Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Keuka Lake

Find and book unique fireplace rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated fireplace rentals in Keuka Lake

Guests agree: these fireplace rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Home in Penn Yan

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 183 reviews

Keuka Lake Hilltop Cottage

This is a unique modern home on a beautiful setting. A circular, 15 sided layout with lots of light overlooking Keuka Lake. Well furnished in a country setting. Enjoy the fresh air and quiet. Internet from TMobile 5G. No network TV included. Guests should bring their own media devices. A HDMI compatible TV is provided. No air conditioning but high airflow due to fans, circular house and bluff location. Memory foam pad is available for use with futon or fold out. Monthly discount only Nov to Mar.

Top guest favorite

Guest suite in Penn Yan

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews

Overlooking beautiful Keuka: Sunrise to Sunset!

A self-contained apt right in the heart of the beautiful Finger Lakes. Close to Keuka College, parks, restaurants, museums, trails, wineries, and kayak/bike rentals. Room for boats/trailers. Self-check in with lock box Super clean, lower apartment features a private entrance. It has a large bedroom with a comfortable king size bed, convertible to two twins, upon request. Twin/mattresses on floor can sleep up to 2 children ($15 ea) or 1 more adult($40)per night Private bathroom with shower.

Guest favorite

Cabin in Prattsburgh

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews

Naples, wineries, breweries, hiking, Finger Lakes!

Get away in this cozy little cabin on 5 acres of mature forest. Just minutes away from the Finger Lakes wineries and breweries. Enjoy everything the Finger Lakes has to offer, kayaking, hiking, skiing -just minutes away. You will love the feel of this cabin and the warm wood stove as you relax in this quiet secluded home with full bath and great well water. Enjoy the nature trail, start a campfire, cook on the grill after the wineries and breweries. Only 8 miles to Point of Bluff Winery!

Guest favorite

Home in Penn Yan

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 163 reviews

The Carlin Cottage on Keuka Lake

The Carlin Cottage sits on the private, beautiful, and picturesque East Bluff of Keuka Lake — it's the absolute perfect getaway for a couple, small group of friends, or a family! Our adorable cozy cottage sits right on the lake and has all you need for an amazing time — a fireplace, a sun porch overlooking the lake, a deck for lounging or outdoor meals, a bonfire pit, grill, kayak, and more! The lake also has amazing restaurants, wineries, and breweries all around, so you'll never get bored!

Guest favorite

Cabin in Branchport

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

FLX Chalet I Finger Lakes Retreat *Private Pond

Cozy FLX Chalet nestled in the woods in between Keuka Lake and Naples! Relax by the outdoor fire pit or have dinner on the deck while gazing at the pretty pond. Inside the chalet is so cozy and sleeps 8 guests! Large open space perfect for hanging out with friends or family! 2 bedroom downstairs with queen bed in each. Upstairs loft with game and chill area and two queen beds! Minutes from Keuka Lake and wine trail! 15 min drive to the village of Naples. 20 mins to Bristol Ski Mountain!

Guest favorite

Home in Keuka Park

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 258 reviews

Mutual Fun Keuka Memories

If you are going to just hang out, do it at this beautiful setting on Keuka Lake. Child-Friendly. Wonderful swimming area! Scenic drives around the vineyards. Spacious, comfortable home along a very quiet road. Cozy All-Season getaway! Enjoy your own private beach and dock. Swim/float/kayak in pristine waters. Walk along the lake. Stargaze. Campfires on the shore. Wintertime retreat. Brand new leather sofa, chair and ottoman. Nice, warm fireplace. Snuggle inside and let it snow!

Guest favorite

Chalet in Dundee

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

Private Keuka Lake-front Chalet | Stunning Views

This four-season get-a-away sits directly on the Keuka Lake Wine Trail and is ready for your weekend vineyard adventure. The 171' feet of private lakefront is the quintessential summer escape or fall foliage photo vista. The home features three bedrooms, two full bathrooms, and can easily sleep ten comfortably. The downstairs game room is designed with the kids in mind. The great room has a beautiful natural stone fireplace, perfect for relaxing after a great day on the Lake.

Top guest favorite

Home in Hammondsport

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Hammy on a Rye 2 Hammondsport NY

There have been professional photos done by the Airbnb photographer, and they are finally here! This is the 2nd Hammy on a Rye right next door to the original Hammy on a Rye started almost 4 yrs ago. This is similar in size and layout as the other home. It has two king-size bedrooms, 2 full baths, a kitchen, a dining room, a living room, laundry, and central air. There is also plenty of off-street parking available. We are putting together the gas firepit and seating now

Guest favorite

Cottage in Penn Yan

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Heart of the Fingerlakes Wine Country

Our special place sits upon 5 quiet acres on the majestic Seneca Lake. With the large wrap around porch, you will get lost in this beautiful setting while sipping on a glass of wine from many of our local Wineries. On the inside the first thing you will notice is the open floor plan, granite counter tops, and wall to wall windows with views for days. This property sleeps up to 6 guest, has 2 bedrooms up stairs and a large day room that can act as a 3rd.

Guest favorite

Cottage in Branchport

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 207 reviews

Comfort and Luxury- Keuka Lake Dream Property

You must see the finest Keuka style home, and experience the life...Sleeps 4 in two separate bedrooms (one king bed - one queen) - and a full size bed for 2 additional people in the ladder accessible loft area. Need more space? Check out the house next door (Finger Lakes Most Welcome Home) (sleeps 8 in three separate bedrooms - plus one bath, kitchen. living room and covered deck) Sparkling hot tub is emptied & sanitized prior to your arrival.

Guest favorite

Cabin in Naples

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Off-grid cabin in Finger Lakes with lake view

Private hilltop cabin with lake view surrounded by wilderness. Off grid and off road. Hike 15 minutes to get to it or drive you FWD vehicle. Fire pit, covered outdoor kitchen, books and games inside. Next door to mountain bike/walking trails at Hickory Ridge preserve. Beddings, towels and cooking gear supplied. Staying at the cabin is like camping, but we try to make it so you do not need to bring any gear.

Guest favorite

Tiny home in Hammondsport

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 199 reviews

Shalestone Landing (Lakeside Tiny House)

As the name suggests, Shalestone Landing sits nestled in at the bottom of our home vineyard, atop layers and layers of hidden shale.....perfect for growing grapes! This quaint and comfortable tiny house is located on the west side of Keuka Lake offering lakeside views of gorgeous Keuka Lake. Shalestone Landing is perfect for a couple or small family (up to 4) looking to get away!