Vacation rentals in New Milford

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Milford

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A bright living area features a comfortable sofa and a round wooden coffee table centered on a patterned rug. Large windows let in natural light, and a dining table with four chairs is positioned beside the modern kitchen equipped with stainless steel appliances.

Home in Bergenfield

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

*NEW* Modern NYC Escape near MetLife/AD MALL/EWR

Welcome to Casa Soriano PH! This modern 2BR/1BA apartment offers a stylish retreat in a peaceful neighborhood. Enjoy a cozy living area, full kitchen, and two serene bedrooms with plush Kg and Qn beds. With highspeed Wi-Fi, Smart TV, and free parking, it’s ideal for relaxing or working. Conveniently located near shops, parks, and EASY city access, it’s your perfect suburban getaway. METLIFE 25 Min Drive Prudential Center 30 Min Drive NYC 20 Min No service animals allowed due to allergies.

Guest favorite

The living area features a cozy seating arrangement with a dark sofa adorned with floral cushions. A vintage side table stands beside it, illuminated by a soft lamp. A colorful area rug adds warmth to the space, while a small bar with high stools offers a place to relax.

Guest suite in Dumont

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

PrivAPT in House/2Blocks from NJTransit Bus to NYC

Artsy and completely private bottom level apartment in our family home (shared entrance). Full private kitchen and full private bathroom in safe quiet suburban neighborhood surrounded by nature and wildlife (deer, rabbits, fox). Two blocks from NJTransit busses to NYC, walking distance from restaurants, pharmacies, supermarkets, laundromats banks, vintage shops, parks and hiking trails, 15 min drive to Garden State Plaza. NO SMOKING! We take cleanliness very seriously. Note: 6’4” ceiling height.

Superhost

A spacious living area is highlighted by a sleek black sofa with white and yellow accent pillows. A round coffee table sits at the center, enhancing the arrangement. A flat-screen TV is mounted on the wall, and natural light filters through a nearby window with a simple curtain.

Guest suite in Teaneck

4.73 out of 5 average rating, 45 reviews

Studio Basement Close to NYC

This cozy and stylish private basement studio with a separate entrance is just 15 minutes from New York City and near popular New Jersey malls. Enjoy free WiFi, central heating and cooling, and a smart TV with free Netflix. A full-size bed, a sofa bed, and modern bathroom ensure comfort, while the fully equipped kitchenette makes meals easy with plenty of dining space. Located in a quiet, safe neighborhood, it’s the perfect base for both city adventures and shopping trips! ABSOLUTELY NO PARTIES

Guest favorite

A cozy bedroom features a softly illuminated nightstand with a lamp beside a wooden bed dressed in neutral linens. Framed wall art enhances the space, while a large mirror reflects natural light from a nearby window, contributing to a serene atmosphere.

Apartment in Lodi

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

Small Cozy Apartment Studio. Near NYC

Welcome to this serene and newly renovated basement studio, perfectly situated in a desirable neighborhood, minutes from everything you need. - Private entrance for more convenience and privacy - Centrally located, close to major highways (Rt 46, 80, 17, 4) - just 2 minutes away - Easy access to NYC - 5-minute walk to bus stop - Comfortable and stylishly designed studio space - Perfect for solo travelers, professionals, or couples. - Wi-Fi - Flat-screen TV - Kitchenette - Parking options)

Guest favorite

A welcoming living area features a stylish gray sofa adorned with colorful throw pillows, complemented by a vibrant wall art piece. A kitchenette is visible in the background, along with durable wood flooring and recessed lighting enhancing the bright atmosphere.

Apartment in Garfield

5 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Comfy Nest Studio-Close to NYC

Surround yourself with style in this cozy, whimsical studio—just a short walk to the train for easy access to NYC, which is only 40 minutes/ 30min away driving the Statue of Liberty, and more. Just 15 min away from MetLife, American Dream Mall. Walking distance from stores and restaurants. Featuring a warm and restful sleeping area, comfy sleeper sofa, full bathroom, and a handy kitchenette. Step outside to enjoy direct backyard access for BBQ’s, plus private parking for added convenience.

