Vacation rentals in Lyme

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

An outdoor seating area features two chairs positioned beside a fire table. A bottle of wine and two glasses rest on the table, with the lake visible in the background. Natural light enhances the peaceful ambiance as the sun sets, casting warm tones over the scene.

Barn in Three Mile Bay

Bayview Lodge

The Bayview, aka the barn, has it all! View, space, breezes, an amazing kitchen for preparing your feasts. Plan your family gatherings, holidays, special occasions here! For a small additional fee, I can fill, hide inside/out plastic filled eggs. Fun anytime! 1835 modern barndomunium! WE WELCOME and can accommodate up to 12 responsible, 25 yr olds and up with their 2 WELL behaved, house trained dogs (please let us know in adbance), if more please let us know. Kids and infants welcome.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

A cozy cottage is shown from the side, featuring a grey exterior with brown shutters. A covered porch is visible, alongside a stone pathway leading to the grassy yard. A glimpse of the water is seen in the background, enhancing the serene setting.

Cottage in Chaumont

The Love Shack- 1 Bedroom Retreat

This cozy, rustic cottage is perfect for settling in, relaxing, fishing, swimming, and reading a book. Yes, you can do all of that simultaneously. Shallow, warm water awaits you at this simple oasis. Relax under the large covered deck on a hanging swing or soak in the sun on the lower deck. Inside there is one bedroom with a double bed with storage under. The kitchen, living room with futon, and dining room are convenient areas. A pint of Knapp's Sapp Shack syrup is provided upon arrival.

Superhost

Farm stay in Cape Vincent

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Spacious Country Getaway

Escape to our peaceful farmhouse on a picturesque 20-acre hay field, just 10 minutes from charming Cape Vincent. This 4-bed/1-bath retreat blends rustic charm with modern comfort, perfect for nature lovers, stargazers, and those seeking to unwind. Sip your morning coffee while spotting deer and wild turkey. Spend your day exploring, relaxing on the deck, or visiting town for waterfront dining and quaint shops. At night, enjoy breathtaking stargazing under wide-open skies, free from city lights.

A historical stone structure with Gothic architectural features is framed by lush greenery and colorful flower beds. The building is highlighted by soft evening light under a vibrant sunset sky, creating a serene backdrop for the peaceful surroundings.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 68 reviews

The Chez Heron. A small gothic castle in Chaumont

The Chez Heron was built in 1872 out of local limestone and was made to resemble a small Gothic castle. It is nationally registered as a historical structure. It is set up for 1 couple looking for a peaceful getaway. Full kitchen. We will have a bottle of champagne chilling for you and with a 2 night minimum you will receive a $25 gift certificate to use at your leisure at The Blue Heron Restaurant located right next door. We have an outside Hot Tub and Fire area for you to relax and enjoy.

A serene view of a cottage resting on a rocky shoreline, surrounded by lush green trees. The calm lake reflects the building's exterior and nearby foliage under a clear sky. A small deck is visible adjacent to the water, offering potential access to the lake.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Sawmill Bay Getaway

Escape to your own slice of paradise with this 3 bed, 1.5 bath winterized cottage nestled on the tranquil shores of Sawmill Bay/Lake Ontario. Stunning lake views and the most amazing sunsets make this retreat perfect for family getaways or romantic escapes. We do not have a "beach" but have water access from the rock shore and are near public launches and marinas. Enjoy fishing, boating, kayaking, nearby restaurants, shops and a winery (across the street). Your Sawmill Bay Getaway awaits!

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

A spacious living area is highlighted by a deep blue sectional couch adorned with decorative pillows. Large windows allow for abundant natural light and provide a view of the water. A round dining table and a decorative plant enhance the inviting ambiance.

Cottage in Chaumont

The Boathouse

The views are surreal! With over a 200 degree view, sitting on the couch seems like sitting over the top of the water. Located on a small protected bay, also home to two yacht clubs, you'll see boaters of all kinds. The fishing is fabulous right from the dock. Located on a quiet private road, you'll be walking distance a from restaurants, an ice cream shop, shopping, banking, the local library, and even a small winery! There is deep water dockage if you plan to bring a boat.

A serene lakeside view features a well-maintained lawn leading to a rocky shoreline. Tall trees provide shade, while a few Adirondack chairs are positioned on the grass, offering a relaxing spot to enjoy the water. A clear sky enhances the tranquil atmosphere.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

3 Mile Retreat - Waterfront Getaway

Relax at this peaceful lakefront property. This lake home sits on a beautiful 100' waterfront with level rocky beach access, wide-open floor plan and incredible views of Chaumont Bay! Featuring a king bed in the main bedroom, and the second bedroom has a queen and twin bed. The living room sofa converts to a full bed. Two full bathrooms to accommodate you and your family. The quiet peacefulness will leave you relaxed while being close to all the local amenities the area has to offer.

Cottage in Three Mile Bay

A modern cottage exterior is showcased with large glass doors allowing for natural light. A colorful umbrella provides shade over outdoor seating. Fresh green grass and a tree stump with an owl sculpture enhance the welcoming outdoor space.

