Vacation rentals in Holley

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Holley

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favorite

A one-story cottage is set near Lake Ontario, framed by lush greenery. Wooden decking leads to the entrance, while a grassy area extends towards the water's edge. The structure features large windows and a simple exterior. A vehicle is parked nearby, highlighting the accessible location.

Home in Kendall

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

The Love Shack

Nice & cozy Winter get a way with lower rates! Lake front 2 bedroom plus pull out couch with hot tub overlooking beautiful Lake Ontario. This recently remodeled 2 bedrooms on Lake Ontario is 20 miles west of Rochester, NY. 2 king beds, pull out couch,6 man hot tub, cable TV, Netflix, HBO, HULU, TVs in both bedrooms and living room, stereo, full kitchen all the pans and silver, all fresh clean bedding, outdoor shower (full bath too) towels, paper goods, books, bikes, board games, ro ck painting,

FamilyValueBeach

Guest favorite

The spacious kitchen features modern stainless-steel appliances, including a refrigerator and oven. Ample cabinetry and a large countertop provide plenty of space for meal preparation. A window allows natural light to brighten the area, highlighting the rich wood flooring.

Home in Waterport

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Beautiful Home Minutes From Lake Ontario fishing

Freshly remodeled, fully furnished, four bedroom home in a country setting close to Lake Ontario's famed fishing locations. Two story, open floor plan. First floor Kitchen, living room, dining room, bathroom, three bedrooms. One bedroom upstairs. Private large country yard. Only minutes away from Lake Ontario, Lake Alice, and the Oak Orchard River. Great for fishing, boating, kayaking, leisure. Ring video security sys. We are located half way between Rochester and Buffalo/Niagara Falls.

LocationFamilySleep quality

Guest favorite

A well-maintained outdoor area features a circular stone fire pit surrounded by red Adirondack chairs. Lush greenery and colorful plants provide a natural backdrop to the spacious home, which includes a multi-level deck overlooking the inviting landscape.

Home in Batavia

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

Spacious w/ lake access, hot tub, rec & movie room

Come enjoy this spacious home with activities to keep you busy year round. Spend the day on this quiet lake swimming, fishing or paddle boarding off the private dock. Come back to the house to relax in the 8 person hot tub, have a drink at the bar while playing a game of pool, watch a movie in your own personal theater or curl up and read in front of one of three fireplaces. Nearby attractions include: Golf, Batavia Muckdogs Baseball, Batavia Downs Casino, Six Flags and Letchworth State Park.

LocationFamilyBathroom

Guest favorite

A lush garden is displayed with a variety of colorful flowering plants, bordered by a circular lawn. Towering evergreen and deciduous trees provide shade and greenery, while a distant car is visible along the gravel path, contributing to the rural setting.

Home in Albion

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

Little Lake Farm House

* Beginning 9/2026, AirBnB is transferring their service fees to the host payout; forcing our per night fee rates to change should you notice the increase. 10 mi from Pt Breeze, NY for fishing; circular driveway for easy boat towing. Close to: Batavia Downs, both Niagara & Finger Lakes Wine Trail & Erie Canal. SUNY Brockport, Genesee Community College; 45 mins to Rochester & Buffalo, 45 mins to Darien Lake, slightly over an hr to Niagara Falls. Less than 1/4 mi from the Erie Canal Towpath.

ValueFamilyCheckout

Top guest favorite

A group of alpacas stands close to a fence, showcasing a variety of colors including black, white, brown, and beige. Their friendly faces and fluffy coats are highlighted, with a rustic building visible in the background among the greenery of the farm.

Farm stay in Brockport

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Cabin at SanGer-La Alpacas

Welcome to The Cabin @ SanGer-La Alpacas, a working alpaca farm owned and operated by Nancy & Kris Sanger. In addition to the wooded Adirondack Park setting, you can learn about alpacas, their care and their wonderful fiber, or just relax and imagine you're in the most peaceful place on earth. You'll meet Lucas and Cody our 2 dogs and our cat Gandalf (the Grey). All friendly. The Cabin is a completely separate 400 sq ft, 1 bedroom & full bath. Parking in front of Cabin. Note: No TV.

ValueLocationTV

Top guest favorite

The living area features a vibrant woven area rug at center, surrounded by a yellow sofa and two armchairs. A lamp provides soft lighting next to the sofa, while a bookcase and a door lead to the bedroom. Floral wallpaper adds a classic decorative touch.

Apartment in Brockport

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 237 reviews

Brockport Village 1-bedroom yds. from Erie Canal.

Thoughtful one bedroom apartment on second floor of historic home. Centrally located in heart of old Brockport, and just 100 yards from the historic Erie Canal. Close to restaurants, laundry, art gallery and Erie Canal Welcome Center. Apartment has separate entrance. owned by cyclists who have cycled Erie Canal many times. All amenities to make your stay enjoyable, we'll help with bikes & repairs. Shuttle services & bike rentals. (fully equipped Trek hybrids for rent by request.)

