Vacation rentals in Horseshoe Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Horseshoe Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

The image captures a serene sunset over the lake, with warm hues illuminating the sky. Properties and trees frame the scene, while boats are visible on the water. Power lines traverse the foreground, connecting the area with the surrounding landscape.

Cottage in Jefferson

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Lakeview Cozy Cottage w/ 2 bedrooms & 1 bath

Start your morning with a fresh cup of coffee while watching the sunrise over the lake. Less than 1 hour from NYC, enjoy your staycation in this updated cottage in a peaceful lake community. Relax on the patio while enjoying the tranquility of nature and creating wonderful memories. Less than 5 minute drive to swimming, watersports, boating, farms, wineries, and lots of great restaurants & bars. Less than 10 mins to Hopatcong State Park, 10 mins from Rockaway Mall, and 30 mins to Mountain Creek.

Guest favorite

A master bedroom features large double doors leading to a private balcony overlooking the lake. A spacious bed with a textured white coverlet is visible in the foreground. The scenic view of the water and distant landscape can be enjoyed from the room.

Home in Hopatcong

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Luxe Experience Hopatcong LakeView

Welcome to our breathtaking lake view Airbnb, a stylish 2,600 sq ft retreat perfect for families and friends. Enjoy separate living areas, flat-screen TVs, a cozy wood fireplace, & pellet fireplace for warm evenings. Fun awaits w/a multi-game table & karaoke setup. A fully equipped kitchen leads to a spacious deck w/ stunning lake views. Desks & high-speed internet make remote work possible. Close to waterfront restaurants, shopping, & Hopatcong State Park. Perfect home for creating memories! 😊

Top guest favorite

A serene landscape features a large farmhouse set against a clear blue sky, with lush green grass surrounding a tranquil pond. Reflections of trees and the farmhouse are visible on the water's surface, complemented by a rustic barn in the background.

Home in Far Hills

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 87 reviews

Pickle Farm

Meticulously maintained private quiet gated enclave featuring a restored vintage 1800 historic farmhouse and pastoral land- 1 hour from NYC. Registered movie and film location, featured in movies, commercials, documentaries and photo shoots. Agent handles negotiations, Prices vary. Minutes to train, Hamilton Farm, Pingry , Gill & Willow schools. Willowwood Arboretum, Bamboo Brook, Natirar, Several well known golf courses surrounded by hundreds of acres of preserved open land and state park.

Top guest favorite

A tranquil garden scene features a stone fountain surrounded by lush greenery and a variety of colorful flowers. The arrangement includes pink geraniums, purple blooms, and vibrant foliage, creating a peaceful outdoor space with a mix of textures and colors.

Loft in West Orange

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 271 reviews

*Fragrance Free-In Top 1% on Airbnb-Cozy-Near NYC

**The studio is private, entry is not private, it is through the hosts living area** (You will have your own keys and you and are free to come and go as early or late as you like) ***BEFORE REQUESTING TO BOOK*** please read my entire listing *As you can see by my photos, ratings and reviews this really is a lovely place to stay, I am an attentive host, but please indulge me and read on.... * I keep a fragrance free house and require that guests be fragrance free.

Superhost

A spacious living and dining area features a blend of comfortable furniture, including a green armchair and a sleek table with chairs. A small decorative rug lies on the tiled floor, and a television is mounted on the wall. Natural light enters through a window, accentuating the room's warmth.

Guest suite in Hackettstown

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

Full Apartment near Hackettstown

Enjoy this private apartment connected to an 18th century stone house. It comes furnished with 1 1/2 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, large living/dining room, and one bedroom with closet and a queen sized bed. We are located in the beautiful highlands of northwest NJ--about 60 miles from Lincoln Tunnel and 75 miles from Philadelphia. Nearby are historical sights, great hiking and skiing areas restaurants, brew pubs, and a train station. Private parking provided next to entrance.

Top guest favorite

An inviting dock extends over the calm waters of the lake, with a wooden adirondack chair positioned for optimal views. A chilled beverage rests on the table nearby, with lush greenery and residential homes lining the opposite shore under a partly cloudy sky.

Home in Hopatcong

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Lakeside Home w/Lake Access, Dock & Water Views!

Enjoy amazing lake views from this absolutely gorgeous, modern lakeside home! Perfect destination for a mini-vacation, couples retreat or a family getaway. "La Vida Lago" is a completely furnished, single family lakeside ranch home featuring 2 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, deck, patio, private lake access and dock directly across the street. The property is perched up from the road and nestled into the mountain surrounded by trees! The ideal environment to connect w/nature, yourself and loved ones.

