Vacation rentals in Benton

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Benton

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

The living room features a comfortable seating arrangement with a leather sofa and a rocking chair. A stone fireplace is centered on the wall, above which a television is mounted. Soft natural light filters through sheer curtains, creating a warm ambiance.

Home in Penn Yan

Experience Finger Lakes at The Best of Both Abode

Nestled on the main road just inside Penn Yan, Best of Both Abode is a split-level home in the heart of the Finger Lakes. About 30 minutes to Watkins Glen, Geneva, or Canandaigua. Dozens of wineries, amazing state parks, beautiful lakes, waterfalls, farms, breweries, shopping, and so much more all close by. The perfect place for couples, families, groups of friends, and traveling workers. Enjoy our spacious lawn and deck, or cozy up inside. We invite you to come make yourself feel at home.

FamilyLocationBeach

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 255 reviews

Top guest favorite

A serene lake view is framed by window panes, showcasing a colorful sunset reflected on the water. Outdoor seating is visible on the deck, with potted plants adding a touch of greenery. The atmosphere appears peaceful and inviting.

Cottage in Penn Yan

On Lake, Stunning Views, Sunrises, Pet Friendly!

We are right on the lake! The view is amazing and the atmosphere is serene and relaxing. Conveniently located. The fully stocked cottage is comfortable and offers a homey feel - clean, updated. Gas fireplace offers additional warmth & ambiance. Fabulous deck with amazing views! Dock/beach area with fire pit. Master bedroom - watch the sunrise right from bed! Kitchen is fully stocked, seating for 6, laundry and two bathrooms. Plenty of parking and a lovely private yard. Linens included

FamilyLocationLaundry

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 262 reviews

Top guest favorite

A single-story cottage is set among lush greenery, featuring a welcoming front entrance with a blue door. The well-maintained yard includes vibrant shrubs and trees surrounding the home, with a large garage visible to the right, adding to the property’s charm.

Cottage in Penn Yan

Blūm on the Hill Cottage in the Finger Lakes

Enjoy a peaceful stay in our cottage located just over 2 miles from the quaint village of Penn Yan on Keuka Lake. Relax in the newly renovated 2 bedroom, 2 full bath home with a fully equipped dine-in kitchen, spacious living room with electric fireplace, and dining room. Enjoy the fresh air on the back deck with Keuka Lake peeking through the trees. Take in the sites of the many trails, vineyards, breweries and state parks in the area during your stay. So just relax, you're on lake time.

FamilyLocationParking

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Penn Yan

Retreat w/ panoramic lake views on wine trail!

Gather your crew & unwind at this peaceful, centrally located retreat - perfect for wine weekends, brewery tours & cozy nights in. With equal-sized bedrooms, a clean, stocked kitchen & a spacious deck made for group hangs, it has everything you need! ⭐ "Perfect home base for our wine trip - equal rooms, plenty of space, and so peaceful after a full day out!" ✓ Centrally located for wine & brewery hopping ✓ Equal-sized rooms & open group-friendly layout ✓ Deck for coffee, cocktails

FamilyLocationBiking

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 204 reviews

Top guest favorite

An outdoor deck is shown with a wooden frame, featuring a glass-top table surrounded by six beige chairs. The scenic view of lush greenery and distant hills is visible in the background under a clear blue sky.

Home in Penn Yan

Guyanoga Getaway ~Peaceful~ 5 min. to Keuka Lake

Nature lovers! Ideal vacation home for a small family, couples getaway or girls/guys weekend. Nestled in the woods, this secluded cabin-like ranch home has a beautiful view of the Guyanoga Valley. Located only 2 miles from Keuka Lake State Park, and a short drive to Penn Yan, this 3-bedroom has all of the comforts of home. Enjoy a cup of coffee on the deck. Minutes away from the lake; breathtaking scenery, wineries and craft breweries. You'll find small-town hospitality in Yates County.

LocationFamilyParks

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 220 reviews

Top guest favorite

A wooden dock extends into the calm waters of Seneca Lake, featuring a ladder for easy access. Two chairs are positioned on the dock, inviting relaxation. The overcast sky reflects softly on the water's surface, creating a serene atmosphere.

Home in Penn Yan

Waterfront Escape in Seneca Lake Wine Country

A true refuge... peaceful, quiet and majestic. The house is right on the lake with gorgeous views of Seneca lake. Large windows overlook the lake from the living room and front bedroom. Single family detached home situated on a dead-end street limited to local traffic, this 2 bedroom, 1 1/2 bathroom year-round home will provide you with everything you need for your next getaway. The house is perfect for 2 couples or a family of four. Bonus room above the boathouse with a pull out sofa.

