Vacation rentals in Potter

Blūm on the Hill Cottage in the Finger Lakes

Enjoy a peaceful stay in our cottage located just over 2 miles from the quaint village of Penn Yan on Keuka Lake. Relax in the newly renovated 2 bedroom, 2 full bath home with a fully equipped dine-in kitchen, spacious living room with electric fireplace, and dining room. Enjoy the fresh air on the back deck with Keuka Lake peeking through the trees. Take in the sites of the many trails, vineyards, breweries and state parks in the area during your stay. So just relax, you're on lake time.

Grandpa-T’s Guest Cottage at Hawks Landing

Welcome to Grandpa-T’s Guest Cottage at Hawks Landing… your romantic getaway! Located in the heart of the Finger Lakes, this extraordinary property perched above Canandaigua Lake with its spectacular views is within minutes of all the region has to offer. Hiking, fishing, boating, cycling, kayaking, snow many opportunities our guests can enjoy locally or just simply unplug and relax in the quiet of this cozy cabin. Come celebrate your special moments in the privacy of this beautiful cottage!

Guyanoga Getaway ~Peaceful~ 5 min. to Keuka Lake

Nature lovers! Ideal vacation home for a small family, couples getaway or girls/guys weekend. Nestled in the woods, this secluded cabin-like ranch home has a beautiful view of the Guyanoga Valley. Located only 2 miles from Keuka Lake State Park, and a short drive to Penn Yan, this 3-bedroom has all of the comforts of home. Enjoy a cup of coffee on the deck. Minutes away from the lake; breathtaking scenery, wineries and craft breweries. You'll find small-town hospitality in Yates County.

Charming Country Cabin- HOT TUB, Sunsets, CMAC

Let the stress melt away as you take a break and unwind at this peaceful oasis. The Cabin is a divine intertwine of a rustic cabin with an elegant master bedroom in a relaxed country setting. Enjoy a soak in the hot tub before you cozy up in front of the pellet stove! All in a fabulous location close to Canandaigua Lake, wineries, breweries, hiking and Naples. Beautiful downtown Canandaigua is a 12 minute drive away for shopping or dinner. Boat/horse trailer parking available. 7min to CMAC

Gorgeous Newly Renovated Waterfront Cabin

Enjoy your morning coffee in this light-filled, modern, cozy, and instagram worthy lakefront cabin with stunning views.  In addition to the freshly designer renovated interiors, this home features a private dock and a brand new wood deck for relishing the beauty of the Finger Lakes. This amazing property sits on the quiet and peaceful Y-end of Keuka Lake in the quaint town of Branchport. There is a marina three houses down if you wish to rent a boat and take advantage of the private dock.

Getaway in the Heart of Wine Country!

Autumn is coming - see fall colors of the Finger Lakes at the Acres at Potter! Central between Canandaigua, Penn Yan, Hammondsport & Naples; easy access to wineries, breweries, pubs, skiing, hiking, Watkins Glen, close to Canandaigua & Keuka lakes. Great for families or multiple couples with 2 bedrooms, bunk beds, a futon and a pull out couch. There’s a great room that is ideal for entertaining, games. Starlink internet access. A well equipped kitchen has a breakfast bar & large table.

Finger Lakes Serenity

Located on a quiet country road, you'll feel peace and calmness in our family friendly home that is only 10 minutes from Keuka Lake. The home is surrounded by farmer's fields and neighboring woods, leaving you to hear the sounds of country life as you spend time on the large back deck. With our 3 bedroom home which sleeps 6, everyone can have their space yet enjoy one another's company around the dining room table. The kitchen is stocked for your basic cooking and baking needs.

Maiden Lane Charm

Cozy updated cottage within walking distance and access to a private community beach. 2 bedrooms, fully equipped kitchen, bath and living space. This charming 800 sq foot home features a gas fire place to keep you cozy in the winter and an upper deck with lake view for relaxing in the warmer months. Large yard, partially fenced in, with play house for children. The storage shed houses outdoor games and wagon for the short trip (.3 miles) to the beach. 4 miles from CMAC.

Finger Lakes Hilltop Chalet Relax, Unwind & Renew

This log cabin chalet tucked back in the woods invites you to kick back and relax, with a cozy fireplace, hot tub, and rejuvenating sauna adding to the luxurious atmosphere. Nestled in the woods on 9 acres, the property provides a tranquil haven, complete with walking trails that allow you to connect with nature. Whether you're enjoying the warmth of the fireplace or strolling through the peaceful surroundings, this home offers the perfect blend of comfort and tranquility.

Beautiful Keuka Lake home close to Penn Yan.

Welcome to Keuka lake in this beautiful home that boasts 3 master suites. The living room has a panoramic view of Keuka Lake. There is a deck off the top floor and a patio off the first floor to sit and enjoy the lake view as well. From the downstairs patio you are only a few steps to the beach. At the end of the dock the lake is only 3 feet deep so it’s excellent for swimming. Everything in this house is new and very clean. We are a mile from downtown Penn Yan.

The Best Getaway on the Keuka Lake Wine Trail

Welcome to our “tree house" paradise on Keuka lake! It's one of the most unique cottages on Keuka. Our lake home promises you an unforgettable vacation on Keuka, with unparalleled views of the lake. Spend your days lounging on the beach, swimming, fishing, kayaking or tasting the local wine & cheese before you wind down on the hammock, taking in breathtaking views among the Keuka treetops. End each night with memories (and S’mores!) ‘round the campfire!

Sanctum at Sunset Lake

Sanctum at Sunset Lake is a private, design-forward retreat on the coveted east shore, offering rare, unobstructed sunset views across the water. Thoughtfully curated with natural textures and expansive windows, the home blurs indoor and outdoor living. Mornings bring soft light and stillness; evenings are reserved for golden hour and quiet reflection. Designed for rest, presence, and elevated comfort, Sanctum is more than a stay—it’s a reset.