Vacation rentals in Carmi

Point Blank - Quiet Lakefront Living!

Get ready for a relaxing stay with your family or friends! This unique, freshly remodeled, Carmi home offers a BEAUTIFUL lake view, 4 bedrooms with all new beds and 2.5 bathrooms. Feel free to bring your fishing poles and swimsuits and take advantage of the peaceful Pontca Lake right out your doorstep. Renting this home gives you full access to the 25 acre lake and newly renovated private beach area. It’s perfect for swimming, fishing, canoeing or kayaking! *We provide a kayak and a swim mat!

Elemental Harmony House

Centrally located walking distance from all attractions in New Harmony, our house is a peaceful & quiet retreat for a single overnight or an extended stay. We've taken great care to love our guests the way we love our house & have everything you need to feel at home with the tools you need to cook meals, prepare an espresso or tea, or work from our office area. We also have yoga mats, bolsters & blocks for your practice. Enjoy two spacious decks and our porch swing when the weather permits!

The Angel Carriage House in New Harmony

Cozy and elegant, located in the heart of historic New Harmony, this 1920's carriage house was reimagined, expanded, and tastefully furnished as a stand-alone guest house in 2016. It includes a fully equipped kitchen, roomy bedroom plus queen-sized sofa bed in the living room, two full baths, hi-speed WIFI, three HD TVs, a private back porch with one of the best views in New Harmony, and heated & A/Ced garage. Relax and recharge, just one or two blocks from the town's key attractions.

New Harmony Cottage

Open concept cottage w lots of space for one or two located in the Historic District of New Harmony. Free street parking, a sitting area and comfortable queen bed. Washer/Dryer and a small kitchenette (no stove or cooktop.) WiFi and and a Smart TV for your convenience. Bring your Netflix or Hulu passwords. Be our guest in your own space. Easy no contact checkin & checkout. Coffee/Tea bar or Black Lodge Coffee! *FYI check hours for shops & restaurants that you plan on visiting.

Honeycomb Hideaway

Welcome to Honeycomb Hideaway, a vibrant yellow cottage nestled in the heart of historic New Harmony, Indiana. Our cozy one-bedroom retreat offers a peaceful and exciting escape, just steps away from Murphy Park, fantastic restaurants, and captivating tourist activities. Immerse yourself in New Harmony's rich heritage, exploring charming streets, unique shops, and art galleries. Indulge in local cuisine or embark on outdoor adventures in parks and walking trails.

The Geneva Cabin

The Geneva Cabin is one of a kind (not in the woods) and has everything you need to enjoy whatever occasion brings you to the area. Located less than 2 miles from the wildlife refuge, 10 min to downtown Henderson, 7 mi to I-69 the property sits in the middle of a quiet dead-end street. Right in the middle of anywhere anyway your journey takes you. 55” TV, sofa bed and recliner in living room, WIFI, washer & dryer. Fully equipped kitchen. Large parking area.

The Main Street Loft

Artsy. Spacious. Exceptionally comfortable. Experience cozy hospitality in our newly remodeled 1920’s luxury loft. The loft is a private apartment on the 2nd floor. It has a separate outside entrance with its own keypad lock. The loft has a fully-stocked kitchen, dining room, living room, smart TV, laundry room, bathroom, & 3 bedrooms. Each bed is covered in quality bedding. There is a couch & a futon in the living room, which guests are welcome to sleep on.

Welcome to The Farm

Reconnect with nature at this unforgettable escape. Just 5 minutes from town, you will be in awe of this tiny home. It has everything you need to have an unforgettable time away from home. There is a nice pond stocked with fish, beach area, outdoor kitchen, and fire pit. The tiny home is equipped with everything you will need. Just bring your food and clothes to get away from the busy everyday life!

The Sunshine Guest House☆ Pool table/pond/yard fun

The Sunshine Guest House is a bright and welcoming home with an easy to find location right outside of Mcleansboro, (6 miles from Big Red Barn& 9 miles from I64) Wi-fi is available throughout our spacious 4 bedroom and 2 baths. Our house can accommodate up to 9 people. It also includes a large deck for outside entertaining with a charcoal grill, yard games, kids toys and stocked pond.

The Main St Carriage House - a charming cottage

This is a charming 1 bedroom 1.5 bath cottage located in the heart of Carmi. Enjoy the fully stocked kitchen, dining table for 4, high speed Wi-Fi, two smart TVs, 1 queen bed upstairs with a half bath, with a full Bath on the main floor, and a private parking spot. We also have a 25amp Level 2 charger available upon request for anyone needing to charge their EV while they stay!

Cozy Garden Home in New Harmony for 6

Welcome to our charming retreat in New Harmony, Indiana! This cozy home comfortably sleeps 6 and is bursting with warm vibes and inviting spaces. Enjoy lazy afternoons in our beautiful garden, sip coffee on the sunny porch, and explore the town's rich artsy culture. Perfect for family getaways or fun trips with friends, you'll love the relaxed charm of this hidden gem!

Nama-Stay ~ A Zen Cabin Retreat

Rustic and cozy cabin nestled in the middle of 3 wooded acres. It provides the perfect escape for travelers looking for a peaceful, quiet getaway, with modern amenities. Conveniently located ten minutes from downtown. House Rules • No Pets • No Smoking • No Parties • No Weddings, Events or Commercial Use • Must be 21 to book