House vacation rentals in Goodyear Lake

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Goodyear Lake

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

Four rustic wooden Adirondack chairs are arranged around a stone fire pit in a grassy area beside Oaks Creek. The lush greenery contrasts with the flowing water and dense trees in the background, providing a peaceful outdoor setting for relaxation.

Home in Fly Creek

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 237 reviews

*Oaks Creek Cottage*ON the Creek*3bd 2bath Sleeps6

*RENT FROM A LOCAL!* Welcome to Oaks Creek Cottage in Fly Creek!!! This adorable 3 bed 2 bath house is RIGHT on Oaks Creek! Go 1 mile down the road to the Fly Creek General Store and grab a fishing pole! Also included is a fire pit, outdoor charcoal grill, outdoor games like corn hole, Jenga, Connect 4 and ring toss. This place is made for the outdoors! 4.5 miles to the Baseball Hall of Fame 7.3 miles to Cooperstown Dreams Park 24 miles to All Star Village 12 miles to Glimmerglass Opera House

Top guest favorite

Home in Roxbury

5 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews

Private 3BR escape w/ sweeping Mt Views & Firepit!

Click: "Show more" to read description before booking. NO PETS Perched high on a private road, The Ridge is a 3 BR / 2 bath newly constructed modern farmhouse w/ sweeping mountain views! Relax & dine outdoors on the wrap around deck & discover all of the comforts of home inside the open concept living space. Set on 5 mountainside acres, 3 min to Roxbury town & 10 min to wedding venues. Outdoor adventures await- 4 season activities at ski mountains, hiking, golf, farmers markets & culinary tours

Top guest favorite

The cabin features a gabled roof and a welcoming front porch with seating, surrounded by lush green grass. Tall trees frame the property, and an American flag is visible on a nearby pole, indicating a serene and private retreat in nature.

Home in Franklin

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Bohemian Cabin with Epic Views

Retreat to this Unique, Private Cabin on 14 private acres. Enjoy the vast mountain views and endless stars from the cozy front porch or the screened private balcony off the master bedroom. Enjoy the meditation chapel and heated guest house. Eat from apple and peach trees. Essentials include pellet stove, washer/dryer, fire pit BBQ and all essential appliances. 13 mins to the Cooperstown Baseball All Star Village. 2 miles to the Historic Village of Franklin. Vibrant Oneonta is 12 mins away.

Guest favorite

Home in West Fulton

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Beautiful Farm Cottage & Majestic Waterfall

The Sparrow House is a beautiful farmhouse with a private trail to a majestic 120' waterfall. With vintage wallpapers, eclectic antiques, a cozy fireplace, an outdoor cedar sauna, a large fenced in yard surrounded by honeysuckle vines and a spectacular mountain view, the house is a perfect getaway spot in unspoiled nature and still-wild forests of the Catskills. The waterfall is a truly magical place and considered a sacred site. The house is not appropriate for loud groups or parties. 🙏🦋🙌

Top guest favorite

A scenic view of Cooper Creek's property is captured, featuring a rainbow arching over green fields and trees. Various buildings, including the main house, are visible in the background against a backdrop of soft blue skies and hints of clouds.

Home in West Oneonta

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

Cooper Creek

Cooper Creek is a valuable piece of central New York history that was built in the late 1700s. This homestead once included an outhouse, a spring house, a Cooper shed, and a proud hand hewn timber barn. Robby and Eileen Robbins purchased the property in 1984-finding it in desperate need of plumbing, electricity, as well as emergent repairs in order to preserve as much history as possible. The 18th century beams,& the wooden pegs used instead of nails helps it maintain its unique identity.

Guest favorite

A spacious lakefront home is nestled in a wooded landscape, featuring a charming porch with ample seating. A stone chimney adds character to the exterior, complemented by a green roof. The surrounding lawn is well-maintained, providing a tranquil space for outdoor activities.

Home in Oneonta

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Lakefront, family friendly home -Baseball campers!

- Lake/waterfront home on Goodyear Lake. - Conveniently located close to local baseball camps (Cooperstown All-Star Village and Dream Park, etc.), SUNY Oneonta and Hartwick college - Large lake view patio and yard for games or campfires and lakeside deck and dock. - Enjoy swimming, excellent fishing, and watersports. Canoe, row boat, and pedal boat on site for guests. - Updated spacious home, including a fireplace and air conditioning. - Away from it all, but close to all amenities!