Top guest favorite

A serene outdoor area features two sets of blue Adirondack chairs positioned beside a gently flowing waterfall. Lush greenery surrounds the private pond, with a distant view of a white shed and the glistening pool, creating a peaceful retreat in nature.

Home in Mendham Township

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Historic Cottage with Private Pond & Pool

Step back in time to 1760 with the old world charm of Colonial America. Pre-dating our country by over a decade, our beautifully renovated 260+ year old home sits on 5 acres with a detached studio and 2 separate water features. Experience the private pond teeming with koi, frogs, and other wildlife or take a dip in the refreshing pool just steps away. Whether you seek a relaxing getaway or a portal back to the days of our founding fathers, our historic home promises the ideal retreat.

Top guest favorite

A serene outdoor space is outlined by stepping stones leading to the water’s edge. Comfortable seating is arranged around a fire pit, with dining furniture positioned nearby. Kayaks rest along the dock, with a clear view of the lake and surrounding landscape.

Home in Jefferson

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

Adorable quiet & cozy lakefront studio on dead end

Welcome to your next getaway! This charming, lakefront studio views will wow you. Let the sound of the lake be your next therapy session! Perfect for a weekend getaway or long-term stay. Bring your work or leave it all behind. House sits at the end of a dead end street uninterrupted by traffic. Short trip from NYC. Enjoy access to kayaks, fishing, gazebo, BBQ & equipped with kitchen essentials. Great eateries & close to hiking trails or shopping centers. You won't be disappointed

Guest favorite

A spacious wooden deck overlooks the lake, featuring a round table surrounded by orange chairs and shaded by a large umbrella. A soft area rug adds color to the space, providing a scenic setting for outdoor relaxation and dining.

Apartment in Hopatcong

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

C’est La Vie Lakeview W/Optional Boat Slip

Unit #1 Welcome to our lakeside retreat on Lake Hopatcong! This charming 1-bedroom apartment offers the perfect escape to a warm cottage with direct access to the sparkling waters of New Jersey's largest lake via the shared dock and dedicated slip. Unwind in the spacious bedroom which features a king bed & futon, or relax in the inviting living room on the open-up sofa. Start your day with breathtaking lake views and end it with a mesmerizing sunset from the dock. Permit#99815

Superhost

The open-concept living area features a modern kitchen equipped with stainless steel appliances and a central island with bar seating. A cozy seating arrangement invites relaxation, while decorative light fixtures enhance the ambiance. Laundry appliances are discreetly integrated into the cabinetry for convenience.

Home in Hopatcong

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Fireworks from the Porch!

Welcome to the largest lake in NJ! Freshly renovated with 4 beds & sleeper sofa, perfect for families and friends. Enjoy multi level comfort. Fun awaits with Kayaks, Paddle Boards, and space for your Boat/Jetski! A fully equipped kitchen leads to a spacious deck with weber grill & 4 burner griddle! Stunning sunset views &High-speed internet make remote work a breeze. Close to waterfront restaurants, shopping, & Hopatcong State Park.

Superhost

A spacious sleeping area features a neutral-colored bedspread atop a comfortable bed. The room is designed with light wood flooring, complemented by a bedside table and a minimalist dresser. A kitchenette with modern cabinetry and appliances is visible in the background.

Guest suite in Livingston

4.74 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Modern & luxury studio

This stylish and peaceful studio with its bathroom & kitchen and this property is 5 mins from Livingston mall, short hills mall and St Barnabas hospital. This place is suitable for healthcare professional travelers and if also just visiting the town. It is 10 mins from turtle back zoo and south mountain reservation and other shopping complexes. Note: Shared laundry space btw host and airbnb guest

Top guest favorite

Two mini donkeys graze peacefully in a grassy field, surrounded by trees with green foliage. A blue sky with a few scattered clouds provides a bright backdrop, and wooden fences outline the pasture, enhancing the farm-like setting.

Farm stay in Frenchtown

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 568 reviews

DREAM BIG! Rustic Tiny Home on Hidden Farmlet

Ready to kick back and relax from your busy life? Have you ever dreamed of waking up on a farm? Then our charming 170 sq ft tiny home is perfect for you! Situated on 10 picturesque acres, and home to one horse, two mini donkeys, two goats, a pig, twenty-two chickens, five ducks, a goose and, of course, a barn cat. This is the place to disconnect and get back to nature!