Guidebook for Shelter Island
Essentials
IGA Shelter Island
75 N Ferry Rdgrocery store
gourmet groceries and prepared foods, great croissant and seating on the water to enjoy a cafe.
41 locals recommend
Marie Eiffel Market
184 N Ferry Rdgourmet groceries and prepared foods, great croissant and seating on the water to enjoy a cafe.
Everything Else
Shelter Island Town Hall
38 N Ferry Rdbeach stickers
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
80 N Ferry Rdfarm stand
Moussa Drame Tennis
13 Shore Rdtennis courts and lessons
Piccozzi's Fuel & Bike Shop
1 Bridge Stgas station, bike rental
Golf Course
26 Sunnyside Avegolf
Shelter Island Yoga & Fitness
13 Winthrop Rdyoga!
Drinks & Nightlife
great for cocktails and fun night out. also pay parking if you dont have a beach sticker
93 locals recommend
Sunset Beach
Shore Rdgreat for cocktails and fun night out. also pay parking if you dont have a beach sticker
Sightseeing
Mashomack Preserve
79 S Ferry Rdnature preserve
Food Scene
18 Bay
11 N Ferry Rdquieter night out, great food
Salt has a bar that is in a boat (on land) and has live music. fun for families as kids can run around, fun for non families because there is usually something going on. Some of the better food on the island.
34 locals recommend
SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill
63 S Menantic RdSalt has a bar that is in a boat (on land) and has live music. fun for families as kids can run around, fun for non families because there is usually something going on. Some of the better food on the island.
Vine Street Café
41 S Ferry RdFestive and kid friendly
Arts & Culture
Havens House
16 S Ferry RdParks & Nature
need a sticker- social beach for families, bathrooms, walk all the way too the right to find an inlet great for privacy and little kids
12 locals recommend
Wades Beach
114 S Midway Rdneed a sticker- social beach for families, bathrooms, walk all the way too the right to find an inlet great for privacy and little kids
Menhadden Lane
a favorite of ours and closest to the house. need a sticker!
South Silver Beach Road
South Silver Beach Roadmost secluded beach- need a sticker here too!