Guest favorite

A modern cabin design features broad wooden slats and floor-to-ceiling glass doors. A spacious deck includes loungers and a hot tub, surrounded by lush greenery, enhancing the outdoor aesthetic. Soft lighting illuminates the seating area, creating a welcoming environment.

Home in Hunter

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Modern House with Mountain View @Getawind

Experience luxury and comfort in our newly built property. Marvel at the breathtaking panoramic views of Rusk mountain through floor-to-ceiling windows. Unwind in the sauna or hot tub, and gather around the fire pit for cozy evenings. Enjoy outdoor movie nights with our projector, or savor grilled delights in the patio area. Warm up by the fireplace, explore Ski resorts, Golf Clubs and more. It's the perfect retreat for families and friends. Book now and create unforgettable memories!

Guest favorite

Home in Davenport

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Cooperstown Vicinity Country Home near Motorsports

Charming open concept house nestled in the Catskill mountains 20 min E. of Oneonta. Exquisite Views! (**Adjacent to motorcycle racetrack. It's not visible, but noisy in daytime 9am-5pm 4-5 days/wk.) Enjoy a morning read in our comfy sofas and armchairs or get cozy by the gas fireplace at night. Explore our 20-acre property or relax out on the wide, sunny lawn. Outdoor table and chairs by the firepit are perfect for an evening meal overlooking the beautiful, ancient Catskill Mountains.

Top guest favorite

A firepit surrounded by five wooden chairs is positioned on a gravel area, offering expansive views of the rolling hills at sunset. String lights above enhance the ambiance as the sky transitions into warm hues of orange and purple.

Home in Jefferson

5 out of 5 average rating, 123 reviews

Catskills Mountaintop House w/ HOT TUB and VIEWS!

Welcome to the best sweeping views in all of the Catskills! This secluded getaway sits on more than 8 acres of land without a neighbor in sight! Whether you are looking to vacation with friends and family, or a romantic escape, this is the place for you. Enjoy this 3 BD 2.5 BA home year round, including our 8 person hot tub! Amenities galore including outdoor firepit, lounge chairs, sledding, BBQ, ping pong, board games, TV and more. This house is perfect for travelers of all types!

Top guest favorite

The rustic cabin features a sloped green metal roof and a spacious wooden deck, surrounded by well-maintained gardens with colorful flowers. Lush trees provide a natural backdrop, enhancing the peaceful setting of the 12-acre property.

Home in Roxbury

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Mountain and tree view cabin on 12 private acres

A great escape awaits you on 12 acres of private land. If you prefer a relaxing vacation or if you want to get involved in local activities (hiking, biking, swimming, skiing, snowshoeing, sledding), this is your place. Enjoy 360 degree views of the Catskill Mountains from almost anywhere on the property. Sip your morning coffee while watching the sunrise on the large deck. Play in the large private yard. Clear evenings are the best for sunsets, a fire pit and star gazing.

Top guest favorite

A welcoming entrance is featured with a set of steps leading to a covered porch. A rail surrounds the porch, while hanging plants add a touch of greenery. Paved pathways and a level concrete area are visible, providing accessibility and a minimalist outdoor space.

Home in Milford

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

At Home Base - Guest House

Enjoy the Cooperstown experience while having all the comforts of home. The Baseball Hall of Fame (6 miles), Brewery Ommegang (5.4 miles), and The Cooperstown Dreams Park (0.5 miles) are all conveniently located. Scenic views from the large-covered deck of the rolling hills set on 20 acres. Check out all of the amenities including high speed internet, central air, and a BBQ grill. View our other “Home Base” listings here on Airbnb, all in the vicinity of one another.

Superhost

Home in Jefferson

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

Catskill Tiny Cabin Hot Tub & Sauna Under Stars!

Welcome to the Mountain Milla! The perfect modern tiny house with the ultimate luxury outdoor experience. You will love our outdoor movie theatre, hot tub and one of a kind wood burning vintage horse carriage SAUNA. Our Milla combines the charm of nature with the comforts of modern luxury amenities. Our private micro resort offers a serene escape while at the same time allowing you to relax in the comforts of modern amenities, it is truly a one of a kind experience.