Home in Bergenfield

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Beautiful 4 bedroom 5 miles to NYC

3 floors with finished attic only 5 miles from NYC ! Beautiful deck off the master bedroom and a backyard with fire pit and outdoor seating. * PLEASE supervise children at all times! * No smoking anywhere on the property Fun for all ages : a barbie house and some toys for in front entrance closet, a foosball table, a WII, plenty of games and books for entertainment Easily accessible public transportation, plenty to do in town, 2 local malls nearby and NYC a hop, skip&jump away!

Guest favorite

A cozy bedroom features a green upholstered headboard against a patterned wall. Soft pillows in neutral tones rest on the spacious bed, complemented by a dark quilt. Vintage-style lamps cast a warm glow, while a bedside table holds a clock and framed artwork.

Apartment in Teaneck

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

Emerald, Stylish & Clean close to NYC & airport

The unit is a 1-minute walk to the bus stop that takes you directly to Time Square (NYC). This beautiful apartment is perfect for a short visit to the NJ/NY area. Close to shopping & dining. This unit is equipped with a kitchenette,Wi-Fi,TV, free parking & AC 19 min. from the METLIFE STADIUM,10 min. from NYC, less than 25 min. from Times Square in Manhattan. Close to Newark NJ, and NY Airports 5 min to Holy Name Medical Center 8 min to Englewood Hospital 14 min to Hackensack Hospital

Guest favorite

A well-lit private room features a spacious bed adorned with white linens. A trio of framed wall art depicting simple, elegant pottery is displayed above the bed. A lighted bathroom can be seen through an open door, enhancing the room's functionality.

Private room in Teaneck

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Comfortable Room, Private Bath

Welcome to our cozy private room! This space features a comfortable queen-sized bed and private bathroom. Enjoy access to a shared kitchen, TV with streaming services, and plenty of closet space. Our location is ideal, with a laundromat, car rental, hospital, and many food options all within walking distance. Public transportation is easy with the bus stop just 30 seconds away, providing direct access to NYC. Street parking is available. We can't wait to host you!

Guest favorite

A cozy living area features a spacious sectional sofa adorned with yellow and patterned throw pillows. A small round table is placed in front of the sofa, and a flat-screen television is mounted on the wall. Warm light fixtures illuminate the space.

Guest suite in Teaneck

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Cozy and Clean Private Suite - Close to NYC

Beautiful and newly refinished private basement located 25 minutes by bus or car to downtown New York City. The apartment comes with a private bathroom and entrance, living space with couches, and one comfortable private bedroom. No kitchen is included but a small refrigerator is available for guest use. The apartment is within a 5 minute walking distance to the NJ transit bus to New York City, a park and outdoor tennis court, and several restaurants.

A light-colored living space features a sofa and two armchairs, all dressed in white slipcovers. An area rug with subtle patterns enhances the flooring, while framed artwork hangs on the wall above. Natural light filters through the window, creating a bright and airy atmosphere.

Home in River Edge

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Quiet place with easy access NYC

Mid century private home with attached private apartment newly renovated and set on a quiet residential street with driveway parking. A small town feel with impeccable streets and scattered small parks and home to the county zoo with carousel/train ride. For malls, supermarkets and cinema a quick ride within 2 miles. The town is home to a quintessential "diner" as well as restaurants serving Italian, Mediterranean and Asian cuisine.

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Dumont

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 284 reviews

Private ground level Studio Available.

This spacious and serene space has an attached garage. Street parking is allowed until September 15, 2025. You may also park in the attached garage as best you can. Up to you. Set the heat or AC, watch TV, nuke a meal, do some laundry, and there's a small office to gather your thoughts. There's high speed WI-FI and your own private entrance through your garage to come and go as you please.

Guest favorite

A well-organized living space includes a round dining table with two chairs, a plush area rug, and a television set on a black stand. Wall art adds character, with a curtain draping over a window, providing privacy and a cozy feel.

Apartment in Dumont

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Cozy, peaceful, 1 bd apt 25-35 mins to NYC/MetLife

Peaceful, cozy and private 1 bedroom apt with bus stop across the street. Easy access to NYC , MetLife Stadium, Malls, restaurants and local parks. It has a private entrance and all the amenities to make you feel at home. Parking is available on site for one vehicle only. Super safe Neighborhood in Northern New Jersey Suburb. The home does have dogs and the owner is onsite.