Vacation rentals in Town of Otisco

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

This aerial view captures a lakefront property surrounded by lush greenery. The spacious home features a large deck overlooking the water, with easy access to the lake. A private dock is visible, offering direct lake access for recreational activities.

Home in Tully

Luxury Lakehouse on the water!

An unforgettable stay awaits at this private lakefront property. The waterfront home has been beautifully remodeled with high-end finishes and equipped with modern appliances, providing the ideal combination of luxury and tranquility. Start your day with a coffee on the large back deck and finish it with a campfire overlooking the lake. Song Mountain - 3 min drive Song Lake - Steps from back door Vesper Hills Golf Club - 12 min drive Create Lasting Memories In Tully With Us & Learn More Below!

LocationFamilyAccuracy

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

An A-frame house is situated amidst lush greenery, featuring a spacious outdoor area with seating arrangements around a fire pit. A grill is positioned nearby, with colorful chairs and picnic tables complementing the scene, while string lights add a soft glow as twilight approaches.

Chalet in Marietta

Pickleball + Hot Tub | Luxe A-Frame Escape

Modern A-frame meets full-on getaway vibes. Just 1 mile from Otisco Lake and under 10 miles to Beak & Skiff, A-Frame and Chill stuns with exquisite design and curated details. Enjoy 2 king bedrooms with balconies and fireplaces, a hot tub, fire pit, full-size pickleball court, half basketball court, 3-hole disc golf, and stylish living with a Vestaboard, spiral staircase, Tempurpedic sleeper, smart TV, games, and a fully stocked kitchen. Note: Guests will be required to sign a short rental agre

LocationValueIndoor spaces

A vibrant sunset casts shades of orange, pink, and purple across the sky, reflecting onto the calm waters of the lake. The silhouette of a distant tree line adds depth to the horizon, creating a serene and peaceful landscape.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Otisco Lake park like setting

Year round home located on a unique lakeside country setting with a newly renovated bathroom. Over 2 acres of outside green space offering a park like experience to enjoy many recreational activities * please note this space is shared with family and another guest house. There is plenty of area for all to enjoy including 900 feet of lake frontage with a creek. Enjoy a campfire lakeside at a dedicated private fire pit. Close to Beak N Skiff and Tims Pumpkin Patch as well as Skaneateles.

LocationFamilyBathroom

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 295 reviews

A spacious wooden deck overlooks Skaneateles Lake, featuring multiple seating areas and umbrellas. A small table with four chairs is situated near the edge, providing a perfect spot to enjoy the serene lake views. A dock extends into the water, enhancing the lakeside experience.

Home in Skaneateles

Gorgeous Lake Home Spectacular View

Rest and relax at this custom-built lakefront home with newly renovated additional bungalow. Offering unparalleled views of Skaneateles Lake, 2,000 sq. ft. of decking over 4 levels, granite countertops, new stainless appliances, waterfalls and much more! Newly renovated living space offers an additional 4th bedroom, luxury bath (with steam shower, radiant flooring, Japanese bidet and soak tub), living area with mini kitchenette overlooking a 2nd floor deck with dining area facing the lake.

ValueFamilyCheck-in

A spacious deck overlooks the lake, furnished with comfortable seating that includes armchairs and a sectional. Two tall umbrellas provide shade, and a small table is placed centrally. The serene view of the water and surrounding greenery creates a peaceful outdoor setting.

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 64 reviews

Beautiful Otisco lakefront house

3bedroom/1 full bath stand up shower. Eat inside the sunroom or outside on the trex deck with large 11 ft umbrella both have a gorgeous view of the lake! Enjoy 60 ft of private water just steps down from the house with a brand new deck. Additionally, a 50 foot dock to swim off with deep area off the end and floating swim raft Bring your own bed linens and towels Brand new 65 inch smart TV WiFi Enjoy a piece of CNY heaven. Nearby wineries, downtown Skaneateles shops, hiking, mountain bike

ValueFamilyView

Vacation home in Marietta

A serene lakeside area is viewable, featuring a circular fire pit surrounded by four brightly colored Adirondack chairs in red, green, blue, and yellow. A large red umbrella provides shade nearby, with a backdrop of lush greenery and calm lake waters reflecting the landscape.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 150 reviews

Nest at Heron Cove - Lakefront Private Apartment

This private apartment w/ EV charger (small added fee) located right the water on Otisco Lake, w/ over 300 ft of lakefront at your front door. Incredible views! The apartment is attached to the main house w/ a private entrance. Beach, seasonal dock, canoe, 2 kayaks, 2 paddle boards, paddle boat, gas grill & fire pit with wood (May - Oct). Fishing, swimming, snow skiing, wine tasting, fine dining, beautiful sunsets await your arrival! 15 min to Skaneateles, 10 min to Song Mountain Skiing.

