House vacation rentals in Payette Lake

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Payette Lake

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A two-story cabin is nestled among tall trees, showcasing a covered deck with a warm wood railing. The exterior features a combination of dark shingles and stone accents, while large windows provide ample natural light. The driveway is spacious, leading to two garage doors.
Home in Donnelly
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Come Relax! Waterfront \ Hot Tub \ Near Tamarack

Wake up to breathtaking mountain views on this waterfront property of Lake Cascade close to Tamarack Ski Resort. Enjoy looking out at the lake while sitting in the beautiful Hot Tub surrounded by trees under a covered deck! Big picture windows let you enjoy the view and keep your privacy. Comfortable king and queen beds with hand-crafted furniture and the living room has top-grain leather recliners all looking out at the lake! We pride ourselves on being the cleanest Airbnb, Let's go Relax!

Guest favorite
The open-concept living area features a spacious layout with a large sectional sofa and a round dining table. A staircase is visible in the background, leading to an upper level. Natural light filters through multiple windows, enhancing the modern décor and warm wooden accents.
Home in McCall
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Walk to Lake & Town! New Home with Lake Views.

Come enjoy our family’s favorite place! Our home is a custom build in an unbeatable location. Walk less than 1/4 mile to main beach, marina, coffee shops, and restaurants. 3 bed/3.5 bath, beautiful kitchen with big island, vaulted ceilings, large gathering room that opens onto deck with lake views, and a m-in-law suite w additional kitchen. Relax around the fireplace out back while you make s’mores and grill. We hope your family can make some incredible summer (or cozy winter) memories here too.

Guest favorite
A spacious open living area is highlighted by large windows that bring in natural light. A modern leather sofa is positioned beside a rustic wood side table. The kitchen features sleek cabinetry and a dining area with a stylish table and chairs. A warm firepit is visible outside.
Home in McCall
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 68 reviews

FINE PINE PLACE: new build! town + adventure

NEW 1 Gb WiFi! Welcome to Fine Pine Place, where modern comfort meets epic outdoor experiences. This new industrial modern home in the heart of McCall offers 3 bedrooms, 4 queen beds, 2 full bathrooms, massive windows, & a soaring 18’ ceiling. Set on a large wooded lot on the edge of Ponderosa State Park, with a chill firepit patio space. Inside find a foodie's kitchen & the fine things. Hike & bike out the door, walk to Payette Lake beach & downtown. Have that adventure - and that luxury too.

Guest favorite
A leather sofa is positioned against a wood-paneled wall, complemented by decorative blue and white cushions. A cozy coffee table features a woven tray with books and natural accents, enhancing the inviting atmosphere of the living space.
Home in McCall
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Top-Rated Coveted Guest-Favorite in McCall

Top-Rated Guest-Favorite in McCall! Enjoy small-town charm with modern comfort just minutes from Payette Lake, Brundage Mountain, and Ponderosa Park. Two private bedroom wings with full baths, a stocked kitchen, cozy living spaces, and Smart TV make this retreat ideal for families or friends. The extended driveway offers free parking for boats and trailers. Perfectly located near golf, trails, and lake beaches—your McCall adventure starts here, with comfort guests return for year after year.

Top guest favorite
A cabin nestled among tall trees features a rustic wooden exterior with a metal roof. A spacious deck is partially visible, with outdoor furniture and stacked firewood. Two bicycles are parked nearby, suggesting opportunities for outdoor exploration.
Home in McCall
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 254 reviews

McCall Lake View Retreat

This cute 2 bedroom, 1 bath cabin is a mountain vacation get away. Our deck and lakeside windows look directly out onto Payette Lake and the rugged Idaho mountains beyond. Walk to the beach, Ice Cream Alley, or many of the local restaurants in just a minute or two. Watch the lake come to life from the comfort of your Adirondack chair on the lake view deck - Or relax as the sun sets over the water highlighting the sail boats in the McCall marina. Set up for your fun filled family vacation!

Top guest favorite
A modern cabin exterior is illuminated by the warm glow of sunset, showcasing a sleek design with large windows. A private hot tub is visible on the expansive deck, surrounded by trees and a view of Lake Cascade in the background.
Home in Donnelly
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Luxe Cabin w/ Sauna, HotTub, Heated Driveway, View

Welcome to The Wildwood at Tamarack! Located only 5 minutes from Tamarack Resort, this stunning 4 bed, 3.5 bath modern luxe cabin has been thoughtfully designed with a minimalist aesthetic and a special emphasis on the stunning views of Lake Cascade. Situated on 2.5 acres of forested land that directly borders Tamarack Resort, The Wildwood is an escape from everyday life that offers an elevated experience with amenities like a hot tub, a sauna, and a heated paver driveway.

