Pet-friendly vacation rentals in Baiting Hollow

Nanette and Jaime were wonderful hosts. The house felt like home, and the place felt bigger than what it seemed like from the photos. Our family enjoyed the time in the hot tub (also not shown in photos) during the chillier evening. Thank you for a wonderful time!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A Perfect Stay! From the moment we arrived, we felt completely at home. The space was sparkling clean. The host was incredibly responsive, kind, and made check-in a breeze. The location was ideal—peaceful and quiet, yet close to everything we wanted to explore. After long days out, it was so relaxing to return to such a cozy and comfortable space. We truly didn’t want to leave! Highly recommend this Airbnb to anyone looking for a restful, welcoming, and seamless experience.

This stay was truly beyond incredible—it far exceeded all of my expectations! The house was not only stunning and beautifully decorated, but it also had such a warm and inviting feel the moment I walked in. It was spotless, impeccably clean, and clearly cared for with love and attention to detail. The highlight for me was the serene back deck overlooking the canal—such a peaceful, calming space that made it easy to relax and unwind. I found myself spending hours out there, just soaking in the tranquility. Yoon was an absolute dream to communicate with—always prompt, kind, and so accommodating. Every part of this experience was seamless and full of thoughtful touches. I honestly can’t say enough amazing things about the home, the location, and the entire experience. It was perfect in every way! I’m already looking forward to my next visit.

My husband, our dogs, and I just returned home after spending a month at Sarah's house on Long Island. we truly didn't want to leave, it was so relaxing! The lousy May weather notwithstanding, the property was absolutely perfect for us. Everything was as described and we felt right at home. Sarah was super proactive/responsive. While we were only able to use the pool a couple of times (weather), it was great and the spa was awesome, especially in the evening under the pretty lights in the backyard! There were great spaces to work (hubby didn't have the full month off like I did) and to just chill. The house is located near many conveniences (I'm looking at you, Walmart) to pick up necessities and while we didn't cook for ourselves quite a bit, we were thrilled that unlike at home, the food delivery services were fast, reliable, and everything arrived at the perfect temperature! we can't say enough good things about our stay and will definitely be returning!

We liked how easy it was to punch the code in to get into the home. Once in the home, it was really nice to see the welcome placard. We enjoyed access to robes, skincare, slippers, towels, etc. The game room was loads of fun. The indoor and outdoor ping pong tables were fun. We enjoyed billiards, arcade games and table games. The icing on the cake were the hot tub, the four mode shower and bidet. The Smart Home technology took a little getting used to, but it was very convenient once we did. We love the quick response time whenever we had a question or concern. This place allowed for a rejuvenating relaxing atmosphere and we are so glad that we chose “The Good Vibes” home for our debut AirBNB experience. Thanks again for hosting us in your charming abode!

Konrad’s home was perfect for my family visiting Long Island for my sister’s graduation. He was proactive and helpful in giving us info before and during our stay. The house is beautiful and comfortable. The kitchen is also super functional and has all of the gear you need to cook for a group. I’d highly recommend staying here!

Had a lovely time in the Hamptons! Tasha was an amazing host- easiest check in/out, very responsive, and gave great recommendations for places in the area. Would love to stay here again!

Nice and cozy house close to the beach, place to park, peaceful and quiet which was perfect for a family stay to forget about loud city sounds. Highly recommended ❤️

Gabby’s apartment is exactly as described. It is in a great location. Very close to Stoney Brook Village. We enjoyed walking to get our morning coffee. The apartment was very well stocked and spotless. Gabby thought of everything we could have possibly needed. We hope to be back next year!

Gorgeous house and property that is even better than the photos. Like other reviews have mentioned, the highway noise in the backyard is definitely present, but easy enough to ignore. Really enjoyed our stay and communication was great!

We had the most beautiful weekend stay at Tim’s home! Everything is accurately described and the pool and hot tub were amazing!! All the beds were very comfortable. Was perfect for a 5 girl weekend getaway!! Tim was incredibly communicative and checking in was a breeze. The location is PERFECT in East Hampton!! So many amazing restaurants and bars nearby. 100% will stay here again for my next Hamptons trip. Thank you so much Tim!!

Location was convenient, place matched description and host was friendly and reachable. Would stay here again!

Great house in a quiet neighborhood. Heated pool and the hot tub were the highlights of the trip. Aida is super responsive and friendly

Had a wonderful little getaway in Hilder’s guest house. The place was clean and cozy! I would return here for another weekend getaway.

We we’re going to Port Jefferson for a family wedding. Our Airbnb was perfectly situated. There is a pool area that we never used because we just didn’t have time. But it looked very inviting. The town of Port Jefferson had plenty of nice restaurants and shops. This house was perfect for our situation. We had six adults, all family members.

Una casa bella para pasar siempre con personas importantes.

Loved this spot! Was the perfect weekend trip and close to lots of different places in the Hamptons. Grace was super responsive and the house was very clean and modern. Would definitely recommend as a place to stay. Will hopefully be back soon. ☺️

We had a relaxing overnight with our two pups! The bay/sound area is so peaceful. Our dogs enjoyed swimming before the tide came in and we kayaked along the shoreline. The inside was stunning and had everything you needed and more! We door dashed lobster rolls from the Bonfire Grille nearby (10/10) and ended the night in the hot tub! Coffee on the sunny patio was a great perk, too! Thanks again!!

The house was gorgeous and such a beautiful location and time of year to stay. Highly recommended!

Ashley’s house is the perfect get away. I booked this house for my family to stay for my wedding weekend. My mom had never stayed in an Airbnb before and I’ve never seen her so happy and relaxed. She truly enjoyed her first Airbnb experience at Ashley’s place. It was exactly as described and the view is beautiful. Ashley was very responsive and made sure to answer any questions I had.

We had a fabulous weekend at this lovely cottage. Located on a remote peninsula surrounded by the glistening water we couldn’t have asked for a nicer experience. The amenities were both convenient and thoughtful. Although we chose to dine out, the kitchen was very modern with upscale appliances and an espresso machine. We did bbq on our last night and had a great end to our 4 night stay!

The camper feels roomy, cozy and comfortable. Includes all amenities and even some not listed. The farm property is located in a peaceful setting and very close to Riverhead and the many wineries in the area. This camper is a good value considering the cost of hotels on Long Island. Susan is a friendly and responsive host. Looking forward to staying here in the future.

We had the most wonderful and peaceful fall weekend at Brooke’s cozy cottage to celebrate our anniversary, and it was truly unforgettable! The cottage itself is beautifully decorated and felt like a warm home away from home. Brooke went above and beyond to make our stay special, leaving us complimentary champagne and wine to kick off our celebration. The location was perfect for enjoying the crisp fall air and stunning foliage, providing the peaceful retreat we were hoping for. We can’t recommend this place enough and will definitely be back for another stay!

Katy’s place is located right in the heart of Riverhead old district next to the aquarium great seafood, restaurants and Turkish restaurants nearby beautiful parks great fishing spots I would highly recommend it.