FamilyLocationBathroom

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 282 reviews

Top guest favorite

A charming home is set on a lush green lawn surrounded by trees showcasing autumn foliage. The single-story structure has a covered porch and is complemented by a spacious driveway leading to a two-car garage.

Home in Penn Yan

Spacious Keuka Lake Gem, BBQ, Firepit, Gameroom

High-end Finger Lakes retreat! This spacious, open-concept home blends elegant design with ultimate comfort. Newly furnished, each room invites relaxation—large windows and hardwood floors create a bright, welcoming vibe. The expansive game room features foosball, ping pong, a bar, plus cozy nooks for reading or remote work. Spend evenings around the outdoor firepit, utilize the on-site EV charger, and explore Penn Yan’s village, Keuka Lake, Wineries and Hiking Trails just minutes away.

LocationFamilyOutdoor spaces

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 37 reviews

Top guest favorite

Apartment in Penn Yan

Route 54 Relic in Penn Yan.

1880's home now 3 units. Built when steam ships still piloted Keuka. Penn Yan can be accessed by sidewalk from here (approx 1 mile to center), steps from Red Jacket Park at Keuka Lake on one side, Seasons on Keuka Lake on the other. Close to Keuka Outlet Trail, on the Keuka Lake wine trail, and between Main Deck restaurant and Rt 54 (WE ARE NOT WATERFRONT). There is plenty to do between shopping in Penn Yan, hiking the Outlet, or going on a wine tour around Keuka and/or Seneca Lake.

ValueLocationWalkability

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 138 reviews

Top guest favorite

The kitchen features modern appliances, including a stainless steel fridge and oven, set against light-colored cabinetry and a mosaic backsplash. A spacious island with bar seating offers additional workspace. Natural light filters through large windows, illuminating the open layout.

Farm stay in Penn Yan

Modern, bright & calm 1 BR / 1 bath farm retreat

Let the calm, quiet beauty of New York’s Finger Lakes region renew you at this modern and bright on-farm escape right on the Seneca Lake Wine Trail. Enjoy our outdoor space and the comfort of our private second floor which features natural lighting, a private entrance, self check-in, marble countertops, tile throughout, a custom bathroom, in-floor radiant heat, WiFi, no TV and a spacious deck overlooking Black Squirrel Farms, a black walnut growing and processing operation.

ValueLocationWifi

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 275 reviews

Top guest favorite

The kitchen area features modern appliances, including a refrigerator and microwave, alongside a granite countertop. A wooden shelf displays dishware and cooking utensils, while a window allows natural light to fill the space. The rustic wood ceiling complements the white shiplap walls.

Guesthouse in Penn Yan

Quiet Guesthouse near Keuka Lake and Penn Yan!

Welcome to our cozy guesthouse! Nestled in the Fingerlakes Region of New York, it's the perfect place to rest after a day spent exploring our beautiful lakes, wineries, hiking trails, and so much more. Our guesthouse is located 2 minutes away from the Keuka Outlet Trail, 5 minutes from Penn Yan and Keuka Lake, and just minutes away from several local wineries. In the winter, we love to visit Bristol Mountain Ski Resort, 45 minutes from us! We can't wait to host you!

FamilyValueView

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Top guest favorite

A serene lakeside home is positioned on a gently sloping green hill, featuring a spacious deck that overlooks the water. Surrounding trees provide a natural setting. The structure showcases large windows, allowing for abundant natural light and expansive views of the lake.

Home in Penn Yan

Beautiful Keuka Lake home close to Penn Yan.

Welcome to Keuka lake in this beautiful home that boasts 3 master suites. The living room has a panoramic view of Keuka Lake. There is a deck off the top floor and a patio off the first floor to sit and enjoy the lake view as well. From the downstairs patio you are only a few steps to the beach. At the end of the dock the lake is only 3 feet deep so it’s excellent for swimming. Everything in this house is new and very clean. We are a mile from downtown Penn Yan.

ValueFamilyAmenities

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 291 reviews

Top guest favorite

A bright living area features floor-to-ceiling windows offering views of the lake. A round dining table accommodates four, while a cozy seating arrangement includes a gray couch and two chairs. Natural light floods the space, enhanced by high vaulted ceilings and wood accents.

Home in Jerusalem

The Best Getaway on the Keuka Lake Wine Trail

Welcome to our “tree house" paradise on Keuka lake! It's one of the most unique cottages on Keuka. Our lake home promises you an unforgettable vacation on Keuka, with unparalleled views of the lake. Spend your days lounging on the beach, swimming, fishing, kayaking or tasting the local wine & cheese before you wind down on the hammock, taking in breathtaking views among the Keuka treetops. End each night with memories (and S’mores!) ‘round the campfire!

FamilyLocationView

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews