Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Otsego Lake

Thank you Sarah for a wonderful, relaxing stay at your Hamilton cottage. My family and I loved the Lebanon Reservoir and the surrounding Colgate community. We appreciate your thoughtfulness and communication!

What a beautiful home! This gem in Mohawk is a must stay - Dean’s home was spotless when we arrived for the weekend. So much space for us to enjoy inside the house and a great outdoor space with a very clean pool! The weather didn’t cooperate with us to enjoy the pool but the water was crystal clear. The people around were town were extremely friendly - a local police officer pulled over to show our kids his patrol car and let them see how the sirens work. Dean’s home is a must stay for you and your family!

Had an amazing time staying at the property! The views are breathtaking and space is something you have to see for yourself! We had a small wedding of 50 people and amos accommodated us completely! We will never forget our stay! I would give this a 1 million star if I could!!

What a gem. Tucked away in woods, this house was just what we needed. Tranquil, gorgeous, homey, and a perfect reset. My dog loved exploring the grounds, while I admired the beautiful mountain view. It was a little chillier than expected when we arrived but host sent directions for food recs and suggested we take advantage of the fireplace, which we did. Everything was very easy to find in the kitchen and bathroom, and my bedroom was cozy. Loved it very much, and would stay again.

What an excellent stay - this airbnb was incredibly well stocked with kitchen supplies, games, extra linens, really anything that one could want. Amenities were high quality and very thoughtful.

Excellent location with private pond. This home was truly built for a family gathering. Wonderful entertaining spaces, large fireplace with an expansive kitchen to cook in. There is a large game room with board games to suite all ages, billiards, croquet, and a small row boat for fun.

Beautiful space. Amazing countryside vibes. Fun hike down to the waterfall, great kitchen for cooking and a fun night in. There was lots of quaint stuff to do in nearby Middleburgh: thrifting, diners, 50s milkshake bar, antique book stores, hikes, breweries, and more. We loved that there was so many towels for the sauna and swimming. One note: give yourself a lot of time for the sauna to heat up. Instructions were clear and they gave us lots of local recs. Also LOVED the hammocks -- lots of cozy nooks to hang for a chill girls weekend. We might be back again! A great stay.

We spent the weekend in the area and Tim’s place was fantastic. It’s loaded with charm, comfortable and very well appointed and stocked (right down to treats for the dog). The location is beautiful and the views are amazing. Can’t wait to return!

Jaynee and her family made us feel right at home. Our stay was super relaxing and enjoyable. The property had gorgeous views and the kids loved the cows. The space had all the necessary amenities and was very clean. Dan took our family on a ride through the property to see the wild life and views. I would highly recommend this place. We will be back !

It was a perfect place for 2. The home was beautiful inside and out. The property was well maintained and attractive. The setting was stunning. Having kayaks available was a bonus. Inside, nothing was missed. Communication was clear and simple; they offered good suggestions on restaurants and places to visit. Would definitely return!

The photos of the place are exactly as it is. It’s a very clean open concept stay within an hour of all of our destinations like Cooperstown and Sherborne really enjoyed our stay and it was a beautiful place.

We loved how quiet and peaceful the location was. We also loved the homey touches- the local books, the honor store out back, the fact that there was the cafe under the apartment. The setting was beautiful and we loved falling asleep to the sound of the brook and the spring peepers!

Eagles ridge farm was such a beautiful and comfortable stay! I came here with my partner and the property could not have been more beautiful. The bed was comfy, the space warm and cozy, and the accommodations perfectly stocked. I hope to come here again for our next Catskills trip! Totally recommend to all looking for a memorable getaway.

Donna's place was immaculate easy to find shes very responsive. For us personally we needed to make adjustments but she is more than willing to work with us. Appreciate the offer to stay. Highly recommend.

We had a great time in Melanie’s place! It’s very cute, but be aware that it is a little small. There is also a very long staircase to make your way up to the top. We stayed here as a stopover on the way to the Finger lakes which works well! Unfortunately the Little Falls downtown seems mostly closed and empty, so make sure to plan accordingly!

Richards apartment was very comfortable and so nicely decorated with such care and thoughtfulness. It was so well co ordinated, even the silverware matched the Retro decor. In fact the entire kitchen matched perfectly! I don't know how they did that!

We loved this house! It was extremely clean, with sheets and towels that looked brand new. The kitchen was fully equipped with everything we needed. Entering the house was super easy. It was so peaceful, with a beautiful view to enjoy. We’d definitely stay here again!

Really nice place to stay. Clean and quiet.

We had a great time staying here! The house was clean and matched the description perfectly. It's the perfect place to stay to go skiing in the winter or hiking in the summer!

Magdalena - Your very comfortable and beautiful home was perfect for our family’s visit. Our only suggestion for going forward would be for you to provide some information about the history of the house. We did a lot of guessing!

Maria is a great host! Highly recommend staying at this house! It was clean and offered many sleeping options! Thank you for providing breakfast groceries! Your thoughtfulness was greatly appreciated!! Maria is an A+ Host, who goes above ours, to insure we had everything we needed! Thank you!

Maria’s place was amazing! It was quiet and tucked away, which was perfect for the group of us since we wouldn’t have to worry about bothering others. The place was very prepared and clean upon arrival and Maria was very responsive to questions we had. With that said, Maria is probably the best-prepared and considerate host I’ve encountered, stocking the place up with a variety of foods and drinks.

My friends and I had the most incredible time at this Airbnb! From the moment we arrived, we were blown away by the stunning views and the warm welcome from our host Joe. The property itself was immaculate — beautifully decorated, clean, and equipped with everything we needed for a comfortable stay. The location was perfect too! Just a short walk from hikes, and local cafes, we were able to enjoy lazy mornings by the and evenings exploring the charming neighborhood. Our host went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we needed, offering great recommendations for activities and dining spots nearby. We truly felt like we were staying with friends rather than in a rental property. Overall, our experience exceeded all expectations. We can't wait to return to this Airbnb for another relaxing getaway. Highly recommended for anyone looking to unwind and enjoy a slice of paradise!

Alexander’s place is as described and look like the pictures. We stayed for one week end with friends to enjoy one day skiing and it was great! We had some trouble making the sauna and pool work at the beginning but Alexander sent someone to help quickly which was much appreciated 3’ drive from the slopes of Hunter and enough space to comfortably fit 12 people Would definitely recommend for a week end between friends or a big family reunion Thank you!