LocationValueSkiing

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 84 reviews

The spacious pine lodge is nestled among lush greenery, showcasing a wraparound porch and multiple gabled roofs. Surrounding trees and landscaped gardens provide a serene setting, with rolling hills visible in the distance. A driveway leads to the entrance and attached two-car garage.

Home in Tully

Rowanberry Pines: Cozy, ADK style 5 BR lodge.

Relax and gather in this spacious pine lodge with breathtaking year-round views of the hills south of Syracuse, NY. Whether exploring the 13 acre property, relaxing on the front porch, or sitting cozy by the fire, this five bedroom venue is an idyllic setting for family gatherings, small groups, or as a basecamp to explore central New York. Your hosts, Mark and Sue live ON SITE in a basement apartment and can assist you as much or as little as needed. Come enjoy our slice of paradise!

ValueLocationDecor

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

A covered porch features sturdy wooden beams and a wide expanse of decking. Two rocking chairs are positioned for relaxation, with potted plants adding a touch of greenery. A lush lawn extends beyond the porch, creating a serene outdoor setting.

Cabin in LaFayette

Cabin DuBois | Central New York Getaway

Cabin DuBois is a beautiful Western Red Pine cabin, built in 1985 and sitting on 6 beautiful acres in Lafayette, NY. Tucked away in the countryside yet conveniently close to the city, it offers the perfect balance of privacy and accessibility. Whether you are visiting for fall foliage, summer adventures or winter ski weekends, Cabin DuBios offers a peaceful escape. We've put together a guidebook full of our top recommendations to help you make the most of your time at Cabin DuBois.

LocationValueCheckout

A serene sunset view over Otisco Lake is captured, with soft orange and pink hues reflected on the water. A wooden deck offers metal tables and chairs, while a grassy area is visible, featuring several kayaks and a shared dock under a tree.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Otisco Lake Cottage

Lovingly renovated cottage on 50 feet of lakefront on the southeastern end of Otisco Lake. Beautiful sunset views. Located within 30 minutes of Syracuse, Skaneateles, Finger Lakes wineries and hiking trails. Large open kitchen and family area, with two bedrooms (one queen, one twin with trundle convertible to a king) and sleeping loft with two twins. 2nd bedroom has a convertible desk. Well-stocked kitchen, books, DVDs, games, shared dock and sloping beach to take out watercraft.

FamilyLocationSolo travel

An aerial view captures the spacious lake house set against vibrant green trees in autumn hues. A fenced heated pool glistens beside a fire pit surrounded by blue chairs. The property is framed by natural landscaping, showcasing both outdoor leisure spaces and the inviting residence.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Lakeside Fun- Hot Tub-Theater-Fenced Yard, Arcades

Escape to Otisco Overlook, a stunning lakeside retreat on 2 acres with breathtaking views: * year-round hot tub * immersive movie theater * arcade games * private heated pool (now thru Sept 30) * Dogs Welcome: 5' high fenced yard Perched across the street from your own exclusive lakefront access with a private dock, we provide 2 Kayaks, Paddleboards, life jackets and paddles. This is the ultimate Finger Lakes getaway for creating lasting memories with your loved ones.

LocationFamilyDecor

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

Home in Tully

Modern Luxury Escape on Private Acreage

Welcome to your serene retreat just outside of Syracuse, nestled in the picturesque town of Tully, NY. Whether you're seeking peace and quiet or adventure in nature, this new, modern home offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and convenience for your stay. Unique Features: Speakeasy Retreat Outdoor Oasis Modern Comforts We are currently building more homes on this 10 acre property to help accommodate all of your friends and family!

FamilyLocationLaundry

A charming lakeside house features a white exterior with a green metal roof and large windows. A welcoming porch is adorned with hanging flower baskets. The surrounding landscape includes manicured greenery and decorative stones, set against a blue sky with gentle clouds.