Top guest favorite
A spacious living area is highlighted by a large sectional sofa adorned with decorative pillows. A coffee table sits in the center on a soft rug, and a ceiling fan offers comfort. The kitchen is visible in the background with wooden cabinets and modern appliances.
Home in McCall
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Heart of Downtown - Golf Course - Pets welcome

Your family will be close to everything when you stay at this centrally-located 3 bedroom 2 bath home in the ❤️ of downtown McCall. Walk to the beach, shops & restaurants all within .6 miles of the house. The McCall Golf Club is .5 miles away. It’s a perfect location on a quiet street yet close to everything! Guests have garage access and 3 additional parking spaces in the driveway. Bring your dog! Pets welcome. Enjoy the fire pit for those perfect McCall evenings.

Superhost
Home in McCall
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

The Outpost on Payette Lake | Dock Slip + Beach!

The Outpost on Payette Lake is an idyllic Sylvan Beach retreat perfect for those seeking adventure, relaxation, or a creative escape! Just 4 miles outside of downtown McCall but feeling worlds away, this light-filled 2BR/2BA cabin boasts gorgeous LAKE VIEWS, an expansive wraparound deck, + is just a quick one-minute walk to your BOAT SLIP + BEACH ACCESS. This peaceful all-season getaway is just 12 miles to Brundage skiing + minutes to hiking, biking, + snowmobile trails

Guest favorite
A spacious living area features a large leather sofa adorned with soft blankets and pillows. A striking mountain mural with vibrant colors is displayed on one wall, enhancing the room's ambiance. Large windows allow natural light and views of the surrounding landscape.
Home in McCall
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Nordic Ski, Golf Course, Hot Tub

On the Golf course, 3min walk to Lake, Davis Beach and Ponderosa State Park. Snow Shoe or Cross Country Ski in/out of this cabin, or sled in winters. Enjoy watching deer in your back yard!! Very close to downtown restaurants. 3 bedrooms all with King beds. Game room with Arcades, Atari video game, Foosball, Dartboard, Board Games and Arcade Basketball. Pellet fireplace, Heated Floors, Hot tub and Firepit. Snow shoes, sleds, beach equipment! Welcome to PONDEROSA!

Guest favorite
An A-frame cabin is nestled among ponderosa pines, illuminated softly by interior lighting. A spacious front deck with seating provides views of the surrounding nature, while a path leads to the entryway. A clear evening sky enhances the calm and serene atmosphere.
Home in McCall
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Anchor Mountain A-Frame

A boutique A-frame cabin submersed in the ponderosa pines, yet minutes from downtown McCall. This is a perfect location for a romantic getaway or for a unique stay with friends while enjoying everything McCall has to offer. Located 15 minutes from Brundage Mountain and a bike ride away from downtown McCall. This home has everything you need to cozy up by the fire, enjoy a beautifully designed space, and enjoy modern comforts in your own cabin in the woods.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of the cabin is highlighted by a green garage door and a rustic wood facade. Surrounding trees provide a natural setting, while a gravel driveway offers access to the entrance. A welcoming porch area is visible, blending harmoniously with the outdoor space.
Home in McCall
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

The Jasper House, near lake, Shore Lodge, Brundage

Cozy yet spacious the Jasper House with 4 beds, a loft and 2.5 baths is great for families or groups. Two-car garage, master bed on the main level with attached bathroom, two-televisions, pellet stove and fully-equipped kitchen and dining for 10. Enjoy mornings on the covered back patio and evenings around the campfire. Just a half mile from Shorelodge and public beach access. Relax, have fun and enjoy this clean, cozy cabin!

Top guest favorite
An outdoor entertaining area features a stone patio with a table and multiple chairs under a green umbrella. A hot tub sits nearby, surrounded by natural landscaping and greenery. The backyard is enclosed by wooden fencing, enhancing privacy.
Home in McCall
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 159 reviews

Mile High Retreat: Hot Tub, Dogs Allowed

Enjoy the magic of McCall from a comfortable, pet-friendly home within walking distance of downtown. The house features a beautiful backyard hot tub, entertaining area, propane fireplace, and jacuzzi bath. Situated in a quiet neighborhood that is less than a 10-minute walk from downtown McCall. Experience all that this area has to offer from a home outfitted with everything you need for your perfect McCall vacation.

Popular amenities for Payette Lake house rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Idaho
  4. Valley County
  5. Payette Lake
  6. House rentals