ValueLocationLaundry

Top guest favorite

The tranquil lakeside view showcases gentle ripples on the water under a pastel sky at dusk. Lush greenery and seating options are visible along the serene shoreline, complemented by patios and gardens that enhance the natural beauty of the surroundings.

Home in Rochester

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 163 reviews

True North Lakeside Retreat Autumn specials!

75’ Lakefront | 6 Outdoor Zones | Wellness Nook Relax at True North, a 2,500 sq ft sanctuary with 6 outdoor living spaces (4 patios/2 decks). ✔ Host: Custom beverage bar with 50lb ice maker & wine fridge (BYOB). Enjoy the granite kitchen & wood-fired pizza oven. ✔ Wellness: CLIMBR gym with lake views, canoe/life vests, & sandy beach access (0.1 mi). ✔ Retreat: Dual Master Suites with private balconies. Spot Bald Eagles & swans from the fire pit. High-end comfort for 8!

ValueFamilyAccess

Guest favorite

A spacious three-bedroom home is showcased, featuring a light-colored exterior with two prominent entrances. The well-maintained lawn is bordered by trees, providing a natural setting. A paved driveway is visible, offering ample parking space. Red chairs are positioned invitingly on the porch.

Home in Brockport

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Brockport's Home away from Home!

Welcome to our Home! This is a 3-bedroom home in the heart of Brockport, Unpack and unwind in a comfortable space. Our fully equipped kitchen caters to all your cooking needs, while the laundry room offers convenient washing and drying facilities. Enjoy high-speed internet and Wi-Fi, and don’t forget to enjoy a walk on the canal just minutes away, explore the Village of Brockport for shopping, dining, and scenic walks along the Erie Canal. Book your stay today!

LocationValueKitchen

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area is featured, showcasing a plush sectional sofa and a wooden coffee table. Two vintage oars are mounted on the wall, enhancing the rustic charm. A stand lamp and a small wooden chair complement the space, which is illuminated by natural light through nearby windows.

Apartment in Albion

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 192 reviews

Lagom Living Not too little ~ Not too Much

Our Airbnb is an entire two-bedroom apartment in an 1800s home in Albion, NY. You’ll have plenty of room to settle in and stretch out here. We can sleep five people in one queen, one double bed and a couch. The comfortable living room is stocked with board games and our full kitchen has all the appliances and kitchenware you need to make your own meals. With onsite parking, a private entrance, and washer and dryer, you can really make yourself at home.

FamilyLocationQuiet

Top guest favorite

The living room features a comfortable sofa and a wooden dining table with chairs, illuminated by natural light from a large window. A neutral color palette is complemented by sliding barn-style wood accents on one wall. A television is mounted on the opposite wall.

Home in Kendall

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Ontario Vista Countryside Home

Welcome to the Ontario Vista - a countryside home located in Kendall, NY! This 1878 farm house is a side-by-side duplex, with the host family living on one side. You will have full access to the other side, with a private parking area and entry door. From the upper story, you can see Lake Ontario, which is only a mile north of the home. *We welcome fishermen! We are located only 4 minutes from Bald Eagle Marine and 10 minutes from Point Breeze!*

ValueLocationQuiet

Guest favorite

The kitchen features exposed brick walls complemented by dark cabinetry and a spacious island. A chandelier illuminates the area, highlighting stainless steel appliances and a sink. Two large windows allow natural light to fill the space, creating a warm ambiance.

Apartment in Albion

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 187 reviews

Bunked on Bank

Welcome to Bunked on Bank! This second story loft style apartment is centrally located between Rochester and Buffalo. Conveniently located near Niagara Falls, Letchworth State Park and Lake Ontario for plenty of day trips during your stay. This apartment offers two queen size beds and two twin beds. The bathroom includes a large soaking tub along with a stand-up shower. Full kitchen with all the amenities. Free parking on site. WiFi included.

LocationFamilyIndoor spaces

Superhost

A bright living space is presented with large windows allowing natural light to fill the room. Light-colored curtains frame the windows, while a spacious bed occupies one side. A small dining table with chairs and a cozy seating area are visible, enhancing the comfortable atmosphere.

Guest suite in Albion

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

The Tillman Room at the Fairhaven Inn

Experience luxury in The Tillman Room #1 at The Fair Haven Inn. This two-bedroom suite comfortably sleeps six and features a bright living space, two double beds on the main floor, and two twin beds in the upper-level sanctuary. The suite includes a full bathroom with handicap accessibility, fresh linens, Wi-Fi, a flat-screen TV, and a kitchenette with microwave, micro fridge and coffee pot. Ideal for wedding parties and family getaways.

ValueFamilyHeating