Vacation rentals in Casey Key

4/2.5 Oak Bahay, Heated Pool! 5min to Beach,4Acres

Welcome to Oak Bahay Ranch, our beautiful 4+ acre ranch home with pool! Enjoy the tranquility of this 4 bedroom/2.5 bathrooms with a pool (heated during winter). Bike or drive the quick 2.5 miles to Nokomis and Casey Key Beaches! Oak Bahay Ranch is a nature lover's paradise, close to Legacy Trail, Sarasota County's premier 20+ mile biking/walking trail. Oak Bahay Ranch is an easy drive to world famous Siesta Key Beach (15 mins), downtown Sarasota (20 mins), and downtown Venice (10 mins).

Top guest favorite

Guest favorite

Tropical Pool Paradise - Minutes from the Beach!

Welcome to your own slice of paradise! This beautifully updated and completely eco-friendly and HEATED pool home in a quiet neighborhood is the perfect setting for your relaxing Florida vacation! You will love the privacy of this home overlooking tropical landscape vistas from the large covered lanai and solar heated pool welcoming you to your PRIVATE OASIS. You will enjoy easy access to our gulf coast beaches just minutes away. Beautiful Nokomis public beach is a 7 minute drive away.

Location · Family · Beach

Private Beachfront Casey Key Cottage B

Experience Old Florida charm! This direct beachfront retreat offers stunning views of the aqua-blue Gulf of Mexico. Wake up to the sound of waves and enjoy year-round swimming in crystal-clear waters just steps from your door. The powdery sand invites pure relaxation. Inside, you'll find a spacious layout with two bedrooms, a full kitchen, living room, and washer/dryer. Unwind on the wraparound patio deck and soak in paradise. Book your beach escape today

Top guest favorite

Guest favorite

Short walk to beach 4, King bed, Dog Friendly

Location Location Location! A few steps to beach, and short walk or bike ride down the tree lined boulevard takes you to Historic Downtown Venice where you'll find, Restaurants, Cafes, and Boutiques. Experience island life from this 1 BR, 1st floor condo, walk to everything. Pack your bathing suit, and flip flops, with all the comforts of home, beach towels, umbrella, and chairs, provided, that's all you'll need here! Sofa bed also available.

Top guest favorite

Guest favorite

Staycation Sanctuary

Our property is clean and welcoming. You can enjoy a relaxing, warm and peaceful getaway from the rest of the world just steps to the beach. This is the perfect "Old Florida-style" location to experience the comfort and hospitality you so deserve! Grab your bathing suit/flip flops and enjoy tranquillity of beach life, sunsets and lazy days of fishing and bird/dolphin/manatee watching and gathering sea shells-- all only 2 blocks away!

Bayview Oasis on Casey Key

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space! Relax in a 3 bedroom 2 bath condo overlooking the canal. Sit outside in the screened in lanai outside your back door and enjoy the nature & boats or grab a fishing pole and fish off the docks. Only a short walk across the street to beautiful private Nokomis Beach. Amazing sunsets. Old Florida beach island still close to all the amenities you need for an amazing vacation!

New Pool Tropical Waterfront Dock & Optional Boat

Located on a highly desirable street, the house is perched high above Curry Creek offering spectacular water views from every room. The property includes a boat ramp to avoid the public launch. Three kayaks (two tandems and one single). Two miles from Nokomis Beach and only half a mile from The Legacy Bike Trail. You can do so many fun things, or just have a drink on the dock and watch the manatees. Pet Friendly

Top guest favorite

Guest favorite

Cozy Beach Cottage, 2 Blocks to Nokomis Beach

Two blocks to Nokomis Beach. Walk to waterfront dining, ice cream, and local shops without touching your car. This cozy 2BR/1BA beach cottage sleeps 4 with two queen bedrooms, a fully stocked kitchen, and all the beach gear you need (chairs, umbrellas, towels). Fast WiFi, smart TVs, gas grill, and washer/dryer. Single level home in a laid back old Florida neighborhood. Just show up and relax.

Renovated Double Efficiency

Welcome to this newly renovated double efficiency with pool and beach access . Modern aesthetics greet you with neutral colors and a beach vibe. You're just steps from the sand for a walk on the beach and soaking up the warm rays. The mini kitchen is a convenient option for meals and local restaurants are a short walk away. Enjoy the peaceful island atmosphere of Casey Key!

Top guest favorite

Guest favorite

SEPT SALE! Sarasota #1 Luxury Villa! PRIV BEACH!

BOOK 2025 NOW, and stay in Style magazines exclusive beachfront gem! This property OWNS THE BEACH!! UNIQUE PRIVATE POOL & BEACH combo is HEAVEN! Private ELEVATOR! 32,000/gl FREEFORM POOL, with 4 WATERFALLS, HOT GROTTO with HOT falls! NEW BBQ PIT AREA, BIKES, KAYAKS, and PADDLEBOARDS! WRAPAROUND BALCONY, CHEF kitchen. Hosted CELEBS! SHOPPING, FINE DINING, watch our VIDEOS!

Top guest favorite

Guest favorite

Casa del Sol II (Non-Smoking Property)

Spacious 3 bedroom 2 bath with 800 sq ft covered porch overlooking neighborhood. Carport under building for up to 4 cars. Private stairway entrance. Lots of sliding glass doors gives you a treehouse effect. All electric home powered by 120 solar panels. 4 minute walk to beautiful Nokomis Beach.

Private Beachside Kitchenette

14 room Beach Resort on beautiful Casey Key. This newly designed condo features memory foam beds, couch, safe, HDTV, WIFI, kitchenette & dinette, keurig coffee maker, quiet mini split ac/heat, walkin granite shower & is 25 steps to the sandy beach.