
Places to stay near Castaway Bay
Book unique vacation rentals, homes, and more on Airbnb
Top-rated vacation rentals near Castaway Bay
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

180° Lake View in the Heart of Downtown Sandusky
This 3-BR, 2-BA loft's high-end furnishings & incredible 180° bay views make it truly unique. Located in the luxury waterfront Chesapeake Condos in the heart of downtown Sandusky with views of Lake Erie & Cedar Point, this is the ideal location for experiencing the North Coast & islands. Walk a few min to restaurants, shops & more, & ferry to Cedar Point or the islands. Less than 10 min to Cedar Point & other attractions. Building has outdoor pool and fitness room. Off-street parking for 2 cars.

Cabin near Cedar Point with Hot Tub & Fire Pit
We personally hand-crafted and built Dancing Fox with 95% gathered salvaged and re-purposed materials to enable us to offer our guests an environment that will sweep you back to the earlier life and times in rural plains Ohio. Relax and experience unique lodging combined with modern amenities yet enjoy the casual rustic nature of what our cabin will radiate during your stay. You'll enjoy features like antique chalkboards used as countertops, hayloft floors, handmade lighting fixtures and more.

White waterfront cottage, close to cedar point
Cute waterfront cottage. Completely updated summer 2021 with new flooring throughout, new kitchen, kitchen appliances. New bathroom (2021). Waterfront seating and propane fire pit. Views of Pipe Creek and the east bay of Sandusky Bay. Sleeps 7. Recently added 28’ dock for use (for 2023 season) Close to everything Sandusky and the surrounding areas have to offer. Minutes to Cedar Point, downtown, Sports Force. Check out my guidebooks by clicking on my profile for restaurants and activities!

2 min drive to Cedar Point & game room!!
Skip the traffic! Located only 1 mile from cedar point and downtown Sandusky our 3 bedrooms, 1,600 square ft, open concept home is a convenient choice for your next vacation! Upgraded amentities and unique experiences make our place a one of a kind gem! Watch the evening firework show from the master bedroom or walk to a nearby brewery (4 blocks away). King bed, 1 queen bed, 1 twin bed, and a very spacious couch. Plus plenty of space to blow up air mattress. House was fully renovated in 2015.

Everything is Better at the Lake!
Want a getaway along the Lake Erie Shores, then you have found it! Our historic newly renovated spacious condo comes with everything you would want. The joint living, dining, workstation, and kitchen area boasts one of the largest living areas in all of the Lofts.Its location is ideal, next to the Goodtime cruise ship and Jet Express for a quick ride to Kelley’s Island and Put-in-Bay, and within walking and biking distance to many restaurants and attractions…and a short drive to Cedar Point!

Pet-Friendly Cottage • Mins to Downtown Vermilion
Ahoy! Sailor’s Way is a relaxing, pet friendly cottage minutes away from the quaint, downtown Vermilion. Whether you’re shopping, eating, boating, or checking out the farmer’s market, Vermilion always has something going on, so book your stay! Although there is no beach access, at the end of the road, you can see Lake Erie! The cottage is close to public beach access, the lighthouse and several parks. Approximately 45 minutes to the Miller Ferry Port and 35 minutes to Cedar Point.

The Farmer's Cottage
The Farmer's cottage is a cozy one bedroom mid-century farm cottage on 2 acres of land nestled among farm fields and woodlands . It features a queen-sized bed, bath and full custom kitchen along with a smart TV and Wi-Fi. . A park-like yard with a stone fireplace and solar installation awaits. This country property features self contained utilities including a water well, sanitation and electricity. Enjoy fresh eggs from our chickens and baked goods from our farm kitchens.

Festive Grinchmas Getaway Downtown At The Loft!
Step into the heart of Whoville where holiday magic, laughter, and a bit of Grinchy mischief come to life! This one of a kind Grinch themed condo is decked out in festive cheer and cozy comforts for everyone's favorite holiday classic! - Free parking 2 vehicles - High speed internet/Wi-Fi - Fully stocked kitchen - 3 TV's w/ Roku streaming device - Full-size arcade game - King bed, queen bed, 3 twin size rollaway beds, futon couch - Inground pool & hot tub (Seasonal) - Gym

Sport Extravaganza | Near CP & SF | W/D| Pet OK
Upper-level duplex unit, perfect for families or groups. This inviting space boasts 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, a fully equipped kitchen, and a combined dining/living area that opens onto a private deck for serene mornings or peaceful evenings. Added convenience is provided with a washer and dryer located downstairs. The unit comfortably accommodates up to 7 guests across 6 beds. Minutes to Cedar Point (5 min), Kalahari Resort (10 min), waterfront, ferries, shopping, and groceries.