5 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

The Cresent Cottage

Welcome to the Cresent Cottage, located on a peninsula with Lake Ontario on one side and Chaumont Bay on the other. This 3 Bedroom Cottage is pet and family friendly. It's about 15-20 minutes from the St. Lawrence River know for It's world renowned fishing. This is a modernly updated cottage that comes with indoor and outdoor games and WiFi connction for days in. Sit on the deck or our front room with a lovely picture window with your cup of coffee and enjoy watching the rise and set.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

The guest room features two twin beds made with rustic log frames, accented by patterned throws. Light wood paneling covers the walls, and a ceiling fan hangs above. A small nightstand is placed beside one bed, with a lamp and decorative items displayed.

Guesthouse in Chaumont

Peaceful Getaway

Kick back and relax in this peaceful space. Guest house has two twin beds, private bathroom, microwave, toaster, Keurig, small refrigerator. WiFi access, outdoor grill with outdoor dining and seating area all under a 16x24 pavilion. This property offers incredible views, fish jumping and canoe and kayak access. End your incredible day fishing off the dock with s’mores at the fire pit. Hunters and fishermen welcome. Plenty of parking so bring your motorized toys! See you soon!

Cottage in Three Mile Bay

A cozy bedroom features a queen bed with a light gray quilt and decorative pillow shams. Two yellow pillows add a pop of color. The bed is positioned against a wall with a window dressed in patterned curtains. A decorative wall piece complements the overall decor.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Bay Breeze

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. This cozy and quaint 400 square foot cottage that sleeps 2 via a queen bed. It boasts a full bathroom with shower as well as an efficiency kitchen complete with microwave, refrigerator and a gas stove. Relax on the front porch, head down to the fire pit, or fish off the dock of the famous “Taylor boathouse”. You can also explore or dine in one of the many waterfront towns in the area such as Clayton or Sacketts Harbor.

Cottage in Three Mile Bay

A modern cottage is set against a tranquil body of water, reflecting the soft colors of the evening sky. Green grasses and a single tree enhance the natural surroundings, while warm lights from the cottage illuminate the exterior, creating a serene ambiance.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

The Oak Cottage

Welcome to your summer getaway at our charming cottage, perfectly designed for a family vacation or fishing enthusiasts! Nestled in the picturesque Chaumont Bay, our cozy retreat is one of five cottages that provide beautiful views of Lake Ontario, allowing you to soak in all that NNY has to offer for an unforgettable experience. Whether you're here visiting the area, or looking to try your hand at fishing, our cottage in Chaumont Bay is your perfect base for adventure

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 98 reviews

A serene lakeside view features a wooden dock extending into calm waters, reflecting warm sunset hues. Smooth stones line the shoreline, with a kayak resting nearby. Gentle trees frame the scene, creating a peaceful backdrop for relaxation.

Cabin in Three Mile Bay

Hideaway on the bay

Updated cabin with 100 feet of waterfront. There is Excellent swimming along with a dock, shared kayaks, and shared kids play set. Perfect family getaway. Great for fisherman, ice fishing, or a peaceful couples get away. The cabin is on a shore well and the water is not drinkable. Guests will need to bring bottled water. Close to long point state park and prime fishing. I do not suggest accessing the ice in-front of the camp. guest access at long pt 1.5 down the road.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Houses

A space thats all yours, with room for everyone

Cottages

Quaint homes, peaceful surroundings

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Popular amenities for Lyme vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Lyme

Superhost

A wooden cabin with a green metal roof is surrounded by lush greenery. Expansive windows invite natural light, and a wooden deck offers outdoor access. The building is elevated on a slight slope, and natural stones are visible in the landscape.

Tiny home in Chaumont

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Big Ben's Riverview Tiny Home

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

A living area features nautical-themed decor, with a large area rug adorned with anchors. Comfortable seating includes a brown leather sofa and a single armchair. A wooden coffee table centers the space, while natural light illuminates the room through multiple windows.

Home in Three Mile Bay

3 Mile Bay Get Away!

Home in Sackets Harbor

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

New Home in the Harbor by Lake Ontario!

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 88 reviews

A wooden pergola frames a serene view of the water, with two comfortable chairs positioned around a small table. A firepit sits in the center, surrounded by a natural setting of rocks and shoreline, under a clear blue sky.

Cottage in Chaumont

Chaumont Bay Getaway | Luxury Waterfront/Hot Tub

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

A large deck with comfortable seating overlooks a tranquil lake at sunset. The vibrant colors of the sky reflect on the water, while a tree provides minimal shade nearby. The wooden deck adds a rustic touch to the peaceful outdoor space.

Home in Dexter

Lake Cabin | Intimate Getaway

5 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

A charming cottage with a red roof is framed by lush grass and trees, with serene water visible in the distance. The sky is painted with soft hues of blue and orange as the sun sets, creating a peaceful ambiance.

Cottage in Dexter

Lakehouse & Tiki Hut on Guffin Bay

An aerial view captures the scenic landscape of Point Salubrious, highlighting lush greenery along the water's edge. The lakefront is visible with boats at dock, and the surrounding area features open fields and trees, offering a serene atmosphere perfect for outdoor activities.

Apartment in Chaumont

4.58 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Waterfront motel suite (#1) with one bedroom

A light-filled kitchen features white cabinetry and modern appliances. The open layout provides views of Chaumont Bay through large windows. Four stools are positioned at the breakfast bar, while a dining table with colorful accents is seen in the background. A welcoming door leads outside.