiansted! Just 0.2 miles from the Christiansted Boardwalk and walking distance to the ferry, seaplane, shops, bars & restaurants, waterfront, national parks and historic sites. This beautiful 2-bed, 1-bath suite provides AC, WiFi, smart TVs, and a fully equipped kitchen. Access to snorkel gear, beach chairs, umbrellas, coolers, and all your beach needs! Enjoy everything St Croix has to offer in comfort and safety!

Superhost

Apartment in Sion Farm

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

Executive 1 Br. Poolside Apt: "Kilele suite"

Fantastic, recently renovated luxury pool side apartment overlooking the Christiansted harbor and Buck island. This is an exclusive gated private residence nestled on Princesse Hill Estate, 2 miles from Christiansted town and 5 mins to local grocery stores, exclusive restaurants, and local beaches. Open your curtains and enjoy the breath taking views of the old Danish City, Buck island, and Green Key. Just want to relax? Enjoy direct access to the pool and hot tub steps away from your door.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

Beach Front Studio Condo Amazing Ocean View

Beautiful, tranquil, beachfront studio condo. King size bed with private balcony. Located in Sugar Beach condos. Onsite pool, tennis courts, and free parking for guests to enjoy. This beachfront condo offers all the luxuries of home with the magnificent view of our sandy beach and turquoise waters. Whether you prefer relaxing on the beach in the breeze of the tropical trade winds or by the poolside with a historic sugar mill. The condo also has its own private washer and dryer.

Guesthouse in Christiansted

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Brand New Cottage II, AC, Pool & Generator

Enjoy a brand new, stylish cottage with an amazing view! Centrally located with AC, wifi, pool and generator. It's less than 8 mins to the beach, 2 mins to major groceries, 12 mins to restaurants and downtown Christiansted. There is a private driveway and parking. For someone new to the island, this is a great location to get to the different spots and necessities. The cottage is in a quiet neighborhood with lots of outdoor space and brand new pool overlooking the South shore.

Guesthouse in Christiansted

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Private Cottage Retreat, Giant Bathroom, Yoga Den

Welcome to your tropical retreat! This brand-new 1-bed, 1-bath guesthouse + bonus yoga room and private patio is your perfect island escape. Nestled in the heart of St. Croix, this spacious getaway offers modern amenities with beautiful outdoor spaces for ultimate relaxation. Centrally located and just 1.7 miles from the Christiansted boardwalk, it’s perfect for exploring beaches, shops, and dining. Unwind or stay active—this cozy retreat brings you the best of the Caribbean.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Villa in Christiansted

Island Vibe Retreat

Enjoy the breathtaking architectural design and location this private villa offers. This unique property embraces indoor/outdoor living with courtyard dining, 3 bedrooms with ensuites, kitchen and laundry room. Relax on the rooftop while you watch the sunrise over the turquoise waters of the Caribbean. Explore our gated community. Unbeatable location with quick access to beaches, the boardwalk, shops, and restaurants. Indulge in water sports, island tours, and many more.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Escape to the Island of St. Croix

Come stay in our 1-bedroom apartment in a great neighborhood. Ideal location for 5 minute drive to Downtown Christiansted Harbor where you can schedule boat tours to Buck Island, visit gift shops, restaurants and historic sites. Also, Frederiksted is a short drive to visit Rainbow Beach. The apartment is located at the end of the main house with your own private entrance. Fruit trees are all around the premises. Great for Business and Personal Getaways!

Superhost

Guest suite in Christiansted

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 188 reviews

Zen Studio King Bed Downtown Christiansted

Your private studio located in a gated tropical courtyard we have 5 private apartments in case you are traveling with friends, family, or a group and need would like to stay together! We are close to the center of Christiansted town's shopping district, featuring arts and cultural events, parks and self-guided walking tours, and national historical sites, as well as award-winning restaurants and top-ranked beaches.

5 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Home in Christiansted

Sunshine Cottage breezy island escape!

Enjoy island life at this peaceful and centrally-located cottage with a gorgeous view and pool! Perfect location for a combination of privacy and easy access to restaurants, beach, activities, and downtown Christiansted. Come live the Caribbean Life! *Adults only. The large outdoor living area overlooks the swimming pool and is not safe for small children.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Protestant Cay vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Protestant Cay

Home in Christiansted

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 94 reviews

CARIBBEAN SPLENDOR WITH MILLION DOLLAR VIEWS

RichardRating, 5 stars4 months ago

The view from the deck is absolutely stunning and includes views of the ocean on both the north and south sides of St. Croix, including Christiansted harbor and Bucks Island. This place is located high on a hill, and the warm breezes make the deck even more wonderful. Great for stargazing and sunrises. Very private, very secluded location. Nice landscaping. The house is comfortable, thoughtfully appointed, clean and well equipped. You will need a car to get around the island. The host was responsive to all our inquiries.

4.69 out of 5 average rating, 83 reviews

Courtyard cottage 4

CURTISRating, 5 stars2 months ago

Sherron was an excellent host and made it seem like I was someone special. I felt like I was staying at Melrose Place, my favorite 90s soap, with all the neighborhood charm but none of the drama!

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Villa in Christiansted

True beachfront villa.

MatthewRating, 5 stars6 months ago

Everything was amazing, steps away from the beach, great view of Buck Island, well equipped home, what more could you ask for. Christana's availability for questions and recommendations was very helpful. Great location for a family with kids. Would stay again!

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

NEW! Saltwater Serenity - Poolside & Walk to Beach

NickRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

I had an amazing stay at this beautiful Airbnb in St. Croix! The property was exceptionally clean, well-kept, and felt incredibly safe the entire time. It’s clear the hosts take great pride in creating a comfortable and welcoming space. One of the highlights was the large pool — perfect for cooling off after a day at the beach or just relaxing with a book. The location couldn’t have been better: close to great restaurants, shops, and everything you might need, but still tucked away enough to feel peaceful and private. I truly felt at home here and would absolutely stay again. Highly recommend to anyone visiting the island!

5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

The Beach Bohemian

TracyRating, 5 stars4 weeks ago

This quaint apartment was very clean and free of bugs (which is important to me). I used the barbecue grill to make some turkey burgers, grilled fish, and veggies, and the kitchenette had exactly what I needed. The location was good for us because we didn’t travel too far from the condos. Plus, being able to wake up, sit on the patio, and watch the movement of the ocean was superb! The bed was comfortable and didn’t hurt my back. Loreto provides everything you need to have a great vacation, and I’m glad we made the right choice!

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

ONLY jacuzzi pool in Christiansted town

ZackRating, 5 stars2 months ago

Great place for the price! The back courtyard area is a great place to hangout, the unit is a nice size, and the appliances are updated and well working. Misty and her doggo were very accommodating and offered great suggestions of what to do and not to do. Very helpful and pleasant visit!