Downtown Boho Studio at The Montgomery
Welcome to our BoHo Studio! One block from Sandusky Bay waterfront, The Montgomery, built in the late 1800's, is located in heart of Sandusky's downtown historic district. The Boho Studio @ The Montgomery is cozy space with an eclectic artsy vibe. This space is outfitted with meditation pillows, games, vinyl record player. The Montgomery has an outdoor community courtyard and literally steps away from a variety of restaurants, shopping, activities, and culture.

Cute Waterfront Home
2 bed (upstairs) 1 bath (downstairs) waterfront home, fully furnished. Minutes to Cedar Point, beaches, Sports Force, and downtown Sandusky. Outdoor patio space, with propane fire pit, adjacent to the water. Relax and watch boats moving along the channel. Enjoy the short drive to and from Cedar Point. Propane Grill We have a boat dock available at marina next door for our guests bringing a boat.

Luxury Farmhouse Apartment -Downtown 1 BR. 1B
This is not your typical Airbnb experience! Escape to rustic comfort in our Gorgeous Farmhouse Suite, just 3 minutes away from Cedar Point. Carefully curated design features warm wood elements, a farmhouse decor, and rustic accents for a cozy ambiance. Modern amenities include high-speed internet, a smart TV, and a fully equipped kitchen. Experience tranquility in the heart of Sandusky, Ohio.
Popular amenities for vacation rentals near Castaway Bay
Condo rentals with wifi

Chesapeake Lofts Condo

Poolside Condo Downtown Sandusky

C&D Book 2 - 3rd night is free 9/1/25 - 3/31/26

Waterfront Condo Port Clinton Beach & Pool

Lovely Waterfront Condo

Lake Erie Retreat

Waterfront condo near Jet Express (Zeitzheim)

Waterfront 1 Bdrm condo w/ Pool - Walk to the Jet!
Family-friendly house rentals

Country House in the woods with all the amenities

Cove Lockwood

Rock House - Lake Views & 15 Mins to Cedar Point

Our Happy Place, Lake views, mins from Cedar Point

Lakefront Retreat on Lake Erie! Amazing Views!

The Penthouse Suite -5 mins to Cedar Point

GLASS HOUSE 5 BR Private Lake Erie Beach

Cedar Point/Summit Motor Sprts/Kahlahari/Lake Erie
Apartment rentals with air conditioning

Vine Street Suite

Home away from home-2 bedroom apt.

2 Bedroom Apartment - End O'Way BnB

Robin’s Nest-Downtown-Port Clinton, Ohio

Your Home Away from Home

Simple spacious apartment near Oberlin College

Studio apt near Cedar Point & Cleveland w/ Sauna

*2BedRM *Spacious & Charming* Downtown* Lake Erie*
Other great vacation rentals near Castaway Bay

Minutes to Cedar Point & CP sports center

The Michael Lake House

Cozy Beachtown Bungalow - The Perfect Getaway!

Rye Beach House - Lake Erie

Comfy Cottage at Bayfront Resort #2

The Coaster Cottage- 1.5 miles to Cedar Point

Coastal Studio 16 mi to Cedar Point - 2 Queen Beds

Charming ranch home
Destinations to explore
- Cedar Point
- Point Pelee National Park
- East Harbor State Park
- Cleveland Metroparks Zoo
- The Watering Hole Safari and Waterpark (Monsoon Lagoon)
- Memphis Kiddie Park
- Catawba Island State Park
- Maumee Bay State Park
- South Bass Island State Park
- Firelands Winery & Restaurant
- Island Adventures Family Fun Center
- Put in Bay Winery
- Sutton Creek Golf Course
- Paper Moon Vineyards
- Heineman Winery




